Business

Partners' corporate agreement: why it is needed alongside the LLP charter

A corporate agreement is an arrangement among the LLP participants themselves that clarifies their agreements on voting, disposal of shares and management without replacing the charter. It applies only to those who signed it and allows the parties to secure what is inconvenient to reflect in the public charter.

Charter and corporate agreement between partners

A dispute between partners does not begin with the conflict as such, but from the moment one of them changes position: sells a share to a third party, votes differently at a general meeting, or stops participating in the affairs. The charter of an LLP rarely reflects such personal arrangements — it is public and designed for general rules, not for the private expectations of participants. A corporate agreement supplements the charter where the latter is silent and binds only those who have signed it.

Below we explain which terms may be included, which contradict the Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships," how to formalize the document, and what happens if it is breached. Separately — the mistakes that make the agreement useless in a disputed situation.

What a corporate agreement is and why partners in an LLP need one

An agreement among the participants of an LLP governing their mutual rights and obligations in managing the company and disposing of their shares — that is how this document is described in a nutshell. Relations among participants are governed by the Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships," but the charter does not cover all matters of running a business together. Agreements fill this gap: partners agree in advance on rules that are inconvenient or impossible to set out in the charter.

It is needed where the charter is silent or provides only a general framework: how to vote at a meeting, who decides when votes are tied, what to do in the event of a conflict. The agreement operates alongside the charter, not overriding it but clarifying the mechanics of interaction. Unlike the charter, which is available to third parties, it may contain confidential terms, including the procedure for distributing profit and resolving deadlock situations. Bonafacto lawyers advise agreeing on such a document before money and disputed decisions appear in the business — reaching an agreement later is more difficult.

What partners usually set out in the text:

  • Voting: the procedure for voting at the general meeting and how participants' special opinions are recorded.
  • Shares: rules and restrictions on the sale or pledge of a share, including the preemptive right.
  • Deadlocks: ways to resolve situations where votes are split and no decision is adopted.
  • Management: conditions for appointing the head and key employees of the LLP.
  • Finances: the procedure for distributing profit and covering losses among partners.
  • Exit: participants' obligations upon withdrawal from the LLP and settlement of the share.

How a corporate agreement differs from the charter

The charter is the constituent document of an LLP, binding on all participants, the partnership itself and its bodies; it is presented to banks, counterparties and state authorities. Amendments go through the general meeting and registration, so management cannot be restructured quickly. The charter sets the competence of the bodies, the decision-making procedure and the limits of the director's powers.

An agreement among the participants is a document of a different kind: it does not replace the charter, is not registered as a constituent document and is not disclosed to counterparties. It records what is not in the charter: how to vote at the meeting, to whom and at what price to sell a share, how to distribute dividends, who nominates the director. As a general rule, such arrangements do not create obligations for third parties. In case of conflict, the charter applies as the constituent document — the internal agreement operates to the extent that does not contradict it.

  • Accessibility: the charter is a public document, the agreement is internal.
  • Binding force: the charter — for all participants and bodies, the agreement — for those who signed it.
  • Amendment: the charter — through the general meeting and registration, the agreement — by agreement of the parties.
  • Priority: in case of conflict, the charter applies as the constituent document.
  • Registration: the charter is subject to state registration, the agreement is not.
Charter and participants' agreement: key differences
Criterion Charter Participants' agreement
Accessibility Presented to banks, counterparties and state authorities Internal, not disclosed
Binding force For all participants, bodies and the LLP itself Only for the participants who signed it
Amendment Decision of the general meeting and registration of amendments Agreement of the parties without registration
Priority Applies in case of conflict with the agreement Operates to the extent not contradicting the charter
Registration Subject to state registration Not registered

Drafting and formalizing agreements of this level is more convenient to do in parallel with a review of the charter: this makes it clear which matters are already covered by the constituent document and which should be moved into the participants' agreement.

How to read these two documents together

The practical meaning of the differences becomes clear when the documents are compared line by line. First, the charter is taken and everything it already regulates is written out: the competence of the meeting, the procedure for convening it, the director's powers, the rules for disposing of a share. Then, alongside, the matters that are not covered in the constituent document or are covered in general terms are written out — these become the subject of the participants' agreement.

  • Cross-checking wording: a term of the agreement must not restate the charter differently — a discrepancy in words creates grounds for a dispute.
  • Checking competence: if a matter falls within the exclusive competence of the general meeting, it is not rewritten in the agreement but recorded how the participants will vote.
  • Link to the charter: it is appropriate to include a clause in the text that the charter applies in case of conflict — this removes some conflicts in advance.
  • Currency: after the charter is amended, the agreement is re-read — some terms may become outdated or begin to contradict it.

A typical mistake is to prepare the agreement without opening the charter: then it contains terms that the constituent document already covers differently, and the priority of the charter turns against the partners. The second mistake is to leave in the agreement general assurances of good faith without the mechanics of performance: who does what and at what point. A workable combination is the charter as the basis of management and the agreement as a refinement to it, cross-checked against each other before signing.

The internal agreement of the participants does not replace the charter and does not create obligations for third parties.

What can be fixed in a corporate agreement between partners

Within a corporate agreement, the participants of an LLP record arrangements that are inconvenient or risky to disclose in a public charter. Relations between participants are governed by the Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships," and the parties rely on its provisions. The content depends on the partners' goals, but most often concerns management, voting, and disposal of shares.

The parties agree in advance how they will vote on specific agenda items of the general meeting, including on candidates for the executive body. Separately, they set out mechanisms for resolving deadlock situations when votes are split and no decision is adopted. Preparing the agreement at this stage comes down to one thing: converting the partners' oral arrangements into verifiable wording against which each party's actions can later be checked.

  • Voting: the procedure for voting at the general meeting on predetermined matters
  • Dividends: distribution of profit and the procedure for paying dividends
  • Sale of a share: prohibition or restriction on selling a share to third parties without the partners' consent
  • Preemptive right: participants' priority right to purchase a share
  • Major transactions: approval of major transactions and interested-party transactions
  • Deadlock situations: the procedure for resolving disputes and withdrawal from the participants

The practical point lies in the link with the charter: the charter is available to third parties, while arrangements on voting and transactions remain between the partners. Check that each item on the list has an addressee and a consequence — otherwise, in the event of disagreements, it will not work.

What cannot be included in a corporate agreement: legal restrictions

A corporate agreement in an LLP is governed by the Civil Code of the RK and the Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships". It is effective only between the parties and does not replace the charter — the constituent document retains priority. The limits are set by mandatory norms: anything that contradicts them does not work.

Terms that contradict mandatory norms are invalid, and a discrepancy with the charter gives rise to a dispute that is best avoided. It is not permitted to oblige a participant to vote contrary to an express prohibition of law, or to deprive them of the right to withdraw or the right to a share upon liquidation. The same applies to provisions that circumvent the competence of the general meeting and replace a decision of the body with a private transaction. Drafting the agreement begins with checking each clause for this conflict — otherwise part of the arrangement simply will not work.

What constitutes impermissible terms:

  • Contradiction of law: terms that diverge from mandatory norms.
  • Voting contrary to a prohibition: an obligation to act against an express instruction of law.
  • Deprivation of rights: waiver of the right to withdraw from the LLP or of the share upon liquidation.
  • Substitution of the meeting: replacing a decision of the general meeting with a private transaction.
  • Obligations for third parties: provisions that create them.
  • Exclusive competence: mechanisms assigned to the remit of the meeting.

How a corporate agreement protects shares and management in an LLP

Protection is built on mechanisms that fix the participants' behaviour in advance: restrictions on transferring a share to third parties, a pre-emptive right to purchase held by existing participants, and a ban on splitting a share without the partners' consent. Provisions on options and the procedure for increasing the charter capital prevent one participant from gaining control at the expense of the others, protecting against dilution of shares. The agreement does not replace the charter but supplements it. If no such mechanism exists, any corporate dispute comes down to the text of the charter, where no such arrangements were made.

What exactly is set out in the protective terms:

  • Transfer of a share: the procedure for approving transactions with shares and the ban on transferring them without the consent of the other participants.
  • Pre-emptive right: purchase of a share when it is sold to a third party and the mechanism for determining the price.
  • Voting: rules at the general meeting, including the list of matters decided unanimously.
  • Executive body: terms of appointment and removal, as well as control over its decisions.
  • Deadlock situations: the procedure for resolving them and for a participant's exit from the membership without harm to the others.
  • Liability: consequences of breaching the arrangements and ways to protect violated rights.

A corporate agreement works only where it contains enforcement mechanics: who does what and at what point, rather than general assurances of good faith. Dulat Abenov

Anna Kulzhemieva

When reviewing such a document, Bonafacto lawyers look at enforceability: each term must have a clear addressee and trigger point. The wording "act in good faith" protects only until the first disagreement — a workable construction always describes the action and its consequence.

How to conclude a corporate agreement: procedure and execution

The procedure comes down to four steps: agree on the terms among the participants, collect information about the company and the shares, prepare the text and have it signed by all parties with the date indicated. The written form is mandatory, while notarization and registration are not a general requirement — the document is not a constituent document, and information about it is not entered into the National Register of Business Identification Numbers.

Work begins with an inventory: the information about the company and the participants, the size and payment of shares, and the current version of the charter are checked. Then comes the drafting of the agreement — with voting on specific matters, the procedure for selling a share, a prohibition on competing transactions and mechanisms for resolving deadlock situations. The draft is cross-checked against the charter: there must be no discrepancies, otherwise the parties will end up with two different sets of rules.

  • Terms: the subject matter, the list of matters for agreed voting, and restrictions on disposing of shares are fixed.
  • Cross-check: each term is compared with the charter and the company's internal documents.
  • Signing: written form, signatures of all participants, date of execution — without a date the document is vulnerable.
  • Storage: a copy for each participant and for the company; if the composition of the parties changes, the text is revised.

At this stage, Bonafacto lawyers verify that the terms do not contradict the charter and do not duplicate it, and that the obligations are formulated in such a way that they can be performed and monitored. A practical tip: talk through out loud the scenario of one of the partners exiting — if there is no answer in the text, the agreement is not ready yet.

Who can be a party to a corporate agreement

The parties to a corporate agreement are primarily the LLP participants themselves at the time of signing. The scope of such persons is defined by the Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships". A participant signs the document personally or through a representative acting under a power of attorney — in that case the text states that the signatory acts on behalf of the participant, and a copy of the power of attorney is attached.

Participants may specify the voting procedure, the approval of transactions and the allocation of seats in management bodies. The agreement consolidates arrangements that they do not wish to disclose publicly and works alongside the charter without replacing it. A corporate lawyer reviews this document point by point: compares the wording with the charter, verifies the authority of the signatories and assesses whether a condition creates risks for the parties.

Participants may also assume obligations toward an external person — a creditor, an investor, a future buyer of a share. Such conditions are set out expressly, and the scope of this person's rights cannot contradict the charter and the law. Before signing, Bonafacto lawyers check who exactly is entering into the agreement and whether the representative has sufficient authority.

Amendment and Termination of the Corporate Agreement

This document can be amended and terminated by agreement of the parties, and in the event of a material breach of its terms by one of them — at the request of the other party through the court (Article 401, paragraphs 1, 2 of the Civil Code of the RK). The rules for drafting the agreement should be thought through in advance: the procedure for amendments, the form of the supplementary agreement and the list of grounds for early termination should be set out in the text itself, so that there is no dispute about the procedure later. Amendments are formalized in the same way as the main arrangement — as a single document or a supplementary agreement signed by all parties.

The document terminates upon expiry of its term, upon performance of obligations or upon a participant's withdrawal, if this is expressly provided for. The charter of the LLP remains in force regardless of amendments and termination — it is a separate constituent document, and its provisions apply on their own. Bonafacto lawyers advise stipulating in the text that termination does not cancel obligations that arose and were not performed before that moment.

  • Procedure for amendments: the common consent of the parties, unless the agreement establishes another procedure.
  • Form of the supplementary agreement: written, with the signatures of all parties to the agreement.
  • Grounds for termination: expiry of the term, performance of obligations, a participant's withdrawal — if this is provided for.
  • Court: termination at the request of a party in the event of a material breach of the terms by the other party (Article 401, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code of the RK).
  • Preservation of obligations: anything not performed before termination remains in force.

Liability for Breach of a Corporate Agreement

Liability for breach of a corporate agreement takes the form of sanctions that the parties themselves have set out in its text. The Law of the RK "On Limited and Additional Liability Partnerships" governs relations among the participants of an LLP, while the partners' agreement creates additional obligations between them. The remedies recorded in the document are designed precisely for their non-performance.

A breach is manifested in voting contrary to the agreed position, selling a share to a third party without offering it to the partners, or refusing to approve a candidate for director. The consequences depend on the instruments built into the text. The working mechanism is a penalty: it is recovered for the very fact of departing from a condition, without proving the amount of losses. An agreement on a penalty must be made in writing (Art. 294 of the Civil Code of the RK), so oral arrangements on sanctions do not work.

What can be provided for in the liability section:

  • Penalty: recovery for departing from the agreed conditions.
  • Losses: compensation for losses, including lost profit.
  • Specific performance: a demand to actually perform the obligation.
  • Transfer of the buyer's rights: to oneself, if the share was sold in violation of the preemptive right.
  • Sale of the share to the partners: the violator's obligation to sell it under a pre-agreed price formula.

Drafting an agreement for a business should begin with the question: which sanction will actually deter a partner from breaching it? Bonafacto lawyers fix the cost of the stage in the agreement before work begins, so the scope of developing the sanctions is discussed in advance. A stipulated protection mechanism is valuable exactly to the extent that it can be applied without a dispute over the interpretation of the conditions.

Verifying the counterparty and participants before signing

Before signing, the company's details and its participants, the current charter and its version, the authority of those who sign, and the consistency of the draft charter and the agreements are verified. A corporate lawyer calls this a basic cross-check: documents first, signature second. The check is needed so that the parties understand whom and on what terms they are dealing with, and so that internal agreements do not diverge from the constituent document.

The details of the partnership and the participants are cross-checked against each other: who is listed as a participant, in what amount, and whether this matches what the counterparties and documents say. The charter is reviewed separately — specifically its current version, not just any copy that comes to hand. The draft agreement is compared with the charter: if a clause of the internal agreement contradicts it, the charter prevails, and such a clause will not work.

The authority of the signatories is verified against documents: who has the right to act on behalf of the partnership, whether there are representatives acting under a power of attorney, and what exactly they are authorized to do. Signing takes place in person or through a representative — in the latter case, it is important to make sure that the representative has proper authority.

  • Company and participants: details of the partnership and the composition of participants.
  • Charter: the current version of the constituent document.
  • Authority: who signs and on what basis.
  • Representatives: the existence and scope of authority under a power of attorney.
  • Consistency: the draft is compared with the charter before signing.

Record any discrepancies with the charter in writing before signing — it is easier to agree on an amendment than to deal with it afterwards.

How the cross-check is carried out: sequence of steps

The cross-check is carried out in order — from the composition of participants to the text of the draft, otherwise the check falls apart into disconnected fragments. First, documents about the partnership are collected and it is confirmed who is a participant as of the signing date. Then the charter in its current version is obtained and everything relating to voting, the competence of the meeting, and the disposal of shares is copied out of it. After that, the draft corporate agreement is compared with these extracts clause by clause.

  • Composition of participants: the list is cross-checked against the partnership's documents, not the partners' memory.
  • Charter: provisions on voting, transactions with shares, and the powers of bodies are copied out.
  • Draft: each clause is marked as consistent with the charter or diverging from it.
  • Signatories: it is verified who signs in person and who acts under a power of attorney.
  • Result of the cross-check: discrepancies are documented in writing and the amendment is agreed before signing.

A typical mistake is to compare the draft with a charter that has already been replaced by a new version: then some of the agreements contradict the constituent document from the very start. The second is to take a partner's word about their share on trust without cross-checking it against the documents. The third is to sign the agreement without verifying the representative's authority: without proper authority, the signature does not bind the participant. It is useful to agree in advance who keeps the signed copy and how the parties will review its amendments.

How a corporate agreement works when an investor enters and a share is sold

When a new participant appears and when a share is disposed of, the participants' agreement continues to apply to those who signed it, while its terms pass to the buyer or investor only through a separate arrangement. Restrictions on the disposal of a share and the preemptive right to purchase allow the participants to control exactly who will join the partnership. The price determination mechanism is fixed in advance so that the sale does not turn into bargaining with a third party.

The obligations of an external person — a buyer, investor, pledgee — are set out expressly: either it signs the agreement or it undertakes to accede to it. Otherwise, the participants' arrangements do not apply to it, and it will not be possible to influence its conduct in the partnership. Options and the terms for increasing the charter capital are fixed in the same document so that the investor's entry follows a pre-agreed scenario.

  • New participant: signs the agreement or an undertaking to accede.
  • Sale to a third party: the restriction on disposal and the preemptive right to purchase are triggered.
  • Share price: determined by the mechanism fixed by the participants.
  • Pledge of a share: the terms and consequences are described in the text of the agreement.
  • Investor: entry is formalized through an option or an increase in charter capital.

If the procedure is breached, the dispute becomes a corporate dispute — with the transaction challenged and a demand to restore control over the share. When selling a share, check whether the buyer has signed the agreement or an undertaking to accede to it: without this, the agreed rules do not extend to it.

What to check in a completed corporate agreement: a checklist

A completed document is checked against six points: verification against the charter, mechanics of performance, consequences of breach, clarity of wording, procedure for amendment and termination, and recording of breaches. Such a run-through takes less time than sorting out the consequences of an unclear clause after a conflict. Below is what to look at for each point.

  • Verification against the charter: the provisions must not contradict the constituent document or the competence of the partnership's bodies.
  • Mechanics of performance: each obligation must describe the procedure — who does what and in what sequence.
  • Consequences of breach: opposite each obligation — a sanction or other result of its non-performance.
  • Clarity of wording: remove ambiguous phrases that allow different readings.
  • Amendment and termination: check how the parties change the terms and exit the agreement.
  • Recording of breaches: it must be clear how the fact of non-performance is confirmed.

Separately, it is worth assessing how well the text takes into account the actual structure of the business: who makes decisions, how roles are distributed, what happens when participants change. Drafting an agreement for a business is conveniently done in parallel with checking the charter — that way discrepancies are visible immediately rather than surfacing at a meeting.

Run the text through the checklist before signing: edits to a draft cost less than a dispute over the interpretation of a clause once the partners have already taken different positions.

Stages of work with a corporate agreement: action and result
Stage What is done Result
Negotiation of terms Translate the partners' oral agreements into verifiable wording List of issues for agreed voting and restrictions on shares
Verification against the charter Compare each term with the current version of the charter No discrepancies, priority of the charter taken into account
Signing Written form, signatures of all participants, date of execution Document, vulnerability without a date eliminated
Storage A copy for each participant and at the company Review of the text when the composition of parties changes
Review of the final text Run through the checklist before signing Amendments to the draft are cheaper than a dispute over the interpretation of a clause

What a corporate agreement ultimately gives partners

A corporate agreement supplements the charter but does not replace it: it records the arrangements among the participants with each other, whereas the charter remains the constituent document binding on the partnership and its bodies. In the event of a discrepancy, the charter prevails — the terms of the agreement apply to the extent that they do not contradict it. Therefore, the agreement works only where it contains a mechanism (who votes and how, to whom and on what terms a share is sold, how a decision is made) and consequences for non-compliance with it.

The practical conclusion is simple: it is worth starting with a list of situations that the partners want to address — a change of director, a participant's withdrawal, the sale of a share to a third party, a deadlock in voting. Each term is then checked against the charter and the law: what is already regulated in the constituent document, what can be set out in the agreement, and what will remain outside it. This order of work saves time in negotiations and reduces the risk that some of the arrangements will prove unworkable.

Services on this topic

Legal support for business Corporate lawyer

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Why is a corporate agreement needed if there is an LLP charter?

The charter sets the general framework: the competence of the bodies, the decision-making procedure, the limits of the director's powers. It rarely reflects the partners' personal arrangements — how to vote, to whom and at what price to sell a share, how to distribute profit. The corporate agreement supplements the charter where the latter is silent and binds only the participants who signed it.

What can be secured in a corporate agreement?

The voting procedure at the general meeting on predetermined matters, including candidates for the executive body. Restrictions on the sale or pledge of a share, the participants' pre-emptive right to purchase it, approval of major transactions and interested-party transactions. Separately, they set out profit distribution and mechanisms for resolving deadlock situations when votes are split.

How does a corporate agreement differ from the charter?

The charter is a constituent document: it is binding on all participants, the partnership itself and its bodies, it is presented to banks, counterparties and state authorities, and amendments go through the general meeting and registration. The participants' agreement is an internal document: it is not registered as a constituent document, is not disclosed to counterparties and applies only to those who signed it. In case of conflict, the charter prevails, and the agreement applies to the extent that does not contradict it.

What happens if a term of the agreement contradicts the charter or the law?

In case of discrepancy with the charter, the constituent document prevails, so the term of the agreement works only to the extent that does not contradict it. Terms that diverge from mandatory norms are invalid. It is better to check each clause for such a conflict before signing — otherwise part of the agreement simply will not work.

What terms cannot be included in a corporate agreement?

It is impossible to oblige a participant to vote contrary to an express statutory prohibition, to deprive them of the right to withdraw from the LLP or of the right to a share upon liquidation. Provisions that replace a general meeting decision with a private transaction or circumvent its competence, as well as terms creating obligations for third parties, are inadmissible. The agreement applies only between the parties and does not replace the charter.

When is it better to conclude a corporate agreement and how should it be prepared?

It is worth agreeing on the document before money and disputed decisions appear in the business — later it is harder to reach an agreement. It is more convenient to prepare it in parallel with a review of the charter: first, everything the constituent document already regulates is written out, then the matters it does not cover. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so the scope of the review is visible in advance.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp