Business

Subsidiary liability of the director: when the company's debt becomes personal

Subsidiary liability of the director is a situation where a creditor of the company makes claims personally against the director, and the proceedings are no longer only about the business's assets. Personal debt does not arise automatically: the creditor must prove the grounds, while the director must build objections and gather documents.

Company director and bankruptcy documents: personal liability

You run a company or own a share in it, and instead of recovering from the company itself, the creditor is trying to hold you personally liable. Or you have just received a claim for subsidiary liability and do not understand where the personal debt came from. Your personal property is at stake, not just the business's assets, so every detail of the position matters.

Some agree to everything and lose their property, others ignore the proceedings and are deprived of the opportunity to object. The outcome depends on which documents have been preserved and how the position is built. Below we explain when a company's debt concerns the director and shareholder personally, how the creditor proves its case, and what to prepare in advance.

Subsidiary liability of a director: when a company's debt becomes personal

A debt of an LLP as a general rule remains the company's debt: a founder risks only what was contributed to the charter capital, and a director — the losses he caused by his decisions. But the law allows an exception: if the company's assets are insufficient to settle with creditors, a claim may be brought against controlling persons. This is subsidiary liability — additional liability for another's debts when the debtor itself lacks funds.

It does not arise automatically from the mere fact of debt. The creditor must prove that the director or founder, by his actions or inaction, brought the company to a state where it cannot pay: withdrew assets, concluded a knowingly disadvantageous transaction, concealed property, failed to hand over documents, or did not apply to court in the face of obvious signs of insolvency. The proceedings revolve around the causal link between such a person's conduct and the fact that the company has no funds left. Hence the practical conclusion: what matters is not the amount of the debt, but the proven decisions and their consequences.

Below is a summary of two categories of controlling persons and of the grounds encountered in disputes. The table helps you understand in advance which documents and explanations will be needed.

What matters in a dispute
Person Ground of risk What is examined Typical objection
Director Decisions and transactions that led to loss of solvency Contracts, payments, account movements The decision was made in the company's interests
Founder Instructions affecting management Minutes, correspondence, actual influence Did not interfere in operational management
Both Failure to hand over documents and property Availability of assets and accounting records Documents were lost through no fault of the person
Both Concealment of information about debts Reporting, transactions before enforcement The creditor itself failed to exercise due care

Each ground is considered separately: the company's overall debt by itself does not yet mean personal liability.

How to read the ground imputed: a step-by-step breakdown

Defense should begin with deciphering exactly what is imputed: not "the company's debt," but a specific decision or inaction with a date and a consequence. Then three things are checked — the period in which the obligation arose, the person's authority at that time, and the fate of the assets after the disputed step. This sequence rules out accusations that have nothing to do with your role: another employee signed, a collegial body made the decision, the transaction was performed in the company's interests.

  • Period: compare the date of the obligation with the dates of the decisions — the imputed act may have been committed before or after the debt arose.
  • Authority: check orders, powers of attorney and the charter — who could actually sign the document and dispose of accounts.
  • Fate of assets: show where the property and money went — actual delivery or payment under an obligation removes the accusation of withdrawing funds.
  • Documents: restore lost papers through counterparties and the bank, not through verbal explanations.
  • Position: set out objections in writing and separately for each ground, without mixing the roles of director and participant.

A typical mistake is to answer all accusations with a single phrase "acted in the company's interests": the court assesses each ground independently, and a general argument closes none of them. The second blunder is "cleaning up" papers: loss or alteration of documents is treated as bad faith and works against you. Practical advice: put together a chronology of decisions and transactions on a single sheet — it immediately shows where a causal link exists and where it does not.

Subsidiary liability of a director does not turn the director into a debtor for every obligation of the company. In assessing such a dispute, Bonafacto lawyers start with the documents: who made the disputed decision and when, what assets the company had at that time, and how this was reflected in the reporting. If the link between the decision and insolvency is not confirmed, the claim against the person remains unproven — and this is the main argument of the defense.

Collecting an LLP's debt from a founder: what a participant is liable for

A creditor may seek to collect an LLP's debt from a founder if it proves that the participant, through their decisions, drove the company into losses or bankruptcy. The status of founder alone does not mean personal liability for the partnership's debts: the company is liable, and the participant only within the limits of their contribution. The exception is when a participant's actions go beyond ordinary business risk and cause damage to the company.

The link between a participant's decisions and losses is established through specific facts: asset stripping, approval of a knowingly loss-making transaction, concealment of property from creditors, or giving binding instructions to the director. The creditor must show a causal link: which specific decision made it impossible to repay the debt. If the participant voted against or the decision was made without their participation, there are no grounds to hold them personally liable — the creditor will have nothing to prove their fault with.

Bonafacto lawyers verify the grounds a creditor relies on in such a dispute against the company's documents: minutes, contracts, bank account statements.

  • Asset stripping: sale of property at an undervalued price or transfer of it to controlled persons
  • Loss-making transaction: approval of a transaction with an affiliate on terms unfavorable to the company
  • Concealment of property: transfer of assets to third parties by the time claims are filed
  • Instructions to the director: orders whose execution led to bankruptcy
  • Documents: failure to hand over accounting and internal papers, which concealed the true state of affairs

A practical point: a participant's contribution to the charter capital limits their risk only in ordinary business activity. As soon as a decision appears that has caused damage to the company, reference to the size of the contribution no longer closes the issue — what counts is the amount of losses, not the share in capital.

When a Director Bears Subsidiary Liability for the Debts of an LLP

A director of an LLP is personally liable for the company's debts if his decisions caused the bankruptcy and the debt to the creditor remained unpaid. The court examines the causal link: not merely a poor result, but a specific act or omission that caused the company to lose solvency. Without such a link, the debt cannot be recovered from the director, even if bankruptcy proceedings are ongoing.

The proceedings revolve around fault and the point at which the director should have seen the problem. In such disputes, Bonafacto lawyers start with a chronology: when signs of insolvency appeared, what decisions were made afterwards, to whom and what was transferred. The chronology shows whether the director had room to manoeuvre or was already acting in a situation where debts were mounting.

The grounds the court assesses first:

  • Bringing about bankruptcy: the director's decisions led to the company ceasing to pay its creditors.
  • Asset stripping: property or money left the company in favour of related parties or through transactions on knowingly unfavourable terms.
  • Failure to hand over documents: accounting records, contracts and correspondence were not transferred to the administrator or the creditor, making it impossible to establish the true state of affairs.
  • Failure to apply to court: despite clear signs of insolvency, no bankruptcy petition was filed, and the debts continued to grow.

Failure to hand over documents operates as a separate risk: the court may treat it as evasion of liability. A practical tip is to record the transfer with an inventory bearing the date and the signature of the receiving party; otherwise, there will be no way to prove that the transfer actually took place.

Subsidiary liability and attempts to recover an LLP's debt from its director: what the creditor must prove

A creditor seeking to recover an LLP's debt from its director builds its case around one question: did the director's actions cause the company to fail to pay. The court looks not at the mere fact of the debt, but at the director's conduct: whether he made decisions contrary to the creditors' interests, whether he withdrew assets, whether he responded to demands, and whether he acted in good faith. The burden of proof lies with the creditor — it is the creditor who submits documents and explains the causal link.

At the same time, the liability of the director and of the participants is distinguished: the director is liable for management decisions, while a participant is liable within the limits of his participation in the charter capital, unless his own bad-faith actions are proven. The creditor's position rests on specific circumstances, and each group of facts requires its own set of evidence. Bonafacto lawyers begin with an inventory of documents: what the creditor has, what can be requested, and which episodes of the director's conduct are confirmed by correspondence, bank statements, and registry records.

The following circumstances are subject to proof:

  • Withdrawal of assets: actions by the director after which the company lost assets or the ability to pay
  • Concealment of documents: failure to provide documents and information about transactions upon the creditor's demand
  • Disadvantageous transactions: entering into transactions on terms knowingly disadvantageous to the LLP
  • Silence about finances: concealment of information about the company's financial condition from the counterparty

Practical advice: for each point, select supporting documents in advance — without them, the argument remains a mere assertion. If you do not have the papers, their absence from the director also becomes a subject of the proceedings.

Comparison of risks for the director and the founder under subsidiary liability

The risk of personal liability depends on the role in decisions, not on the position in the staffing table: the court looks at who actually determined the fate of the company and how this affected creditors. The director is responsible for operational management — signing, performance of obligations, safekeeping of documents. The founder — for decisions of the general meeting that change the company's financial position.

Risks diverge most clearly along three lines: signature, disposal of assets and the ability to stop deterioration. If the founder simultaneously held the post of director, both roles are assessed together — the status of participant in itself does not rule out questions about his actions.

Below is a summary of typical actions and how they relate to status:

  • Transactions: contracts that worsened the position of creditors
  • Assets: transfer of property to affiliated persons
  • Documents: failure to hand over documents and seals
  • Meeting decisions: participation in voting on key issues
Who risks what and for what
Action or status Director Founder
Signing contracts and primary documents Direct risk Risk if he signed himself
Asset stripping, sale of property Responsible for execution Responsible for the decision
Transaction with no benefit to the company Initiator and executor The one who approved it
Concealment of documents from creditors Risk of personal liability Risk under actual control

The court assesses the actual role, not the entry in the charter

Practical conclusion: the defence is built around a specific episode — what exactly the person did, in what status, and which documents confirm this. The more precisely the chronology of decisions is reconstructed, the clearer it is which of the figures is being pursued with claims.

How subsidiary liability proceedings unfold: stages

The proceedings move from reviewing the application and the grounds alleged to a written position, then to hearings and appeal. First, you need to understand exactly which actions or decisions the creditor blames you for and what evidence supports them — the set of evidence depends on this. Without such an analysis, objections come out generic and do not respond to specific arguments.

Next, primary documents are collected: contracts, invoices, acts, correspondence, bank statements. Some copies are lost by this point, and they are restored through counterparties and the bank — requests should be prepared in advance so as not to end up at a hearing without the needed document. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so the scope of preparation is discussed upfront.

  • review of the application and the grounds alleged
  • collection of primary documents and restoration of copies
  • written position with economic justification of decisions
  • participation in hearings and objections on each ground
  • appeal of the issued act

The position is built around economic sense: why the transaction or decision was reasonable at the time it was made, which documents confirm this, and how they relate to the creditor's arguments. Objections are filed separately for each ground — a general answer of "we are not to blame" does not work. It helps to put the arguments and evidence into a table in advance: this shows where confirmation is lacking.

At hearings, it is important to hold the defense line and respond to new arguments, and after the decision — to assess the prospects of appeal. The stages here are the same as in other disputes: review of documents, position and strategy, court, appeal and cassation, then enforcement. The earlier the primary documents are collected, the smoother each next step goes.

What to check in the creditor's application before the first hearing

The first thing to do is break down the application by its elements: which grounds are alleged, against whom exactly the claims are brought, and which documents the creditor refers to. Then the dates are cross-checked: when the obligation arose, when the disputed decision was made, and when the company stopped paying. A discrepancy in dates is not a formality but a working argument: a decision made before the debt appeared could not have caused it.

Separately, all of the creditor's references to transactions and payments are written out and checked to see whether you have primary documents for them. If a document confirms the reality of the operation — a supply, a service, a payment — it closes off the argument about withdrawal of funds. A typical mistake here is to respond to the application as a whole without breaking it down point by point: then the objections look like denial and do not remove a single specific reproach.

  • Grounds: which actions or inaction are alleged and what confirms them.
  • Addressee: claims against the director, the participant, or both — and how their roles are distinguished.
  • Chronology: date of the obligation, date of the disputed decision, moment of insolvency.
  • References to transactions: whether you have primary documents for each challenged operation.
  • Discrepancies: inconsistencies in dates, signatures, and amounts in the creditor's documents.

Such an analysis turns the application from a general accusation into a list of specific questions, each of which gets its own answer backed by a document. The more precisely the application is mapped out, the lower the risk that at a hearing you will have to respond to an argument you did not prepare for.

What to do in case of subsidiary liability: objections and evidence

If the creditor has already asserted claims against you personally, the first step is to gather the primary documents: contracts, invoices, acts, delivery notes, bank statements, correspondence and internal orders. These documents must show the court that decisions were made within the framework of ordinary business risk, and not to siphon off assets. Any attempt to hide or "clean up" papers will backfire: the court assesses the conduct of the director as a whole, and the loss of documents may be interpreted as bad faith. Bonafacto lawyers advise starting with reconstructing the chronology of events — this makes it clear which decisions were made and what information the director relied on.

Separately, prepare an economic justification: why the transaction, loan or deferral was reasonable at that time, what the alternatives were and why this particular option was chosen. If the money went to a counterparty, demonstrate the reality of the supply or service. Your task is to separate liability: the company's obligation remains with the company, and personal liability is possible only in the case of intent or gross negligence, which the creditor is obliged to prove.

Below is what exactly should be prepared and how to structure the objections.

  • Primary documents on disputed transactions: contracts, acts, delivery notes, statements — they show the reality of the transactions.
  • Ordinary business risk: market conditions, counterparty delays, seasonality — they confirm that the decision was not made to siphon off funds.
  • Absence of intent: decisions were made collectively or within the framework of the charter — this removes the accusation of sole abuse.
  • Involvement in the siphoning of funds: rebutted by the fact that the money went to the company's real needs.
  • Economic justification: a written calculation on key decisions — why the chosen option was reasonable.
  • Chronology of events: the sequence of decisions and documents helps show the logic of the director's actions.

The objections are built around one point: the creditor must prove bad faith and a causal link between the actions and the inability to repay the debt, rather than simply referring to the fact of indebtedness itself. The more complete the documents and calculations, the less room for conjecture.

How to structure objections step by step

It is more convenient to assemble the position not as a list of papers, but as a sequence of steps — then it is clear what exactly is being rebutted and by what. First, write out each imputed circumstance separately: siphoning off assets, a loss-making transaction, failure to hand over documents, operating amid signs of insolvency. Then, for each point, select its own set of supporting evidence — there is no universal answer to all grounds at once, and mixing them into one pile means weakening each argument.

Check the dates: compare the moment when the obligation to the creditor arose with the dates of the disputed decisions and transactions. If the decision was made earlier than the debt appeared, the link between them must be explained by the creditor, not by you. Such a calendar cross-check reveals discrepancies in the plaintiff's position on details (and it is worth doing before the first hearing, not in the course of the dispute).

  • Separate the grounds: for each imputed episode — a separate block of objections and its own set of documents.
  • Cross-check the dates: obligation, decision, transaction — line them up in one row and note discrepancies.
  • Confirm the reality of transactions: supply, service, payment — closing documents and correspondence on the transaction.
  • Record your role: what you signed personally, what was approved by the general body, where the decision was made without you.
  • Do not edit retroactively: corrections and "restored" papers raise more questions than original documents with marks.
  • Request copies officially: from the bank and counterparties — if part of the primary documents is not in your possession.

A typical mistake is to respond to the claim with general words about good faith, without tying the arguments to specific documents and dates. The second misstep is silence: if objections and supporting evidence are not presented, the court has nothing to assess your version of events by. It is useful to draw up a short inventory in advance: which document proves what and which circumstance it addresses — it makes it easier to prepare for the hearing and not lose the thread.

Documents in subsidiary liability: what to prepare before the hearing

After receiving a claim to hold you subsidiarily liable, first check what is being alleged and what supports it. Look at the date when the obligations arose and at what decisions you made as a director: signed contracts, approvals, transfers, responses to claims. A mistake is to come to the proceedings without written confirmation of your position: the court does not treat oral explanations as evidence.

Collect documents that show the real picture: accounting records, bank statements, reconciliation reports, correspondence with counterparties, HR decisions. If some papers are lost or remain with former employees, request copies from counterparties and the bank. Separately check whether the documents contain discrepancies in dates, signatures and amounts — the creditor uses such inconsistencies against the director. Bonafacto lawyers advise preparing the evidence folder in advance, not by the hearing: that way it is clear which episodes are confirmed and where explanations are needed.

A basic set that is convenient to start with:

  • Founding documents: charter, appointment orders, minutes of participants' resolutions.
  • Accounting records: accounting records for the disputed period.
  • Bank statements: account activity of the LLP for the same period.
  • Contracts and correspondence: acts, letters and claims with counterparties.
  • Disputed transactions: documents on transactions challenged by the creditor.

Check that every paper is legible and matches the original: a copy without a signature or seal is weaker than a certified document. If some data is missing, record this in writing — by a request to the bank or counterparty — so that in the proceedings you have something to explain the gap with.

How to arrange evidence by episode and not get lost in objections

A simple technique works: match each creditor's claim with a specific document and your explanatory note. The creditor builds its position around the causal link between your decision and the company's inability to pay — meaning each alleged episode needs its own response, not a general phrase "acted reasonably". Arrange the materials in folders: decisions separately, settlements with counterparties separately, correspondence and claims separately. That way it is immediately clear where there is enough evidence and where copies will have to be requested.

Typical mistakes that weaken the position:

  • A general brush-off instead of analysis: the court will not connect an objection without reference to dates and transactions to the case.
  • Editing documents "retroactively": a discrepancy with the original at the counterparty or bank devalues the entire folder.
  • Silence about gaps: an unresolved request to the bank or counterparty is better formalized in writing than left without explanation.
  • Mixing roles: responses for the director and for the participant are prepared separately if the statuses did not coincide.

A practical tip: keep a register — episode, document, what it confirms, how the gap is closed. By the hearing, such a register helps maintain the logic of the position and not lose objections to individual claims.

The court looks not at the position but at your decisions and documents: an ordinary director is liable for losses caused by his actions, while a participant risks personally only if the link between his conduct and the company's inability to pay is proven. Zhanibek Mugadarov

Natalya Lukyanova

What Ultimately Protects Against Personal Liability for Company Debts

Protection rests on three pillars, and it works only when they are combined. The first is causation: it must be shown that insolvency arose not from a specific decision, but from circumstances the person did not influence. The second is written economic justification for decisions: calculations, explanatory notes, and risk analysis at the time they were made. The third is a complete set of primary documents confirming the reality of transactions and the movement of assets.

Proceedings assess the conduct of a specific person, not their status in the company: an entry in the charter or minutes by itself decides nothing. Therefore, it is useful to collect documents in chronological order in advance — this makes it clear when and why each decision was made.

  • the link between a decision and the deterioration of solvency
  • written justification of economic expediency
  • primary documents on transactions and the movement of funds

The earlier the evidence base is gathered, the smoother the proceedings go

Services on this topic

Bankruptcy of a legal entity Corporate lawyer Legal services for legal entities

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
When can the company's debt become the director's personal debt?

Only if the creditor proves that it was the director's decisions or inaction that led to the company being unable to pay. The mere fact of an LLP's debt does not create personal liability: as a general rule, the founder risks what was contributed to the charter capital, and the director risks losses from their decisions. The law allows an exception where the company has insufficient assets, but each time a causal link between the person's conduct and insolvency is required.

What exactly is attributed to the director and how can it be verified?

What is attributed is not the 'company's debt' but a specific decision or inaction with a date and consequence. The period when the obligation arose, the person's authority at that time and the fate of assets after the disputed step are cross-checked. This sequence rules out accusations unrelated to your role: another employee signed, a collegial body made the decision, the transaction was performed in the company's interests.

What grounds does the creditor cite?

Asset stripping, a knowingly disadvantageous transaction, concealment of property, failure to hand over documents and failure to apply to court where there are obvious signs of insolvency. For a participant, there are additionally instructions to the director whose execution led to bankruptcy. Each ground is considered separately — the general argument 'acted in the company's interests' does not close any of them.

Is the founder personally liable for an LLP's debts?

As a general rule, no: the company is liable, and the participant only within the limits of their contribution. Personal liability is possible if the creditor proves that the participant, through their decisions, drove the company to losses or bankruptcy. If the participant voted against or the decision was made without their participation, the creditor has nothing to prove their guilt with.

Who must prove guilt and what does this change for the defence?

The burden of proof lies with the creditor: they present documents and explain the causal link. The defence is built on counter-documents — a chronology of decisions and operations, orders and powers of attorney, confirmation of actual supplies and payments. If the link between the decision and insolvency is not confirmed, the claim against the person remains unproven; at Bonafacto, the assessment of such a dispute starts precisely with the documents.

Which mistakes harm the position?

Answering all accusations with the single phrase 'acted in the company's interests' — the court assesses each ground independently. The second mistake is 'cleaning up' papers: loss or alteration of documents is treated as bad faith and works against you. Record the handover of documents with an inventory stating the date and the signature of the receiving party, and restore lost papers through counterparties and the bank.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp