Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty — we select the procedure and protect the director

A lawyer reviews the company's documents with the director in preparation for the procedure in Almaty
  • We work out what suits: liquidation, rehabilitation or bankruptcy
  • We assess the risks for the director and participants before the procedure begins
  • We protect against subsidiary liability and challenge of transactions
  • We handle the procedure from preparation of documents to completion
Bankruptcy and Liquidation

A section on how to wind up or rehabilitate a business with the least loss

Three paths with different consequences — the choice is made based on the state of assets and debts

The main risk here is not the loss of the company, but the personal liability of the director

The earlier the review begins, the more options remain

We act both for the debtor and for creditors in third-party procedures

We give an assessment of the situation before work begins and free of charge

Zhanibek Mugadarov, Legal consultant

Tell us what is happening with the company: what debts, what assets, whether there are creditors' claims. We will say which procedure suits and what the director risks personally. Assessment of the situation is free.

  • 15years
    in bankruptcy
    Procedures, rehabilitation, separate disputes
  • 3paths
    of closing a business
    Liquidation, rehabilitation, bankruptcy
  • 3years
    suspect period
    How far back a company's transactions are reviewed
  • 70+
    procedures
    Acting for debtors and creditors

Types of services

Bankruptcy and liquidation in Almaty: what the section covers

Choosing a procedure

We review the state of the assets, debts and prospects of the business and say what fits: voluntary liquidation, rehabilitation or bankruptcy.

Voluntary liquidation

When the property is enough to settle with creditors. The calmest path, but it requires care in the settlements and in the order of steps.

Rehabilitation of the company

The business is viable but cannot cope with its current obligations. The procedure gives breathing space and a recovery plan instead of liquidation.

Bankruptcy of a legal entity

When settlement is impossible. We handle the procedure and protect the interests of the debtor and its management at every stage.

Defence against subsidiary liability

The main personal risk for a director and the owners. We examine the grounds in advance and prepare the position before a claim is brought.

Challenging transactions

The company's transactions are reviewed several years back. We assess the risks on each one and defend those concluded on ordinary terms.

Representation on the creditor's side

Filing claims in the register within the deadline, participation in meetings, challenging the debtor's transactions, holding controlling persons liable.

Preparation for the procedure

Audit of documents and transactions before filing the application. Work done in advance removes most of the future risks.

Tell us about the state of the company — we will select the procedure and assess personal risks

The assessment is free of charge. If the company can be saved through rehabilitation or closed through an ordinary liquidation, we will say so rather than steer it into bankruptcy.

  • Debts exceed assets
  • The business cannot keep up with payments
  • We want to close the company
  • Creditors have filed an application
  • Threat of subsidiary liability
  • Our transactions are being challenged
  • The debtor is going bankrupt
  • I don't know what to choose

Cost

Cost of services for bankruptcy and liquidation

The cost depends on the procedure and on the volume of disputed transactions. Preparation before filing is substantially cheaper than defence in a procedure already underway.

Cost of services for bankruptcy and liquidation
Service What is included Cost
Assessment of the situation and choice of procedure What suits the company and what the director risks free of charge
Audit of transactions before the procedure Review for risks of challenge from 180,000 ₸
Voluntary liquidation Full support throughout the procedure from 300,000 ₸
Preparation for rehabilitation Plan and documents for the procedure from 350,000 ₸
Support during rehabilitation Conducting the procedure and dealing with creditors from 450,000 ₸
Preparation of the bankruptcy application Documents and justification from 280,000 ₸
Support during bankruptcy The entire procedure, meetings, reporting from 600,000 ₸
Defence against subsidiary liability Position and evidence on each ground from 400,000 ₸
Defence of a transaction against challenge Justification of ordinary terms from 220,000 ₸
Filing claims in the register On the creditor's side, with document collection from 130,000 ₸
Separate dispute Challenging transactions or claims from 260,000 ₸
Representing a creditor in the procedure Meetings, control, separate disputes from 250,000 ₸

The ranges are indicative and do not constitute a public offer. The manager's remuneration, state duty, publications, valuation and auctions are paid separately.

How we handle bankruptcy and liquidation: from assessment to completion of the procedure

  1. We assess assets and debts

    The first thing that determines the route: whether there is enough property to settle with creditors. This decides whether ordinary liquidation is possible.

  2. We assess viability

    Whether the business has contracts, revenue and prospects. If it does, rehabilitation may be better than closure.

  3. We review transactions

    The company's transactions over recent years are reviewed for challengeability. We analyse each one in advance, not after claims are filed.

  4. We assess personal risks

    Grounds for subsidiary liability of the director and participants. This is the main thing to know before filing an application.

  5. We choose the procedure

    Liquidation, rehabilitation or bankruptcy. A mistake here is costly: once a procedure has started, it is hard to change.

  6. We prepare the documents

    Reporting, list of property, register of obligations, justification. An incomplete set means the application is returned and time is lost.

  7. We run the procedure

    Creditors' meetings, reporting, separate disputes, interaction with the manager. The procedure requires constant involvement.

  8. We close out the consequences

    We make sure that completion of the procedure genuinely releases the company and its management from the claims filed.

  9. Not sure which procedure suits you?

    Message us on WhatsApp with the company's debts and assets — we will tell you what to choose and what the director risks personally.

    Describe the situation
Bonafacto lawyer at work: company bankruptcy and liquidation in Almaty

A company can be closed in different ways, and the chosen route decides whether questions will remain for the director. We compare the options in advance and explain the consequences of each.

The Bonafacto teamlawyers in bankruptcy and liquidation

Team

Team of lawyers in Almaty

We handle a case from start to finish with the same team: you always know who is dealing with your matter and who to contact.

Practice

Recent case stories from our lawyers in Almaty

Details have been changed and anonymised: the content of the case is protected by professional privilege.

Choice of procedure

The company was heading for bankruptcy — rehabilitation was the right fit

Situation
A manufacturing company with debts of 340 million tenge could not keep up with current payments after a major contract fell through. The owners were preparing to file for bankruptcy. Yet production was running, the equipment was in working order, and two active contracts for the following year remained in the portfolio.
What we did
We calculated not only the debts but also the prospects: revenue under existing contracts, capacity utilisation, and the structure of liabilities. It turned out that with a three-year instalment plan the enterprise could service the debt from its current operations. We prepared a rehabilitation plan and held negotiations with the largest creditors before filing.
Result
The rehabilitation procedure was opened, and the plan was approved by the creditors' meeting. The enterprise is operating, about a third of the debt was repaid in the first year, and jobs have been preserved.
Subsidiary liability

The director was faced with a claim for 180 million tenge

Situation
After the settlements in the bankruptcy procedure were completed, the creditors sought to hold the former director subsidiarily liable for the outstanding amount. The grounds cited were the late filing of the bankruptcy application and the conclusion of loss-making transactions in the company's final year of operation.
What we did
We analysed each ground separately. On the timing, we showed that the signs of insolvency had arisen later than the stated date, attaching management accounts and correspondence with counterparties about restructuring. On the transactions, we proved that they had been concluded on market terms and had been aimed at preserving the business.
Result
The claim for subsidiary liability was refused in full. The director's personal property was unaffected, and the claims remained unsatisfied out of the bankruptcy estate.
Liquidation

Voluntary liquidation instead of bankruptcy saved a year

Situation
The owners decided to close a company that had stopped generating income. Debts to two counterparties amounted to about 9 million tenge, while around 14 million remained in accounts and property. The accountant insisted that bankruptcy was required where debts existed.
What we did
We showed that the property was sufficient for the settlements and that a bankruptcy procedure was not required here. We carried out a voluntary liquidation: notifying creditors, settlements in the prescribed manner, interim and final balance sheets, and deregistration.
Result
The company was liquidated in six months instead of the year and a half to two years of a bankruptcy procedure. The creditors were paid in full, and no claims arose against the owners.
Challenging transactions

The trustee challenged the sale of equipment — the transaction was upheld

Situation
In the bankruptcy procedure, the trustee sought to challenge the sale of a production line carried out a year and a half before the application was filed. The argument: the price was undervalued and the buyer was connected to the debtor. The buyer — our client — risked losing equipment it was already operating.
What we did
We gathered evidence that the price was market-based: an independent valuer's report as at the transaction date, information on offers for similar equipment, and documents on its condition and wear. We showed there was no connection between the parties and confirmed actual payment with bank documents.
Result
The challenge to the transaction was refused. The equipment remained with the client, and no additional payments into the bankruptcy estate were required.
Preparation

An audit before filing removed three of five risks

Situation
The company planned to file a bankruptcy application. Management believed that preparation amounted to collecting the accounts. Yet in the preceding two years there had been several transactions involving property, and some settlements had been made through related companies.
What we did
We audited the transactions for the period that would be reviewed and assessed each one for the risk of challenge. For three transactions we gathered supporting documents in advance: valuations, business correspondence, and confirmations of settlement. For two, we recommended a different sequence of actions before filing.
Result
In the procedure, not one of the prepared transactions was challenged. No claims were brought against the director — the evidentiary basis for each episode had existed from the outset.
On the creditor's side

The claim was included in the register, and the assets that had been removed were returned

Situation
The client learned of its counterparty's bankruptcy late — eight days remained before the deadline for filing a claim expired. The debt amounted to 24 million tenge, and some of the supporting documents were kept in another city.
What we did
We prepared an application based on the available documents and attached the rest by way of a motion. In parallel, we reviewed the debtor's transactions for the preceding period and found two sales of real estate to related parties shortly before the application was filed.
Result
The claim was included in the register in full. The challenged transactions returned two properties to the bankruptcy estate, from which the client received 17.3 million tenge.
Rehabilitation failed

The plan did not work — we moved into bankruptcy with no losses for the management

Situation
A year after rehabilitation began, it became clear that the plan was not being fulfilled: the key customer terminated the contract on which the calculation had been based. The management feared that the failure of the plan in itself would become grounds for personal liability.
What we did
We documented the reasons for non-fulfilment of the plan as external and not dependent on the management: termination of the contract, correspondence, attempts to replace the volume. We promptly initiated the transition to bankruptcy proceedings, without delaying recognition that the plan was unfeasible.
Result
The transition proceeded routinely, and no claims for subsidiary liability were made. The timeliness of the management's actions became the decisive circumstance.
The wrong choice

The company started the wrong procedure and lost six months

Situation
The company filed for bankruptcy on its own, although its assets were sufficient to settle with creditors. The procedure dragged on, the costs of administering it grew, and the owners were losing control over assets that could have been enough for a voluntary closure.
What we did
We analysed the structure of assets and liabilities and prepared a justification for terminating the procedure, with a calculation showing that the assets were sufficient. We held negotiations with creditors on the manner of settlement outside the procedure.
Result
The procedure was terminated, settlements were made voluntarily, and the company was closed by ordinary liquidation. The loss amounted to about six months and the costs of administering the procedure — these could have been avoided by analysing the matter before filing.

Useful information

Bankruptcy and liquidation: how to choose between liquidation, rehabilitation and bankruptcy

An owner or director comes in with the same picture: debts have grown, some obligations are overdue, counterparties and creditors are demanding settlement, and the business no longer generates its former revenue. The first question usually sounds like this: close the company, try to pull it through, or file for bankruptcy. The difference between these paths is not just in the name — it lies in the timelines, in the fate of the property, and in whether past transactions will surface.

A creditor of a company that has already entered the procedure is looking for something else: how to file claims so as not to be left out of the settlements, and whether it is possible to return to the estate what the debtor managed to transfer to third parties. Below we look at three paths for winding up or rescuing a business, the criteria for choosing between them, the mechanics of challenging transactions, and the personal risks of the director, including subsidiary liability for unpaid debts.

Bankruptcy and liquidation of a company: how these paths differ in substance

Bankruptcy and liquidation of a company are not synonyms, although at a everyday level they are confused. Liquidation is the termination of a legal entity's activities with full settlement of obligations to creditors, employees and the budget. Bankruptcy is initiated in cases of insolvency, when the LLP cannot settle its debts within the established period. Rehabilitation occupies an intermediate position: it is needed not to close the business, but to restore solvency.

The difference is easiest to see from the state of the debts. In voluntary liquidation, the property and funds are sufficient to close all obligations, so the process proceeds by decision of the participants and without court pressure. Bankruptcy implies that there is not enough money for full settlement, and then the procedure goes through the Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court with the participation of a bankruptcy manager. The choice between the three paths is determined by this: whether the assets are sufficient for settlement and whether there is any point in preserving a going concern.

  • Liquidation — termination of activities with full settlement of obligations, assets are sufficient.
  • Bankruptcy — a procedure in cases of insolvency, when the property is not enough for settlement.
  • Rehabilitation — restoration of solvency without closing the enterprise.
  • Whether there are enough funds to settle accounts is the main criterion for choosing between liquidation and bankruptcy.
  • Whether the business remains viable is the criterion for choosing rehabilitation.
  • The personal risks of the director depend on which path of winding up or rescuing the business is chosen.

Voluntary liquidation of an LLP: when bankruptcy and liquidation are not yet equivalent

Voluntary liquidation of an LLP is the closure of a company by decision of its owner, without a court declaring it bankrupt. This path is possible while the property and money are sufficient for a full settlement with creditors, and the remainder is distributed among the participants. Otherwise bankruptcy and liquidation are not equivalent: closure bypasses the interests of creditors.

The procedure begins with a decision of the general meeting of participants, the information is entered in the Legal Cadastre, and creditors are notified. Before settlements are completed, the liquidation commission identifies all creditors, collects receivables and sells the property. Registration actions and removal from the register follow only after the confirmed claims have been discharged.

Liquidation with debts is permissible if the debt is covered by assets. Where property is insufficient, the law requires bankruptcy: there claims are satisfied in order of priority, and transactions are checked for asset stripping. Closure with unpaid debts through voluntary liquidation creates a risk of challenge and of personal liability for the director and participants.

Indicators under which ordinary closure remains lawful:

Creditors are notified in the established manner, not merely formally.

Assets are sufficient to cover all confirmed debt, including taxes and mandatory payments.

Rehabilitation procedure: a chance to preserve the business instead of bankruptcy and liquidation

A rehabilitation procedure in Kazakhstan is a court-supervised attempt to restore the debtor's solvency rather than to sell off its property. Cases are heard by a Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court, and the course of the procedure is supervised by a rehabilitation manager. Unlike voluntary liquidation, where the decision is taken by the owner, rehabilitation proceeds under the supervision of the court and the creditors. The aim is to preserve a going concern and gradually settle the debts.

Rehabilitation of a legal entity suits companies with production or trading potential whose temporary difficulties are caused by external factors: falling demand, terminated contracts, sanctions against counterparties. If the business has stopped, the assets have been sold off or there is no source of income, rehabilitation will not produce a result and gives way to bankruptcy. Restoring solvency is possible where the model is viable and creditors are interested in a deferral.

In winding up a business there are 3 paths: liquidation, rehabilitation, bankruptcy. Liquidation is the voluntary cessation of activity with settlement of obligations. Bankruptcy is the declaration of insolvency and the sale of property to discharge claims. Rehabilitation does not end the business but gives time to emerge from the crisis.

  • the legal entity and jobs are preserved, whereas in liquidation and bankruptcy the activity ceases
  • management passes under the control of the court and the rehabilitation manager
  • creditors receive repayment according to a schedule, rather than a one-off payment from the sale of assets
  • support measures are applied: a moratorium on enforcement, debt restructuring, the possibility of attracting investment
  • the procedure ends either with the restoration of solvency or with a transition to bankruptcy

When bankruptcy is chosen and liquidation can no longer be postponed

The decision to launch insolvency proceedings is not always driven by the director's wishes. The Law on Bankruptcy obliges proceedings to be initiated when a company shows signs of insolvency: it has stopped settling its obligations, and the amount of debt exceeds the value of its liquid assets. Delay works against the debtor and its management.

The first criterion is the persistent nature of the problems. One-off cash gaps covered by receipts from debtors do not give grounds to conclude insolvency. A warning signal is the systemic non-performance of obligations, the accumulation of creditors' claims, where current revenue does not cover mandatory payments and wages.

A separate trigger is the threat of enforced recovery. Having received an enforcement document, a court enforcement officer may freeze accounts, seize property and restrict the disposal of assets. When there are several such proceedings and they affect production assets, the company loses manageability, and creditors gain advantages in order of priority. The duty to file for bankruptcy becomes a requirement of law.

  • systematic delays on obligations to creditors and employees;
  • the aggregate debt exceeding the real value of assets;
  • the existence of enforcement proceedings and arrests on accounts or property;
  • loss of the ability to carry on ordinary business activity due to debts;
  • cessation of income from which obligations were previously repaid;
  • creditors making claims and the threat of compulsory enforcement.

Comparison of three scenarios: liquidation, rehabilitation and bankruptcy

The purpose of voluntary liquidation is to terminate the company's activity by decision of the owners in the absence of signs of insolvency. The process is conducted by the participants and the liquidation commission, with control exercised through registration actions via the Legal Cadastre and the Public Service Centre. Property is sold in the interests of the participants, obligations to creditors are settled, the remainder is distributed, and the outcome is removal from the register. Liquidation is not designed to protect against debts: it assumes that there are sufficient funds.

Rehabilitation is applied in cases of temporary difficulties where a viable business model is preserved. The procedure is conducted by a rehabilitation manager under the supervision of the Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court, and creditors agree the plan. Assets are not sold off: the manager preserves operations, may suspend obligations and restructure the debt. Completion means restoration of solvency or termination of the procedure.

  • Liquidation: managed by the owners, property is distributed among the participants, the procedure is formalised through registration channels.
  • Rehabilitation: managed by a rehabilitation manager, assets are preserved, contracts continue under the plan, supervision is through the Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court.
  • Bankruptcy: managed by a bankruptcy manager, assets form the estate, settlements are made in order of priority.
  • The speed and depth of intervention by the authorities: from registration actions in liquidation to court supervision in bankruptcy.
  • Outcome: removal from the register in liquidation, restoration of solvency in rehabilitation, discharge of debts or liquidation in bankruptcy.
Key differences between the three scenarios
Parameter Liquidation Rehabilitation Bankruptcy
Purpose To terminate activity by decision of the owners To restore solvency To settle with creditors where restoration is impossible
Who manages Liquidation commission Rehabilitation manager Bankruptcy manager
Assets Realised in the interests of the participants Kept in operation Form the bankruptcy estate
Contracts Performed and closed Operate under the rehabilitation plan, some obligations are suspended Some are terminated by the manager
Control Registration actions Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court and creditors Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court and creditors
Outcome Removal from the register Return to normal operation Debt discharge or liquidation

All procedures are handled within a single practice: across 70+ procedures conducted on the side of debtors and creditors, it is clear that the choice is determined by the state of the business and the position of the creditors, not only by the amount of debt.

Debt in itself is neither a sentence nor grounds for bankruptcy. First an honest calculation of assets and liabilities, then a decision on the procedure: it is almost impossible to change the path once started.

Dulat Abenov

The fate of assets and transactions in bankruptcy and liquidation

In voluntary liquidation, the property remains at the disposal of the company and its participants: assets are consistently sold or distributed among the participants after settlements with creditors, receivables are collected by the liquidation commission itself, and past transactions are not reviewed by anyone. Liquidation proceeds by decision of the participants, without a court or a manager, and is therefore predictable. Debts in themselves do not mean bankruptcy: if the property is sufficient to settle with creditors, the company is closed through voluntary liquidation — faster, cheaper and without review of past transactions.

In bankruptcy, the property is controlled by the bankruptcy manager: they form the bankruptcy estate, conduct the realisation of property through auctions, distribute the proceeds among creditors in order of priority, and return the remainder to the participants last. The manager analyses the debtor's financial condition and reporting for the preceding period, which affects previously concluded transactions.

  • Liquidation: property is realised under the control of the liquidation commission, receivables are collected by the company itself, completed transactions are not revisited.
  • Bankruptcy: the bankruptcy estate is formed by the bankruptcy manager, realisation of property goes through auctions, receivables are collected into the common estate.
  • Rehabilitation: property and operations are preserved under the rehabilitation plan, disposal of assets is limited by the need for agreement with creditors.
  • Past transactions: in liquidation they are untouchable, in bankruptcy they may be challenged on the grounds of causing harm to creditors.
  • Liability: liquidation risks claims if the order of settlements is breached, while bankruptcy risks subsidiary liability of the director and participants.
  • Accounts receivable: on liquidation it is assigned or recovered, on bankruptcy it is included in the estate and distributed among all creditors.

The role of the bankruptcy and rehabilitation manager in the procedure

The procedure on the debtor's side is conducted not by the owner or the director, but by a bankruptcy or rehabilitation manager appointed by the authorised body in the field of rehabilitation and bankruptcy. He acts independently of the former management and is accountable to the court and the creditors. From the moment of approval, the powers of the executive body to dispose of property are substantially restricted: the owner retains corporate rights but loses operational control over assets and transactions.

The powers differ by purpose. In rehabilitation, the manager controls the implementation of the plan, approves transactions, keeps records of creditors' claims and ensures that the business continues to operate and restores solvency. In bankruptcy, he takes over the property, conducts an inventory, forms the property estate and settles with creditors in the established order of priority. What is common: the manager disposes of the fate of the assets instead of the owner, and reporting and major decisions go through the creditors' meeting and the court.

Bankruptcy and liquidation through a creditor's eyes: how to file claims

On liquidation and bankruptcy, creditors' claims enter the register, but the grounds and consequences differ. On voluntary liquidation, the commission itself identifies creditors and settles the debts; if the property is insufficient, the liquidation is not completed and the debtor goes into bankruptcy by a court decision. On rehabilitation and bankruptcy, the creditor files claims in the case, and the order of priority and the extent of satisfaction depend on the moment of filing.

In bankruptcy, the claim is filed with the court hearing the case, with documents confirming the basis and amount of the debt: the contract, acts, delivery notes, payment documents, correspondence about the claim, and a court decision that has entered into force. Claims are included in the register after verification by the court; the creditor has the right to participate in meetings and to object to the claims of other creditors.

On liquidation, claims are filed with the liquidation commission within the period stated in the publication on liquidation; missing the period does not deprive the creditor of the right, but such claims are satisfied out of the property remaining after settlements with creditors from the register. The filing periods are key to the order of priority and to receiving money.

  • Determine the procedure: liquidation, rehabilitation or bankruptcy — this determines to whom and in what manner claims must be filed.
  • Collect the primary documents confirming the debt and calculate its amount as at the date the procedure was introduced.
  • File the claim with the court or the liquidation commission within the period set by the publication.
  • Check whether the claims have been included in the register of creditors' claims and appeal a refusal.
  • Participate in creditors' meetings and monitor the debtor's transactions with assets.
  • Keep evidence of late filing, withdrawal of assets and misstatement of reporting for a subsequent dispute.

Order of settlements: who gets what in bankruptcy and liquidation

The order of satisfaction of creditors' claims is determined by law and does not depend on who manages the process. On voluntary liquidation, the founders themselves determine the order of settlements, but must observe the priorities established by law. In bankruptcy proceedings, settlements are conducted by the bankruptcy manager under the control of creditors and the court. The difference is fundamental: liquidation is built on the good faith of the management, bankruptcy on external control.

On liquidation, obligations to employees are covered first, then claims for taxes and other mandatory payments, and the remainder goes to other creditors. If the property is insufficient, the liquidation stops and bankruptcy is initiated. Attempts to close a company with unpaid debts through liquidation lead to transactions being challenged and to the liability of the director.

  • Claims of each priority are satisfied only after the previous one has been fully paid.
  • In voluntary liquidation, settlements are controlled by the liquidation commission; in bankruptcy proceedings, by the bankruptcy manager.
  • Settlements with individual creditors bypassing the established order of priority may be challenged.
  • Sale of property below market price and gratuitous transfer of assets are checked for damage to creditors.
  • Set-offs with related companies do not preclude a revision of settlements in bankruptcy.
  • Insufficient property on liquidation obliges the company to move to bankruptcy proceedings rather than complete the liquidation.

Personal risks of the director in bankruptcy and liquidation

In bankruptcy and voluntary liquidation of a legal entity, the director and the owner are not automatically protected by the company's status. Subsidiary liability of the director arises where the company's debts were caused by his unfair or unreasonable actions and the debtor's property is insufficient to settle with creditors. The grounds and procedure are established by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Rehabilitation and Bankruptcy and the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan; the dispute is heard by a Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court.

A separate ground is the failure to file a bankruptcy petition in the event of objective insolvency. If the director knew that the obligations could not be performed and did not initiate the procedure, he may be held liable for the debts incurred after the petition should have been filed. The court assesses the point at which the signs of insolvency became obvious and the director's conduct thereafter.

What to check before choosing between liquidation, rehabilitation and bankruptcy

Before choosing between voluntary liquidation, rehabilitation and bankruptcy, a company carries out an inventory: what forms the debt burden, whether there are disputes, what condition the assets are in and whether the business is capable of generating revenue. For choosing a procedure, what matters is not only the amount of debt but also its structure: claims of the tax authority, banks, counterparties and employees for wages are settled in different order of priority, and their combination determines whether rehabilitation is possible or liquidation is indicated. The criteria also depend on whether transactions are being challenged and whether there are enforcement proceedings with court enforcement officers.

The condition of assets is checked not by their carrying amount in the accounts but by the real possibility of selling them: encumbrances, arrests, pledges, the actual location of the property, as well as receivables that can be recovered. The prospects for revenue are assessed separately: whether contracts are still in place, whether valid licences and permits exist, and whether the company is capable of restoring solvency once pressure from creditors is removed. If the business is loss-making and the assets are insufficient, rehabilitation will have no effect, and liquidation or bankruptcy is more rational.

  • Debt structure: the share of claims of the tax authority, banks, counterparties and employees, the presence of pledges and sureties.
  • Court disputes: cases before the Specialized Interdistrict Economic Court, enforcement proceedings with court enforcement officers, challenged transactions.
  • Assets: real market value, encumbrances, arrests, liquidity and the recoverability of receivables.
  • Revenue: existing contracts, licences, the ability to restore solvency once pressure from creditors is removed.
  • Creditors' willingness: consent to instalments, deferral or debt forgiveness outside the procedure.
  • Transaction documents: the valuer's report as at the date of the transaction, information on market offers, confirmation of payment and of the absence of a connection between the parties, if a sale of property is planned.
Comparison of the routes by key criteria
Criterion Voluntary liquidation Rehabilitation Bankruptcy
Debt structure The debt is repayable, there are no disputes with creditors There is debt, but repayment is possible under a schedule The debt exceeds the assets, repayment is impossible
Disputes and enforcement None, or of a technical nature There are disputes, but there is a chance of reaching agreement There are disputes and enforcement proceedings
Assets Sufficient to settle with creditors Sufficient to continue operations Insufficient or assets are illiquid
Revenue prospects Not required, operations are ceasing There are contracts and demand for the product Absent or unstable
Position of creditors Agree to liquidation Ready to make concessions and accept instalments Not ready to make concessions

For a bona fide buyer of property from a future bankrupt, the transaction is defensible if there is a valuer's report as at the transaction date, evidence of market offers, confirmation of actual payment and no connection between the parties.

Typical mistakes in bankruptcy and liquidation of a company

The main misconception is that a company with debts can simply be closed without any procedures. Ceasing operations without settling with creditors does not extinguish obligations: the claims remain, and creditors are entitled to challenge such actions. This leads to mistakes in liquidation, where an entry in the register is treated as the final point.

The second group is concealment or removal of property before the procedure. Transferring assets to related parties, understating the value on sale, and sham transactions do not protect against claims but become grounds for action against management. Courts assess such transactions on the actual circumstances, not on the paperwork.

The third is ignoring creditors' claims and staying silent instead of engaging in dialogue. Failing to respond to claims and evading disclosure strengthens the creditors' position and widens the range of grounds for challenge. This is where the consequences of improper liquidation come to light, when a formally closed company is brought back into the arena of disputes.

  • Closing a company with debts without a procedure — obligations are not extinguished, creditors retain their claims.
  • Concealment and removal of property before the procedure — an independent ground for challenging transactions and for claims against management.
  • Ignoring creditors' claims — silence instead of responding to claims increases the risks.
  • Relying on automatic discharge of debts — release from obligations requires disclosure of property and good faith.
  • Delay in acknowledging that the rehabilitation plan is unfeasible — transition to bankruptcy and grounds for claims against management.
  • Mistakes in company bankruptcy and mistakes in liquidation share a common root — an attempt to resolve a debt situation without a legal procedure.

Reviews

Reviews of work on bankruptcy and liquidation

4.9
Google
4.9  · 128
Yandex
4.8  · 94
2GIS
4.9  · 156
Zoon
4.7  · 41
Manufacturing enterprise

We have a manufacturing business, and when the debt reached 340 million, I was already mentally preparing to go bankrupt — I saw no other way out. I came in for advice, and they assessed the prospects: it turned out that with a three-year instalment plan we could manage on our own. We went into rehabilitation, paid off a third of the debt within a year, people are still working, the plant didn't shut down.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Askar T.

As a former director, I was hit with 180 million in subsidiary liability, and it was very unexpected because I hadn't run the company for a long time. I was looking for a lawyer who specialises in exactly these kinds of disputes, because my first conversation with other specialists went nowhere — they just told me my chances were slim. Here, Noyan sat down with me and we went through every single ground, and for the first time I saw the whole picture. We analysed each ground, pulled up the documents, looked at exactly when the insolvency had arisen. We proved that it arose later than the period they were trying to hold me liable for. It was painstaking work — I brought in papers, we had calls, we clarified things several times over. But in the end they were refused in full. I'm very grateful that it ended this way.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Irina V.

Our accountant insisted that with debts like these it was bankruptcy and nothing else, and I had almost come to terms with it. I came for a consultation because I wanted to understand whether it was realistic to close the firm without all that public procedure. Anna looked at the documents and said there were enough assets and we could get by with an ordinary liquidation. At first I didn't believe it, to be honest, I asked again several times. But she calmly explained everything, showed me the calculations, and we went down that path. In the end we closed in six months instead of two years. That was a huge difference for me, because all that time I couldn't properly focus on new projects

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Dmitry N.

The trustee in someone else's procedure was challenging our purchase of equipment from a bankrupt, and it was a complete surprise for us. We'd bought the machinery long before all those events, everything was clean, but we had to prove it. We put together a valuation as at the transaction date, pulled up all the proof of payment, every payment slip. I personally drove around and brought in documents, and together with the lawyer we prepared the position. It was nerve-racking, because it was expensive equipment that was already standing in our workshop. But the transaction held up, we fought off the challenge. I can say the approach was serious and unhurried. Glad we came here.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for the review. We're glad we managed to defend the transaction — in such disputes, thorough preparation of documents really is what decides it. Get in touch if you need help again.

Sibir Group LLP

Before filing the application, I was afraid that afterwards they'd start picking apart every transaction from recent years and come after the director with claims, so I looked for lawyers who know how to prepare everything in advance. They audited the transactions before filing. In the procedure, not a single one was challenged, and there were no claims against the director. It cost a fraction of what defending ourselves afterwards would have.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Murat Zh.

We found out about the debtor's bankruptcy a week before the register deadline closed, and to be honest I was in a panic. We had to submit additional documents, and we waited for a response a bit longer than we'd have liked, but we made it in time, and we even got his transactions challenged. We received 17 million

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Olga K.

When the client terminated the contract, I realised the rehabilitation plan wasn't going to work, and I ran around looking for someone to help us stay afloat. They helped us move into bankruptcy in time and without any claims against the management. It turned out that timing is the main thing here

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Yerlan S.

We filed for bankruptcy ourselves even though we had enough assets. We lost six months. They helped us terminate the procedure and close properly.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Viktor M.

Right in the first conversation they told me about the director's personal risks — it was Natalya, she laid out all the points straight away. Before that, nobody had mentioned it at all. After that conversation I somehow looked at the whole situation differently

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Gulnara A.

Being a director, I neglected accounting, and when we started preparing the company for the procedure, I realized there's no way without getting things in order. I looked for a lawyer to sort out the documents and see where my holes are. They laid everything out for me and helped gather the papers. Turned out that failure to submit reports is a separate ground for liability. Thanks, now I look at the situation more calmly.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Bakhytzhan O.

They count the assets before proposing anything. That seemed like the right approach to me.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Natalya D.

Our situation was difficult, I went to several places for advice, but not everyone told me the truth. Dulat told me straight that rehabilitation wouldn't work for us, that the business was systematically sinking into losses. He didn't sell me hope, he said everything openly. I'm glad about that, because we didn't waste extra time and money.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for your review. In such situations, giving an honest assessment is our job. If you need help later, get in touch.

Ruslan B.

We held negotiations with the main creditors before filing. There were no surprises at the meeting.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Saule T.

The same person who handled the whole procedure, Murat, dealt with the separate disputes. We didn't have to brief anyone new, he kept everything in his head. That saves a lot of time and nerves

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for the review. We try to run a case from start to finish with one specialist — it really is easier both for you and for the result.

Ayan F.

When the debt problems started, I didn't know what to grab hold of and was just looking for a calm conversation at the very least. Everything was professional and calm. In that kind of situation that's valuable in itself.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Kamila Sh.

I came in with a pile of debts and completely lost, I didn't understand where to even start. Zhanibek did the assessment, and it was free and detailed, not a five-minute thing. After it everything in my head fell into place.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for taking the time to write. We're glad the review of your situation helped you see the whole picture.

Talgat E.

They explained that they check transactions going back several years. We hadn't even thought about that.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Zhanna R.

It was long, the procedure took more than a year. I went into it with debts and already understood it wouldn't be easy. But they warned me right away that it's never quick

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Serik G.

We participated as a creditor in someone else's procedure, and it was important for us to understand what was happening. At first it was unclear, we had to submit papers that we thought were unnecessary. But then everything got sorted out, they kept us informed about every meeting. Sometimes we had to wait for an answer, but overall the work is normal. Thanks for the support.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Dinara L.

When they started putting pressure on the director over the company's debts, what I feared most was for our flat and that the children would be left with nothing. My husband didn't sleep at night, we were looking for lawyers who understand exactly this area. They helped preserve the director's personal property. They also explained separately what can be protected and what can't, without empty promises. I went to the meetings together with my husband, asked a lot of questions, and no one got irritated. It went on for several months, we waited, we worried. For the family that was the main thing

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for your trust. In cases like this it's important to separate the personal from the business — we're glad we could help your family.

Marat Y.

Мен бұл жерге келгенде жағдайым өте ауыр еді, бірнеше адамның алдында қарызым бар болатын. Келген себебім, осы салада шынымен түсінетін адамдар керек болды. Олар дараулық дауларда жақсы түсінеді, бұл бірден байқалады. Маған түсінікті етіп айтып берді, артық уәде берген жоқ. Соңына дейін өз ісін білетін адамдар.

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for your feedback. Bankruptcy cases are one of our core areas, so we look into every case carefully.

Elena P.

I came in when the creditors had already filed the application, before that I thought I'd manage to sort everything out myself. Murat honestly said that earlier there would have been more options, but they did what they could. It was unpleasant to hear, but at least it was honest

Service: Bankruptcy and Liquidation in Almaty

Company response

Thank you for writing. With those timelines it really is important to come in earlier — we're glad that we were still able to do at least something for you in this situation.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about bankruptcy and liquidation

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
If a company has debts, is bankruptcy mandatory?

No. If the assets are sufficient to settle with creditors, the company is closed through voluntary liquidation — it is faster, cheaper and without a review of past transactions. We had a case where a company filed for bankruptcy itself while holding assets one and a half times its debts, and lost six months.

How does rehabilitation differ from bankruptcy?

By its purpose. Rehabilitation aims to restore solvency: the business continues to operate under an approved plan. Bankruptcy ends the company's story. Rehabilitation makes sense when there are contracts, revenue and operating production, and the problem was caused by a specific event rather than systemic unprofitability.

What does the director risk personally?

Subsidiary liability for the company's unpaid debts. The grounds repeat: late filing of the application, transactions that worsened the position of creditors, withdrawal of assets, failure to hand over documentation, misstatement of accounts. Each one is rebuttable, but with documents, not explanations.

How far back are the company's transactions reviewed?

For the period preceding the filing of the application, and that is several years. Not only obvious asset withdrawals are reviewed: sales below market price, settlements with individual creditors bypassing the order of priority, set-offs with related companies and gratuitous transfers all come under scrutiny.

What needs to be done before filing the application?

Honestly count the assets and liabilities, audit the transactions for the review period, gather supporting documents for the risky ones, assess the grounds for personal liability and put the accounting in order. This work takes weeks and costs several times less than the defence that follows.

We bought property from a company that is now going bankrupt.

The transaction may be challenged, but it is defensible. You need evidence that the terms were market terms: a valuer's report as at the date of the transaction, information on market offers, confirmation of actual payment and the absence of any connection between the parties. We handle such disputes and win them.

What happens if the rehabilitation plan is not being fulfilled?

The procedure moves into bankruptcy. It is important to acknowledge the plan's unfeasibility in time and document the external causes — termination of a contract, loss of a customer. Delay in itself becomes grounds for claims against management, while timeliness, on the contrary, protects.

How long does the procedure last?

Voluntary liquidation — several months. Bankruptcy and rehabilitation — from a year and longer, depending on the volume of assets, the number of creditors and the number of separate disputes. We will say more precisely after reviewing the specific situation.

Our debtor is going bankrupt. What should we do?

File your claims in the register within the established deadline — a creditor who is late almost always ends up with no payment. In parallel, it is worth checking the debtor's transactions for the preceding period: challenging them often returns to the estate the property from which the payments are made.

Can you start the procedure and then change your mind?

Changing a procedure once it has started is difficult, so the case is analysed before the application is filed. In our practice, terminating an erroneously started bankruptcy took time and required proving that the assets were sufficient — this could have been avoided.

How much does the initial assessment cost?

Nothing. We analyse the state of the assets and liabilities and tell you which procedure fits and what the director risks personally. If the company can be closed through ordinary liquidation or saved through rehabilitation, we will say so rather than push it into bankruptcy.

Contacts and maps

Where to find a bankruptcy and liquidation lawyer in Almaty

Address
348/4 Raiymbek Ave, office 517, Almaty
Reception
at the office and by video call, travel within the city
Working hours
Mon–Sun: 10:00–19:00

2GIS opens in a separate tab — the service does not allow embedding an organisation's listing.

Open in 2GIS

Zoon opens in a separate tab: it has client reviews and ratings.

Open on Zoon

Tell us about your situation

The first consultation is free. If the matter can be resolved without court, we will say so directly.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp