Real estate

Major repairs of a building: who decides and who pays

Major repairs of a building in Kazakhstan are carried out by decision of the owners of apartments and non-residential premises, and the costs fall on them through contributions to the building's savings account. We explain where the line is between major and routine repairs, how the general meeting decision is formalized, and what to check in the estimate and the minutes before work begins.

Major Repairs of an Apartment Building: Who Decides and Who Pays

A repair dispute begins with a payment document: a line for a contribution has appeared in it, but what exactly is being repaired and on what basis is unclear. The apartment owner and the owner of a ground-floor commercial premises ask the same question: who made the decision, is he obliged to pay, and where should he look if he disagrees with the decision.

Below is the boundary between routine and major repairs, the procedure for forming savings and calculating the contribution, the requirements for the minutes of the general meeting and the cost estimate, and acceptance of the works. Separately — protection of the owner's rights and objections in a dispute over contribution arrears.

Major home repairs: who makes the decision and on what basis

The decision on major repairs of a building is made by the general meeting of owners of apartments and non-residential premises — the management structure has no right to start work at its own discretion. The meeting determines the list of works, the source of financing and the procedure for carrying them out, and the number of votes must be sufficient under the Law of the RK "On Housing Relations".

Management of an apartment building is carried out by property owners' associations ( POA ) or simple partnerships under the same law. They organize the maintenance of common property and prepare estimates, but they do not decide the fate of repairs alone: their role is to prepare documents and put the matter to a vote.

Certain matters fall within the competence of the local executive body: dilapidated buildings, participation in state housing stock modernization programs, budget co-financing. The owners' decision is not replaced in this process — Bonafacto lawyers advise checking before the vote which matters actually require the involvement of the local executive body and which the meeting can resolve on its own.

Which works qualify as major repairs and which as routine maintenance

The classification of works determines the source of funding. Major repairs of the common property of an apartment building are the restoration or replacement of structural elements and engineering systems that have exhausted their service life, funded by the owners' accumulated contributions. Routine maintenance covers minor repairs, servicing, and the elimination of local faults, funded by regular payments.

Major repairs affect the common property and concern all owners. Their scope is determined by design and technical documentation, not by requests from individual residents. The decision is made by the owners of apartments and non-residential premises at a general meeting; without it, major works are not financed from the savings account. Bonafacto lawyers advise checking the list of works against the building's technical documentation before voting — otherwise the meeting risks approving an estimate for works that do not qualify as major repairs.

What is classified as major repairs and what is covered by routine maintenance:

  • replacement or restoration of in-building engineering systems for water supply, heating, wastewater disposal, and power supply;
  • repair or replacement of structural elements: foundation, load-bearing walls, floor slabs;
  • repair of the roof and roofing, including replacement of the covering and drainage devices;
  • replacement or modernization of elevator equipment and elevator shafts;
  • facade insulation and repair of enclosing structures;
  • servicing and minor routine repairs, maintaining equipment in working order.
Major and routine repairs: classification of works
Criterion Major repairs Routine repairs
Engineering systems Replacement or restoration of systems that have exhausted their service life Elimination of local faults, servicing
Structural elements Repair of foundation, walls, floor slabs Minor repairs without replacing structures
Roofing Replacement of covering and drainage Local repair of leaks
Elevator equipment Replacement or modernization of elevators Technical servicing and inspections
Decision Made by the owners at a general meeting Carried out as part of maintenance

Classifying works as major or routine repairs affects the procedure for their financing and for decision-making by the owners.

How to distinguish major repairs from routine maintenance in practice: a checklist

A dispute over the nature of the works is resolved on the basis of the building's documents, not the wording of a resident's request. Before the meeting, go through the points — this way the estimate will not mix the two types of funding.

  • Subject of the works: full replacement of an element or restoration of a component that has exhausted its service life — major repairs; elimination of a local fault — routine maintenance.
  • Basis: a defect report and design documentation from a specialized organization versus an ordinary service request.
  • Source of funds: accumulated contributions in the building's savings account versus regular maintenance payments.
  • Decision: minutes of the general meeting versus works within routine maintenance.
  • Estimate: approved by the meeting and attached to the contractor agreement — otherwise works are not paid for at the owners' expense.

A typical mistake is to include the replacement of risers and minor repair of valves in a single estimate: part of the costs ends up charged to the wrong source, and the minutes then have to be contested. Separate the lists before voting.

Who Pays for Major Repairs: Owners, Tenants, and the Budget

Under the Law of the RK "On Housing Relations," the burden of maintaining the common property of an apartment building rests with the owners of the premises. They make mandatory contributions for major repairs, which accumulate in the building's savings account; the amount of the contribution is determined by a decision of the general meeting. The building is managed by associations of property owners (APOs) or simple partnerships: they pool the funds and organize the work.

Tenants of the state housing fund and persons residing under a lease agreement pay for use and maintenance, but the obligation to accumulate funds for major repairs remains with the owner — the state or a private individual. The question of who pays for major repairs is decided by title to the premises, not by the fact of residence. Hence the practical consequence: the invoice is checked in the name of the owner, not the occupant — otherwise a debt dispute is addressed to the wrong person.

The sources that make up the financing of the work:

  • Contributions of premises owners to the building's savings account
  • Funds previously accumulated in the building account or held by the previous manager
  • Co-financing from the local budget under major repair programs
  • Funds of the owner — a state body, if the premises are in the communal fund
  • Other sources provided for by a decision of the meeting and the legislation of the RK

Each source is confirmed by a document: minutes of the meeting, an account statement, a contract with the previous management organization. Without such linkage, the estimate remains a calculation on paper.

Capital repair contributions: how savings are accumulated in the building's savings account

Capital repair contributions are mandatory payments by owners of apartments and non-residential premises in an apartment building. They accumulate in a savings account opened by the OSI or the simple partnership of that building. The payer is the owner of the premises, not the tenant or lessee, unless otherwise agreed in the contract.

The amount of the contribution is determined by a decision of the general meeting of owners. The charge is reflected in a single payment document, and receipts are recorded separately for each premises. Capital repair savings are not mixed with current payments for maintenance and utilities.

What is important to know about such payments:

  • contributions are mandatory for all owners of premises in the building
  • the basis for charging is the area of the premises
  • records are kept separately for each premises
  • funds may be spent only on capital repair of common property
  • information on the movement of funds is provided upon request of the owner

The savings account is not a common "piggy bank" of the building, but a targeted reserve for specific works. If an owner sells the premises, the savings for it remain in the building's account and do not leave with the seller: the new owner receives both the obligation to pay and the accumulated reserve.

Calculation of the capital repair contribution: what determines the amount

The amount of the capital repair contribution consists of the area of the premises, the rate per square meter and the accrual period. The basis is the area of the owner's premises in an apartment building: the larger it is, the higher the payment. The area is taken from the title and technical documents for the apartment or non-residential premises.

The second element is the rate per square meter. It is approved by the general meeting of owners, taking into account the condition of the building and the plan of upcoming works; there is no single nationwide rate. The third element is the accrual period: the payment is regular and is calculated for the months during which the person is the owner of the premises.

What affects the final amount:

  • the area of the apartment or non-residential premises owned by the owner
  • the contribution rate approved by the meeting of owners
  • the accrual period of the payment
  • decisions of the OSI or simple partnership on matters of the building's common property
  • a change in the rate by a new meeting of owners

The calculation comes down to multiplying the area by the rate, taking into account the period for which the payment is accrued. Check whether the area in the receipt matches the technical passport: a discrepancy changes the amount even if the rate has not been revised.

A dispute over capital repair almost always comes down to two documents: the minutes of the meeting and the estimate. If there are gaps in them, it is not the works themselves that have to be challenged, but the procedure by which they were assigned. Natalya Lukyanova

Aizhan Dzhunussova

Major Repairs and the General Meeting: How to Formalize the Owners' Decision

The decision on major repairs of common property is made by the owners of apartments and non-residential premises at a meeting. The initiators are the owners of the premises, the house council, or the management body — the chair of the OSI or an authorized representative of a simple partnership.

The meeting is valid with the participation of more than half of the total number of owners. The procedure for counting votes and the majority required for a decision on major repairs are established by the Law of the RK "On Housing Relations" — and it is this law that is checked when verifying the minutes. Bonafacto lawyers advise verifying the list of owners against the data on rights to the premises before voting: a discrepancy in the number of votes is a frequent cause of a dispute over the minutes.

The minutes are signed by the chair and secretary of the meeting and the members of the house council. Attached to them are registration sheets, powers of attorney, and voting sheets. They are kept by the management body of the house.

The minutes state the agenda, the voting results, and the decision. Errors give grounds to challenge the decision in court. Below are the key steps of the procedure in order.

  • Identify the initiator and convene the meeting with notification of the owners
  • Form the agenda with the item on major repairs of common property
  • Verify the quorum against the registration sheets and the number of votes
  • Hold the vote and count the votes on each item
  • Draw up the minutes with the signatures of the chair and secretary of the meeting and the members of the house council
  • Attach the voting sheets, powers of attorney, and registration sheets to the minutes

A practical tip on the documents: verify the dates of the notification, the holding of the meeting, and the signing of the minutes — they must form a logical sequence, and the representatives' powers of attorney must correspond to the voters. Keep the complete set of documents in one place: it is precisely this set that is used to verify the lawfulness of the decision if the dispute reaches court.

What the meeting's document set must contain

The meeting's document set is not only the minutes but also everything that confirms its preparation and conduct. It includes the notice of convening with the date of delivery, the participants' registration sheets, the representatives' powers of attorney, and the voting sheets on each agenda item. If even one part is missing, the reviewer will be unable to confirm either the quorum or the result.

  • Notice: records that the owners knew about the meeting and its agenda.
  • Registration sheets: show who attended and which premises they represent.
  • Powers of attorney: confirm the representative's right to vote on behalf of the owner.
  • Voting sheets: disclose the position on each item separately.

A typical mistake is "package" voting, when a single ballot mixes the list of works, the estimate, and the source of financing: then the minutes cannot show what exactly was approved. The second misstep is a power of attorney issued after the date of the meeting or to a person who is not on the registration sheets. The third is the absence of a signature of a member of the house council when the rest of the set is formally complete. Check the documents before the works begin, not after: the minutes cannot be reissued retroactively, and the meeting will have to be convened anew.

Errors in drawing up the minutes and the estimate: what to check before work begins

A dispute over major repairs rests on two documents — the minutes of the general meeting and the estimate. If they contain defects, the decision can easily be challenged, and the contractor will be left without an approved scope of work and a source of payment. Checking these papers before work starts is cheaper than litigation afterwards.

Typical defects in the minutes: lack of a quorum, violation of the procedure for notifying owners, inclusion of an item outside the agenda, unreliable vote counting. There are no fewer complaints about the estimate: it may be missing altogether, or it may change during the work without agreement with the owners. Each such point is an independent ground for objections.

  • Quorum: check that a sufficient number of owners participated in the meeting and that this is reflected in the minutes;
  • Notification: make sure that owners were notified of the meeting in the established manner, and not retroactively;
  • Agenda: verify that the item on repairs and their financing was put forward in advance;
  • Votes: recount the votes by area and cross-check against the register of owners;
  • Estimate: demand an approved document with the scope and types of work before it begins;
  • Changes: any adjustment to the estimate during the process must go through agreement with the owners.

Practical advice: request the minutes, the estimate and the voting register as a single package and cross-check the dates — a discrepancy in the chronology is a signal in itself. At Bonafacto, the cost of a stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, and the same principle should be applied to a contractor: first the approved scope and price, then the work.

Major repairs in a new building and in older housing stock

In a new building, the developer is responsible for the quality of structures and engineering systems — within the warranty period under the RK Law "On Shared Participation in Housing Construction." The warranty covers both apartments and common property: roofing, facade, risers, elevators. Until the period expires, the developer pays for remedying construction defects, and claims are submitted through the HOA or a simple partnership. A practical point: record defects in writing and immediately — after the warranty ends, proving their origin is more difficult.

In older housing stock, the costs fall on the owners: the law classifies as such work the restoration or replacement of structural elements and engineering systems with expired service life. The decision is made by the general meeting, costs are shared in proportion to shares, and savings are held in the house's savings account. Hence a non-obvious consequence — the fate of the repairs depends on the quality of the minutes, not only on the condition of the building.

  • Responsible party: in a new building — the developer under warranty, in older stock — the owners.
  • Basis: warranty obligations and the contract versus a meeting resolution.
  • Money: developer's funds versus residents' contributions and savings.
  • Management: in both cases — the HOA or a simple partnership.
New building vs. older housing stock: comparison
Criterion New building Older housing stock
Who is responsible Developer within the warranty Owners
Basis Law on shared participation, contract Law on housing relations, meeting resolution
Source of funds Developer under warranty Owners' contributions

Estimate and acceptance of major repair works

The estimate for major repairs of common property is formed on the basis of a defect report and the design documentation of a specialized organization. The calculation includes materials, works, technical supervision services and contingency costs. It is approved by the general meeting of owners of apartments and non-residential premises — without an approved estimate, works and their payment at the expense of the owners are not permitted. A practical guideline: check the list of works in the estimate against the defect report line by line, otherwise the construction contract will include a scope that no one agreed to.

The estimate is preliminarily reviewed by the house council, then approved at the meeting by a majority of votes. The approved estimate is an annex to the construction contract and is binding on the contractor; it may be changed during the works only with the consent of the owners. Any change to the scope or materials without such consent is grounds not to sign the work completion certificate.

Acceptance is carried out against the same estimate: the owners and the engaged technical supervision verify the actual scope, quality and compliance of materials, and record identified defects in a report with a list and deadlines for their elimination. A certificate signed without remarks closes the stage — therefore the inspection is carried out before signing, not after.

Major repairs and owner's rights: access to the apartment, inconvenience, damage

The owner is obliged to provide access to the apartment for major repair work, but has the right to know in advance who will carry it out and when. The client is the OSI or a simple partnership, and the contractor acts under a contract with it: the scope of obligations, deadlines and liability are determined by the contract, not by verbal agreements with residents. The work affects in-apartment risers, ventilation or utility networks — it cannot be performed without access to the premises.

Access does not mean free entry: demand prior notification, agreement on the time and your presence during the work. The client may challenge a refusal of access in court if the repair is necessary for the maintenance of common property. Practical advice: agree on the schedule in writing — this makes it easier to prove both the fact of notification and compliance with the deadlines.

If the work has damaged property, proceed step by step:

  • Record the damage in a report with a description, date and photographs
  • Obtain a copy of the works contract and the minutes of the owners' meeting on major repairs
  • Send a written claim to the client and the contractor demanding compensation
  • Keep evidence of expenses for restoring the property
  • Go to court if the claim is not satisfied voluntarily
  • If access for the work is refused — agree on a schedule and the owner's presence

It is better to draw up the report with the participation of a representative of the client or contractor: without their signature, the dispute over the cause of the damage comes down to words. Keep copies of documents until the proceedings are completed — they will be needed both for the claim and in court.

Challenging a capital repair decision and a contractor's actions

A meeting's decision and a contractor's actions can be challenged in court, but each of these disputes has its own subject of proof. A decision of the owners on capital repair of common property is challenged by a person who did not participate in the voting or voted against it — in cases of violations of the procedure for convening the meeting, absence of a quorum, unreliable counting of votes, or inclusion of an unannounced item on the agenda. The law limits the time period for filing, so the date on which the owner learned of the decision is documented in writing. Bonafacto lawyers advise starting with a copy of the minutes and the meeting materials: without them, the dispute turns into a retelling.

Claims regarding the works are brought against the contractor under a contract in which the client is the HOA or a simple partnership. Deviation from the design, delayed deadlines, poor-quality works and unremedied defects during the warranty period give the right to demand elimination of defects, a proportionate reduction in price and compensation for losses. This is proven by the terms of the contract, work completion certificates and an independent expert report — and it is better to record the defects before the contractor leaves the site.

Grounds for challenging a meeting's decision:

  • adoption of a decision in the absence of the required quorum
  • violation of the procedure for notifying owners of the meeting
  • inclusion of an item on the agenda that was not announced in advance
  • unreliable counting of votes and distortion of the voting results
  • adoption of a decision on an issue within the competence of another body
  • material violation of the owner's rights by the adopted decision

Collection of arrears on capital repair contributions: procedure and objections

The obligation to pay contributions arises for the owner of premises before the association of property owners or a simple partnership that manages the building under the Law of the RK "On Housing Relations". The amount of the contribution and the procedure for its payment are approved by the general meeting — the claim is based on this decision. The creditor is the association or partnership itself, not the akim, the CAO , or a contractor.

The obligation to pay contributions does not depend on whether the owner uses the premises, resides in it, or has received a separate payment document. The basis is the law, the decision of the general meeting, and data on the area of the premises. In case of delay, the creditor sends a pre-action claim and then files a lawsuit with the court at the location of the defendant or the property; at this stage, Bonafacto lawyers verify whether the right to claim has been confirmed for the specific premises and for which periods.

Objections to the claim are built on documents, not on general references to unfairness:

  • the decision of the general meeting was not adopted or was adopted without a quorum;
  • the amount of the contribution was not approved or was calculated incorrectly;
  • the amount has already been paid but was not reflected by the creditor;
  • the limitation period has expired for part of the periods;
  • the payment includes expenses not related to capital repair;
  • the creditor has not confirmed the right to claim for the specific premises.

Practical advice: keep payment documents and meeting minutes — in a dispute, they are precisely what shows for which period and at what rate the amount was assessed.

Conclusion

A major building renovation rests on three documents: the minutes of the general meeting, the approved cost estimate, and the works contract. Each of them covers its own area — the owners' decision, the scope and cost of the works, and the contractor's liability. If even one link is drafted with gaps, the dispute has to be resolved after the works have already begun or been paid for.

An owner should verify the quorum and agenda of the meeting, whether the cost estimate matches the adopted decision, and the calculation of the contribution. Violations should be documented: copies of the minutes and cost estimate, inspection reports, and correspondence with the management organization or contractor. Such a set of documents helps both when contacting the supervisory authorities and in court.

  • check the meeting agenda against the decisions actually adopted;
  • verify that the cost estimate was approved by the same decision as the works;
  • keep the works contract and the acceptance certificates for each stage;
  • record defects in the works in writing before signing the acceptance certificate.

Services on this topic

Housing and Utilities Lawyer

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Who makes the decision on major repairs of an apartment building?

The decision is made by the general meeting of owners of apartments and non-residential premises. The management structure — an OSA or a simple partnership — prepares the documents and puts the issue to a vote, but does not assign the work itself. The meeting determines the list of works, the source of financing and the procedure for carrying out the work.

Who is obliged to pay contributions for major repairs?

The owner of the premises pays, not the tenant or lessee, unless otherwise agreed in the contract. Contributions accumulate in the building's savings account, which is opened by the OSA or simple partnership. Therefore, the invoice is checked in the name of the owner — otherwise the debt dispute is addressed to the wrong person.

How to distinguish major repairs from routine repairs?

They look at the subject of the work and the source of funds. Replacement or restoration of an element that has exhausted its resource is major repairs at the expense of accumulated contributions; elimination of a local malfunction is routine maintenance at the expense of regular payments. The basis is also different: a defect report and design documentation versus an ordinary service request.

What determines the amount of the contribution for major repairs?

The amount consists of the area of the premises, the rate per square meter and the accrual period. The area is taken from title and technical documents; the rate is approved by the general meeting taking into account the condition of the building and the work plan. There is no single rate nationwide, so it is worth comparing the area in the invoice with the technical passport.

What must be in the meeting minutes and the estimate for the work to be paid for?

The estimate must be approved by the meeting and attached to the contractor agreement, otherwise the work at the expense of the owners is not paid. The list of works is compared with the technical documentation of the building so that routine works do not end up in the estimate. A typical mistake is to mix replacement of risers and minor repairs in one estimate: part of the costs will hang on the wrong source.

Where to look if the owner disagrees with the decision on repairs or with the accrual of the contribution?

A dispute about major repairs rests on two documents — the meeting minutes and the estimate. If there are gaps in them, it is not the work itself that has to be challenged, but the grounds and the calculation. At Bonafacto, they advise checking the list of works against the technical documentation before voting and checking which issues really require the participation of the local executive body.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp