Real estate

Shares in an apartment: how to determine, divide and challenge a will for an apartment

A will for an apartment can be challenged only through court and only on grounds relating to the procedure for drawing up, signing or certifying the document, or to the testator's condition at the time it was made. Shares in an apartment remain ideal parts of the right, not metres on a floor plan, and confusion between these concepts hinders both division and dispute.

Division of shares in an apartment between owners

You own an apartment together with someone — a former spouse, relatives, other heirs. Or you are about to buy a share, gift it, or allocate it to a child. The documents say "1/4" or "1/2", but how many square metres that is, whether you can live there, and how to dispose of it — is unclear. Mistakes begin with the everyday notion of a share as a "room" or a "part of an apartment".

In reality, a share is an ideal part in the right of common ownership, not a physical piece of floor area. Hence the confusion around partition, disposal, and the pre-emptive right of the other owners. Below — how to determine shares, when a notary is needed, how to divide an apartment in a divorce and between heirs, and how to challenge a will for an apartment if the document raises doubts.

How shares in an apartment are determined: square meters, ideal parts, and what this means in practice

A share in an apartment is an ideal part in the right of common ownership, not specific square meters. The size of the share is confirmed by a title document: a sale and purchase agreement, a certificate of inheritance, a court decision, or a partition agreement. The owner may use the entire apartment, but their actual possibilities depend on the consent of the other co-owners.

Confusion arises when a person believes that a specific room or square meters belong to them. In practice, this leads to disputes: one owner occupies the largest room, citing the size of their share, while another demands that the premises be vacated. A share gives the right to participate in use, and the procedure for access is established by agreement or by a court.

An ideal part can also exist "in kind" — when a specific premises is recorded in the documents. This is possible if the apartment is in fact divided among the owners and this is reflected in the title papers. Without such formalization, the room remains common, no matter how many square meters correspond to it by calculation.

  • Check the document: it states either an ideal part (for example, 1/2) or a specific premises.
  • Cross-check with the technical passport: the layout and area help to understand which part of the apartment the owner occupies.
  • Record the procedure for use: a written agreement with the other co-owners reduces the risk of a dispute.
  • Assess the prospects for allocation: without the consent of the others, the matter is resolved through a court.

Transfer of a share in an apartment without a notary and sale of a share: when a transaction can be completed without certification

A notary is not required if all owners transfer their shares simultaneously under a single contract — in this case, the shares cease to exist as separate objects, and the subject of the transaction becomes the apartment as a whole. A simple written form is also suitable when the entire property is transferred at once. As soon as one owner disposes of their share, the transaction must be certified by a notary.

Buying a share in an apartment through a notary reduces risks: the notary verifies the seller's legal capacity, the absence of arrests and hidden encumbrances, and compliance with the preemptive right of other owners. Without certification, the buyer risks facing a challenge to the transaction, a demand to transfer the rights to another owner, or the contract being declared invalid.

Practical advice: before signing, request written waivers from the other owners confirming they will not purchase the share — this document will be useful both to the notary and in court if someone tries to challenge the transaction.

  • Check the list of owners: the extract will show all owners and the size of their shares.
  • Collect waivers: written confirmations that the others will not exercise their preemptive right.
  • Verify encumbrances: arrests and liens must be removed before the transaction, not after.
  • Determine the format: a single contract for all shares — no notary; a separate share — go to a notary.

Gifting a share in an apartment: notary, contract and transactions without certification

Notarial certification is required when the donor disposes of a share in common property: without certification, such a transaction is invalid. Parties sometimes sign a contract for gifting a share in an apartment without a notary to save money — but registration in the legal cadastre will not go through, and the title record will remain with the donor.

If you are gifting the entire apartment or several shares at once, certification may not be required. But when gifting a share in an apartment without a notary, the risk of contestability is higher: the transaction may be declared invalid, and the donee will be left without rights. The notary verifies the legal capacity of the parties and the absence of arrests — the notary sees this data through their own channels, and separate certificates are usually not needed.

  • Simple written form: suitable when certification is not mandatory — for example, when gifting an entire apartment.
  • Notarized contract: required when disposing of a share in common property.
  • Spouse's consent: required if the property was acquired during marriage.
  • Title document: confirms that the apartment belongs to the donor.
  • Technical passport: shows the characteristics of the property and the composition of the premises.

Practical tip: before signing, check how the share is recorded in the legal cadastre — a discrepancy in the description of the property delays the paperwork.

Sale and purchase of a share in an apartment between relatives and the pre-emptive right of other owners

You can sell a share to a relative, but only after the other co-owners have waived it in writing: their pre-emptive right is enshrined in the Civil Code. A notice is sent to each participant in common ownership stating the object and the price, and then you wait for a waiver or silence within the established period. Without such notice, the transaction can be challenged, and the buyer — even a close person — risks losing both the money and the share.

If a co-owner expresses a desire to buy the share themselves, the seller is obliged to sell it to them on the same terms: you cannot change the buyer or lower the price "for a relative." It is better to record the waiver in writing or notarially — this protects both parties. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so support for such a transaction does not accumulate additional charges along the way.

  • Compile a list of co-owners with current addresses and contacts
  • Describe the object and price of the future transaction in the notice
  • Keep evidence of sending and receiving the notice
  • Obtain waivers or wait for the response period to expire
  • Execute the contract with a notary after collecting the waivers
Sale and purchase of a share between relatives: what to consider
Situation What is needed Risk without it
A relative buys the share Notify the other co-owners The transaction may be challenged
A co-owner wishes to buy Sell to them on the same terms Claim for transfer of rights
Waiver by a co-owner Written or notarial waiver Dispute over the deadline and fact of waiver
Sale to an outsider Waiver by all co-owners Invalidity of the sale

The response period and procedure are clarified depending on the situation.

Division of an apartment in divorce when there are minor children

Division of an apartment in divorce when minor children are present follows the general rules for division of jointly acquired property, but with an adjustment for which parent the children will stay with and whether they will keep their usual living conditions. An apartment acquired during the marriage is considered common property, and the spouses' shares are, as a general rule, equal. Housing registered in one spouse's name may still be included in the division unless it is proven that it was purchased with personal funds or received as a gift or by inheritance.

The interests of the children do not directly turn them into owners of a share upon division; however, the court may depart from equal shares and increase the portion of the spouse with whom the children remain. The grounds are usually: the child living with that parent after the divorce, that parent having no other housing, and the use of targeted child payments and housing payments in purchasing the apartment. To confirm this, a birth certificate, a certificate of family composition and place of residence, and documents on income and on payment for the apartment are required.

Practical advice: gather the supporting evidence in advance — before filing the claim, not during the dispute. A certificate of the child's place of residence, an account statement showing the movement of funds for the purchase, and documents on child payments show the court the full picture, whereas individual papers brought to the hearing are less convincing. And one more consequence: if the apartment is registered in one spouse's name, the other should raise the documents on the origin of the funds in advance — this determines whether the property will be included in the division at all.

Division of an apartment among heirs and allocation of a share in kind or compensation

Division of an apartment by inheritance ends either with allocation of a share in kind or with monetary compensation — the court awards nothing else. Heirs receive the housing in common shared ownership, and they divide ideal shares, not rooms. They may dispose of the property by an agreement with notarial certification or through court when they fail to reach an agreement. At Bonafacto, the practice's notary executes such an agreement, while the lawyers prepare documents for court litigation.

Allocation in kind is possible if the heir receives an isolated premises with a separate entrance, kitchen and bathroom. Otherwise, recovery of monetary compensation is discussed. Before filing a claim, the following is checked:

  • Technical passport and floor plan: whether there is an isolated room and a separate entrance
  • Expert opinion: whether the layout allows redevelopment and re-equipment
  • Information about other owners: who actually lives in the apartment and pays for it
  • Substantial interest: evidence of its presence or absence in the heir
  • Options for exchange or buyout of the share: what terms you are willing to discuss
How the division dispute ends
Situation What is awarded When it is realistic
An isolated premises exists Allocation of a share in kind A house or apartment with the possibility of a separate entrance and utilities
Allocation is impossible, the share is small Monetary compensation The heir does not live in the apartment and does not need the square meters
Exchange is possible Sale with division of the proceeds All owners agree to the sale
Shares are disproportionate to the area Compensation with an additional payment One heir receives more square meters than his share

The outcome depends on the layout and the position of each owner, not only on the size of the share.

Can a will for a share in an apartment be challenged and how is it done

A will for a share in an apartment can be challenged, but not out of disagreement with the testator's will — only on strictly defined grounds. The dispute concerns whether the testator, at the time of signing, did not understand the meaning of their actions or could not control them, whether they were pressured, misled, or taken advantage of while in a helpless state. A separate ground is a violation of the form of the will and the procedure for its certification, as well as the situation where only a share is bequeathed but the rights of heirs to a compulsory share are infringed.

Who can challenge a will for an apartment — heirs by law or under another will whose interests are infringed, as well as their representatives under a power of attorney. In court, it is not the mere fact of disagreement that is proven, but a defect of will or form, so evidence is gathered in advance. The heavy part of the work — analysing the inheritance file and building the position — is taken on by Bonafacto lawyers before the claim is filed, so that by the time of the hearing the documents are already collected.

What becomes the evidence base:

  • Extracts from the medical record and conclusions on the testator's diagnoses
  • Conclusion of a post-mortem psychological and psychiatric examination
  • Testimony of witnesses, the notary, doctors and neighbours
  • The text of the will and documents from the inheritance file

How the claim is prepared: sequence of steps and typical mistakes

A claim to challenge a will does not start with the court but with the inheritance file: it is there that you can see how the will was executed, who was present at certification and what documents on the testator's condition already exist. Next, medical documentation is collected, information is requested from the notary, and only after that is the ground formulated — defect of will or violation of form. The procedure for going to court and the time limits are clarified for the specific situation, since they depend on when the heir learned that their right had been infringed.

The practical part is a checklist worth going through before filing:

  • Inheritance file: request copies of the will and related documents from the notary.
  • Medical documents: extracts, diagnoses, information on medication taken as of the date of signing.
  • Witnesses: record in advance who can confirm what — oral agreements do not work in court.
  • Examination: think through which questions to put to the expert — the conclusion depends on how they are worded.
  • Compulsory share: check whether the rights of heirs whom the law guarantees a part of the inheritance have been infringed.

The mistake that nullifies all efforts is building a position on emotions: "he didn't want it this way", "the heir is unfair". The court assesses documents and conclusions, not resentment. The second typical mistake is delaying the collection of medical papers: some of them are lost over time or become unavailable. The third is filing a claim without checking whether there is any ground at all, and getting a refusal that then hinders building a new position. When certifying a will, the notary does not require the testator to prove title to the property, so the dispute over a share is not about what the testator owned but about the procedure itself and the testator's condition.

A share in an apartment is not equal to metres: until you have carried out an allocation in kind or agreed on the procedure for use, you own an ideal part of the right to the entire apartment. Before signing any transaction with a share, check whether the other owners have a pre-emptive right and whether notarial certification is required. Natalya Lukyanova

Madina Issatayeva

Grounds to contest a will: what is proven in court

The reasons for which a will is contested fall into two groups: defects of will (the testator did not understand the meaning of his actions, acted under pressure or in error, was in a helpless state) and defects of form (the procedure for drawing up, signing or certifying the document was violated). A separate ground is the infringement of the compulsory share: the right to it belongs to minor or incapacitated children of the testator, and to the incapacitated spouse and parents (Article 1069, paragraph 1 of the Civil Code of the RK). A will may be declared invalid on the claim of a person for whom this has property consequences, as a result of violation of the procedure for drawing up, signing and certifying the will (Article 1056, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code of the RK).

Evidence is selected for each ground. A defect of will is confirmed by medical documents on the testator's condition, an expert's opinion, witness testimony, correspondence; in a dispute over mental state, the court may order a forensic psychiatric examination (Article 325, part 2 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). A defect of form is proven by the text of the will itself, the notary's marks, and the absence of mandatory details. Infringement of the compulsory share is calculated from the portion of the property that would have been due to the heir without a will.

Practical advice: disagreement with the testator's will is not yet a ground for a claim. If a father left an apartment to one of his children, the others may disagree with this decision, but the court examines not the fairness of the choice, but defects of will or form. Bonafacto lawyers first study the documents and only then assess the prospects — this is fairer both for the client and for the strategy.

Time limit for contesting a will and the procedure for going to court

The time limit for contesting a will depends on the ground for the dispute: the law calculates it differently for a voidable will and for a void will, so the exact date from which time is counted is clarified based on the circumstances of the specific case. First, it is determined what exactly was violated — the procedure for drawing up, signing or certifying the document — and the calculation is built from that. An error in classifying the ground results in the claim being filed within the wrong time limit, and the court considers the matter without the applicant.

The procedure for going to court begins not with the claim, but with the documents. You need to collect the death certificate, documents for the apartment, the text of the will itself and information about the circle of heirs, then obtain from the notary information about the inheritance case — who opened it, which applications were received, whether a certificate has been issued. Without these data it is impossible either to confirm your interest or to formulate the claims.

  • Collect documents for the property and proof of kinship
  • Request information about the inheritance case from the notary
  • Prepare a claim stating the ground and the claims
  • File a motion for a post-mortem examination if the testator's condition is disputed
  • Go through the court proceedings and obtain a decision

Next, a statement of claim is prepared and filed with the court; during the proceedings an examination may be ordered, and the court assesses its conclusion on an equal footing with other evidence. Practical advice: do not delay going to court while the inheritance case is already open — this makes it easier to fix the composition of the heirs and to prevent the property from being distributed without your participation. If the ground and the time limit raise doubts, Bonafacto lawyers help review the documents and build the sequence of steps.

What to prepare before filing a claim: a document checklist

A claim concerning a will rests not on emotions but on written evidence, and it must be collected before the application goes to court. The basis of the evidence is the testator's medical documents: extracts from the medical record, conclusions on diagnoses, certificates about medication intake. To these are added the text of the will itself, the materials of the inheritance case and information about which of the heirs is declared and in what status.

Witnesses are considered separately — the notary, doctors, neighbours — and which circumstances each of them confirms. If the testator's condition is disputed, a post-mortem psychological and psychiatric examination is discussed in advance: without it, arguments about a defect of will remain unfounded. It is useful to draw up a list of claims straight away: to declare the will invalid, to determine the shares, to recognise the right to a mandatory share — the wording determines which documents will be needed. Having decided to contest a will in court, check in advance that each claim is supported by its own group of papers — otherwise part of the arguments will remain without support.

  • Medical documents: extracts from the medical record, diagnoses, prescriptions and certificates about medications
  • Text of the will: a copy with the notary's mark on its certification
  • Inheritance case: information about the heirs' applications and issued certificates
  • Confirmation of interest: documents on kinship or on rights under another will
  • Witnesses: who confirms which circumstances of signing

A typical mistake is to file a claim before at least a minimum of written evidence has been collected: the applicant spends time on the proceedings with nothing to support the position. The second mistake is to combine in one claim a dispute about the form of the will and a dispute about the testator's will, although they are proven by different documents. A well-thought-out procedure for collecting papers saves both time and nerves.

Challenging an inheritance under a will: what happens to the share after a court decision

If a court declares a will invalid, the property is distributed as if that document never existed: the statutory order of inheritance or a previously executed will applies. The shares are recalculated among the heirs, and the issued certificate of the right to inheritance no longer reflects the actual situation. The notary amends the inheritance file, and the record of the right to real estate requires correction — without it, the property cannot be disposed of.

Separately, it is worth checking whether the heir disposed of the share before the decision took effect: sold, gifted, or pledged it. If the transaction has already gone through, the question of its fate will have to be resolved, and here it matters how conscientiously the acquirer acted. A practical tip is to request up-to-date information on the rights to the property before and after the court, rather than relying on documents obtained when the inheritance was opened.

When the dispute concerns a will for a share in an apartment rather than the entire property, the redistribution affects only that part, but the procedure remains the same: first the court act, then an application to the notary, then registration of the changes. Challenging an inheritance under a will means achieving not only the invalidation of the document but also the actual return of the property to the lawful circle of heirs.

  • Obtain a certified copy of the court decision
  • Apply to the notary with an application to review the inheritance file
  • Check whether the share was alienated before the decision
  • Amend the information on the rights to real estate

What to prepare before applying to the notary

The package is assembled in advance: this reduces the risk that the inheritance file will "stall" at the stage of clarifications. You will need an identity document, the death certificate of the testator, documents confirming kinship, the title document for the apartment and the technical passport, as well as the court decision itself with a mark of entry into force. If the share has already been re-registered to another heir, documents on the rights to the property will be useful — they show which records will have to be corrected.

A typical mistake is to assume that the court decision by itself "returned" the share. Without applying to the notary and without updating the record of rights, the property cannot be disposed of: the buyer or the bank simply will not see you as the owner. The second mistake is to delay checking transactions made by the heir who received the share under the disputed will: the earlier the alienation is identified, the easier it is to build a position for the return of the property.

Notarial acts on inheritance can be arranged with a notary of the Bonafacto practice — in the same company where lawyers and advocates handle civil cases.

What to consider before a transaction or dispute over a share in an apartment

A share in an apartment is an ideal part of the right to the property, not specific square meters and not a room; exactly how many meters it corresponds to depends on an agreement among the co-owners or a court decision. Everything else follows from this: notarial certification depends on the subject matter of the transaction, not on who its parties are, so the mere fact that the buyer and seller are related changes nothing in itself.

The preemptive right of the other co-owners is checked before signing the contract — after the transaction it is too late to fix this. Division among heirs proceeds by agreement, and if no agreement is reached — through court, where the allocation of a share in kind or compensation is discussed. And can one simply disagree with the last will? No: disagreement is not a ground; what is needed are violations of the procedure for drafting, signing or certifying it, and evidence to support them.

  • Check what exactly is secured to you — part of the right or a specific premises
  • Clarify whether your transaction requires notarial certification
  • Collect written waivers from the co-owners before signing
  • For a dispute over a will, determine the ground and evidence in advance

Services on this topic

Housing lawyer Real estate lawyer Family lawyer

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
What is a share in an apartment — is it specific metres or part of a right?

A share in an apartment is an ideal part of the right of common ownership, not a physical piece of floor area or a specific room. The size of the share is confirmed by the title document: a sale and purchase agreement, a certificate of inheritance, a court decision or a division agreement. The owner has the right to use the entire apartment, but actual possibilities depend on the consent of the other co-owners. A specific premises is assigned only if this is reflected in the documents.

When can a transaction with a share be completed without a notary?

A notary is not required in the case where all owners alienate their parts simultaneously under a single agreement: the shares cease to exist as separate objects, and the subject of the transaction becomes the apartment as a whole. As soon as one owner disposes of their part, the transaction is certified by a notary. When a share in common right is gifted, the absence of certification makes the transaction invalid, and registration in the legal cadastre will not go through.

Is the consent of other owners required to sell a share to a relative?

Yes, you must first obtain a written waiver from the other co-owners: their pre-emptive right is enshrined in the Civil Code. A notification is sent to each participant in common ownership stating the subject and the price, then a waiver or silence is awaited within the established period. If a co-owner wants to buy the share themselves, the seller is obliged to sell it to them on the same terms. Without notification, the transaction can be challenged, and the buyer risks losing both the money and the share.

How is an apartment divided in a divorce if there are minor children?

An apartment acquired during the marriage is considered common property, and the spouses' shares are, as a general rule, equal. Children do not automatically become owners of a share, but the court may depart from equality and increase the part of the spouse with whom the children remain. The grounds are the child living with that parent, the absence of other housing for that parent, and the use of targeted payments for children in the purchase. It is better to collect evidence before filing a claim.

How do heirs divide an apartment — can they get a room instead of money?

The division ends either with the allocation of a share in kind or with monetary compensation. Allocation is possible if the heir receives an isolated premises with a separate entrance, kitchen and bathroom; otherwise, recovery of compensation is discussed. Heirs receive the housing in common shared ownership and divide ideal shares, not rooms. They may dispose of the property by agreement with notarial certification or through court when they fail to reach an agreement.

On what grounds is a will for an apartment challenged?

A will is challenged when there are doubts about the procedure for its drawing up, signing or certification. It is checked whether the testator understood the meaning of their actions and whether there was pressure from other persons. A claim may be filed by a person for whom this has property consequences. The specific grounds and procedure depend on the circumstances, so the documents should be shown to a lawyer before going to court.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp