Business
Securing performance of obligations: what to choose in a contract
Securing performance of obligations is a mechanism that allows the creditor to get what is due if the counterparty breaches the contract. The Civil Code of the RK names several methods, and each protects the creditor's interests differently. Let's examine how they differ and how to choose the appropriate one for a specific transaction.
People come with a question about securing the performance of obligations in two situations: when the counterparty has already missed deadlines or stopped responding, and the contract has no provision that would allow you to get what is yours quickly, and when a transaction is only being prepared — then you need to understand in advance which mechanism will work: a penalty, a pledge, a surety, or something else. Security is arranged before the main contract is signed or simultaneously with it, and how realistic it is to recover a debt or achieve performance depends on the chosen structure.
Below are the methods named by the Civil Code of the RK, and the logic for choosing between them: contract terms, industry-specific nuances for loans, leases, and construction contracts, and situations in which the security does not work. The guidelines are intended for a reader in Almaty who is encountering this for the first time.
What security for the performance of obligations is and when it comes into consideration
These are additional legal mechanisms that increase the creditor's chance of actually obtaining performance. The principal obligation answers the question "what and when the debtor must do": repay a loan, pay rent, deliver goods, perform work. Security arrangements answer a different question — what happens if the principal debt is not performed or is performed improperly.
The point is to narrow the room for bad-faith conduct and give the creditor leverage without letting the situation escalate into a lengthy dispute. This also benefits the debtor: it demonstrates seriousness of intent and helps obtain a deferral, installment plan or softer terms. At Bonafacto, such terms are analyzed before the contract is signed — the documents are reviewed first, then the prospects are assessed.
The main methods worth keeping in mind when negotiating a contract:
- Penalty: a sum of money for delay or improper performance.
- Pledge: property from which the creditor obtains satisfaction.
- Retention: the creditor retains the debtor's item until the obligation is performed.
- Suretyship: a third party is liable to the creditor together with the debtor.
- Guarantee: the guarantor is liable to the creditor for the debtor's non-performance of the obligation.
- Deposit: a payment confirming the conclusion of the contract and securing its performance.
A practical tip: choose the method according to the type of risk — money is better covered by a penalty and a deposit, items and work by a pledge and retention, and a counterparty's weak solvency by suretyship or a guarantee.
Types of security for the performance of obligations: a brief overview and the logic of choice
The Civil Code of the RK names the following methods of security: penalty, pledge, retention of the debtor's property, suretyship, guarantee, deposit and others provided for by law or contract. The list is open: the parties may also agree on a structure not expressly named, for example a security payment. The choice depends on what matters more — swift compulsion to perform, retaining control over an item, or bringing a third party to liability for the debt. That is why the types of security for the performance of obligations are selected for a specific transaction rather than by template.
All methods are divided into personal and proprietary. Personal security adds another obligated subject alongside the debtor: the surety and the guarantor are liable with their own property together with the principal debtor. Proprietary security ties the creditor to a specific asset — pledge, retention; in the event of non-performance, the creditor obtains priority over other creditors in respect of that item. The penalty, deposit and security payment occupy an intermediate position: they are monetary incentives that work without separate property.
- Penalty: a sum of money for delay or other breach; suitable for transactions with regular payments and deliveries.
- Pledge: the creditor obtains priority over the pledged item; appropriate for lending and instalment sales secured by a valuable asset.
- Retention: a creditor in possession of the debtor's item is entitled not to return it until performance; convenient in construction contracts, carriage and storage.
- Suretyship: a third party is liable together with the debtor; used when the principal debtor has insufficient property.
- Guarantee: the guarantor's obligation to pay the creditor upon breach of the terms; in demand in banking and large commercial transactions.
- Deposit and security payment: sums of money that incentivise performance; the deposit is intended to confirm the conclusion of the contract, while the security payment is intended to cover possible losses.
| Method | What it gives the creditor | When it is appropriate | Who is liable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penalty | A monetary claim for breach | Delays, regular deliveries | Debtor |
| Pledge | Priority over the pledged item | Loan, instalment sale secured by an asset | Debtor, pledgor |
| Retention | Right not to return the item | Construction contracts, carriage, storage | Debtor |
| Suretyship | An additional debtor | Insufficient property of the debtor | Surety |
| Guarantee | Payment by the guarantor upon breach | Large commercial transactions | Guarantor |
| Deposit, security payment | A monetary incentive to perform | Prepayment and framework transactions | Debtor |
The table is best read row by row: on the left is the method, then what it gives the creditor, in which transaction it is appropriate and who is ultimately liable. The methods can be combined: for example, a penalty together with a pledge or suretyship strengthens the creditor's position.
How to verify the chosen method before signing
The verification comes down to one question: what exactly will the creditor be able to claim if the debtor stops performing. Then follow three steps that take little time but remove some of the risks already at the negotiation stage.
- Match the method to the subject matter of the transaction: money is protected by a penalty, deposit or suretyship, an item — by pledge or retention.
- Check the obligated person: the surety and the guarantor must have property, otherwise the additional debtor remains on paper.
- Describe the mechanism: at whose expense, in what manner and when the creditor obtains satisfaction — without this the clause is formal.
- Link the documents: a separate security agreement is tied to the main contract — the parties, the subject matter, the secured obligation.
- Check the encumbrances: information on prior pledges shows whether the item will be sufficient for all creditors.
A typical mistake is to name the method and stop there: the contract contains the word "pledge", but the item is not described in a way that allows it to be individualised. The second is to leave the security without a link to a specific obligation, and then the dispute is already about what is secured and to what extent. The third is to rely on a surety without finding out what it is liable with. The practical guideline is simple: if the mechanism cannot be restated in one sentence, the clause should be rewritten before signing.
Penalty as Security for Performance of Obligations: When It Works
A penalty is a sum of money that the debtor is obliged to pay to the creditor upon breach of a condition, over and above the principal debt. It works simply: breach it — pay for it. Hence its place in supply, construction, and lease contracts: including a penalty clause is cheaper than subsequently proving losses.
A distinction is made between statutory and contractual penalties. The statutory one applies regardless of whether the parties have stipulated it — it is sufficient that it be established by a rule of law. The contractual one applies only when the parties have expressly agreed to it in the text, specifying the calculation procedure and the basis. If there is no such condition, a contractual penalty cannot be recovered.
Three things matter in a contract: the accrual base (the amount of the debt or the cost of a stage), the rate and the period for which the late-payment charge is calculated, as well as the very breach for which liability arises. The more specific the wording, the fewer disputes about the calculation. A vague "for each day of delay" without reference to the amount turns the clause into the subject of a separate claim.
- Statutory penalty: applies by force of a rule of law, regardless of a condition in the contract.
- Contractual penalty: applies only upon express agreement by the parties.
- Late-payment charge: accrued for the period of delay; a fine is imposed once for the breach.
- Proportionality: the amount of the penalty must correspond to the consequences of the breach.
- Reduction: a clearly inflated amount gives the debtor grounds to request a reduction.
- Judicial assessment: the court has the right to reduce the penalty if it finds it disproportionate.
Pledge and retention: proprietary security for the performance of obligations
A pledge is an agreement concerning a thing or a right; retention is the creditor's statutory right to withhold a thing until settlement. Both mechanisms tie a specific object to an obligation, and in the event of non-performance the creditor obtains priority over other claimants. Movable and immovable property, as well as property rights, may be pledged.
A pledge arises from a contract and, in cases expressly provided by law, also from the law itself. The contract must include the subject matter with a description allowing it to be identified, its valuation, the essence and amount of the secured obligation, the term for its performance, who retains the pledged thing, the creditor's right to inspect its condition, and the procedure for foreclosure.
- Subject matter of the pledge: a description allowing the thing or right to be individualized
- Secured obligation: essence, amount and term of performance
- Possession and control: who retains the subject matter and how the creditor inspects its condition
- Foreclosure: the procedure for foreclosure and sale of the subject matter
- Encumbrances: information on prior pledges
Retention is formalized differently: it does not require a separate agreement, but it operates only while the thing is held by the creditor — once it is returned, the protection ends. Therefore, the contract records the terms of storage and return of the retained thing.
Suretyship and guarantee in the system of securing performance of obligations
Suretyship is built on the figure of a third party: the surety is liable to the creditor for the debtor. The basis is a suretyship agreement between the creditor and the surety in written form. Under the Civil Code of the RK, the surety as a general rule is liable jointly and severally with the debtor, unless the agreement or legislation provides for subsidiary liability.
A guarantee under the Civil Code of the RK is close to suretyship: the guarantor is liable to the creditor for the debtor's non-performance of an obligation, as a general rule subsidiarily, unless the agreement provides for joint and several liability. Separately, RK legislation regulates bank guarantees. A security payment is closer to a deposit and an advance payment: the amount is paid in advance, is set off against performance or is returned; its coercive function is weaker.
- Suretyship: a third party is liable for the debtor, jointly and severally by default; the basis is a written agreement with the creditor.
- Guarantee: the guarantor's liability, subsidiary by default; a bank guarantee is regulated separately.
- Security payment: money is paid in advance and goes toward performance or is returned — the leverage is weaker than that of suretyship.
Security rarely saves the day after the fact: its value lies in having been stipulated and formalized before the counterparty breached the obligation. Zhanibek Mugadarov
What to Compare When Choosing Security for the Performance of Obligations: A Clear Table
Choosing a method of protection begins with the question of what exactly the creditor receives upon breach: a monetary claim or access to a specific thing. A penalty and a deposit are usually set out in the main contract, whereas a pledge and suretyship require separate execution. The complexity of enforcement depends on whether it must be directed at a thing or whether it is sufficient to bring a claim against the obligated person.
It is more convenient to compare the options across six parameters:
- who is liable: the debtor, a third party or specific property;
- whether a separate transaction and its registration are required;
- whether the obligated person has liquid property;
- how simple and quick it is to enforce;
- whether the protection depends on the preservation of the subject matter;
- whether several methods can be combined in one contract.
| Method | What serves as the guarantee | Separate transaction | Property held by the obligated person | Complexity of enforcement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penalty | A monetary claim against the debtor | No, usually in the contract | Not required | Medium: delay must be proven |
| Pledge | Specific property | Yes | Yes, the pledged item | Higher: enforcement against the thing |
| Retention | A thing that has come into the creditor's possession | No, follows from law | Yes, but not any | Medium: depends on possession |
| Suretyship | Liability of a third party | Yes | Held by the surety | Medium: claim against the surety |
| Guarantee | Obligation of the guarantor | Yes | Held by the guarantor | Depends on the terms of the guarantee |
| Deposit | Payment and liability of the parties | Often in the contract | Not required | Lower: tied to the main obligation |
The table is read row by row: each row shows exactly what secures the obligation and what will have to be proven in a dispute. Methods can be combined; the choice depends on the subject matter of the transaction and the risk.
How to Verify the Chosen Method Before Signing
The table provides guidance, but the decision is verified against the counterparty's documents and the text of the clause. The procedure is as follows: first determine what exactly is being protected — money, a thing or the quality of work, then check whether the obligated person has anything to answer with, and only after that choose the structure.
- Counterparty check: request information on property and encumbrances — this determines whether suretyship or pledge will provide real protection.
- Cross-check with the main contract: the security clause must not contradict the terms and scope of the main obligation.
- Reading the clause in full: the method is named but the mechanism is not disclosed — which means there is nothing to operate upon breach.
- Checking the annexes: a separate agreement without a link to the contract leaves open the question of what is secured and to what extent.
A practical guideline: if, under the chosen method, it is impossible to answer in advance what the creditor will obtain satisfaction from, the structure has been chosen unsuccessfully — it is changed before signing, not after a breach.
Securing performance of obligations in a contract: wording and risks
The clause must specify the method, the amount, the procedure for application and the moment it takes effect — without these four elements the condition does not work. If the method is named but the mechanism is not set out, the clause remains formal and does not protect the creditor in the event of a breach.
A separate agreement requires a link to the main contract: the parties, the subject matter, the obligation secured. Without it, disputes arise over which obligation is secured and to what extent. Bonafacto lawyers begin their contract review with precisely this link — it holds the entire structure together.
If the condition is absent or incomplete, the creditor loses additional instruments and must prove the breach in the general manner. The gap cannot be filled retroactively: correspondence does not replace an agreed clause.
What to check before signing:
- State the method of security directly in the text of the contract or in an annex to it.
- Link the security agreement to a specific main obligation with its details.
- Set out the mechanism: from what, in what procedure and when the creditor obtains satisfaction.
- Check the security clause against the terms of the main contract — contradictions work against the creditor.
- Record the consequences of invalidity or termination of the main obligation for the security.
Securing performance of obligations in loans, lease and construction contracts: industry-specific nuances
The choice of security method depends on what needs to be protected: repayment of money, preservation of property or quality of work. In a loan, the creditor's interest is focused on repayment of the amount, so security is built around pledge and suretyship: a pledge gives priority over a specific item, while suretyship adds a second obligated person alongside the debtor. If money is advanced against a future delivery, the pledge or suretyship clause is best set out in the same document as the payment schedule — otherwise, if shipment fails, the security will have to be renegotiated from scratch.
In a lease, the main risk is not so much non-payment as the condition of the property and timely vacating. Security for lease obligations usually rests on a security deposit and a penalty: the deposit covers debt and damage to property, while the penalty enforces deadlines. It is important to describe the security deposit so that it is clear what it is withheld for and in what procedure the remainder is returned. Practical advice: list in the contract exactly which damages and debts are covered by the deposit, and state that the remainder is returned after signing the premises handover act.
In a construction contract, what is protected is not the repayment of money but the result of the work and the deadlines. Here, a penalty for delay and retention apply: the customer is entitled not to pay for a stage until defects are remedied, and the contractor — to hold back the result until payment. Bonafacto lawyers advise describing the retention procedure in the construction contract itself, tying it to the stage acceptance act.
When security for the performance of obligations fails: common mistakes
A security arrangement does not protect the creditor if it is executed with violations: errors at conclusion reduce its meaning to zero. A surety for a person without property does not cover the debt — there are simply no assets that can be foreclosed upon. An unexecuted pledge gives the same result: no contract in the required form, no registration where it is mandatory, or no item in kind. Risks increase when there is no check of what the surety or pledgor is liable with.
Before signing, Bonafacto lawyers verify the security transaction against the main contract using the following checklist:
- Property: check whether the surety has real property and income that can be foreclosed upon.
- Form of pledge: make sure the contract is concluded in writing, contains an exact description of the item, and is registered if required.
- Time limits: compare the surety and pledge periods with the date of performance of the main obligation and with the moment the claim is presented.
- Consistency of terms: compare the main contract and the security transaction — a change in the amount, term, or obligation without the surety's consent deprives the protection of meaning.
- Liability: check the wording on the scope of liability and the grounds — they must be defined unambiguously.
- Evidence: keep documents on the transfer of the pledged item, the deposit, and the agreements — without them, challenge or foreclosure becomes difficult.
Securing evidence: why it is needed before a dispute
Recording information and facts before they disappear or become unavailable is a distinct legal institution. It is not connected to measures that compel a debtor to perform an obligation and serves a different purpose — to preserve information for future proceedings. The logic is simple: recording is needed where the medium of information may be lost, altered, or cease to be accessible.
Consider a messenger chat, the condition of premises at handover, or a website with an advertisement — all of these exist on their own terms and can change at any moment. A fact recorded in advance helps a dispute rely on a verified picture rather than on the parties' recollections. Practical advice: collect and record information before going to court, while access to the source is still available.
Bonafacto lawyers consider securing evidence together with the case documents: they first study the materials and only then assess the prospects — including the question of what should be recorded and how. This approach makes it possible to understand which information is actually needed for the position and which need not be collected. Separately, they clarify the method by which the information should be recorded so that it remains suitable for the proceedings.
Notarial Evidence Preservation: How It Works in Practice
Recording information that may be needed in a dispute by a notary is what notarial evidence preservation is. People turn to it when a fact needs to be officially established: correspondence, the condition of an item, the circumstances of document handover. The result is a formalized notarial act, a written confirmation of exactly what was recorded and at what moment. Such a document does not resolve the dispute, but it preserves the picture of events as it existed before the proceedings.
The procedure is built step by step. First, it is determined which specific fact is being recorded — this determines the set of materials. Then the documents are prepared: what is to be attested and the papers confirming the lawfulness of the request. After that, one applies to the notary, and as a result receives a formalized document. Notarial actions can be arranged with a notary at the Bonafacto practice, within the same company — this is convenient when preparations for a dispute are underway nearby.
- Identify the fact: what exactly needs to be established and why.
- Gather documents: the materials to be recorded and supporting papers.
- Apply to the notary with the prepared package.
- Receive a formalized document with the recorded information.
Practical tip: it is better to record the circumstances before the counterparty learns of the dispute. While the situation has not yet escalated into a conflict, the information is preserved in its natural form — which means it is also easier to confirm.
Termination and Amendment of Security for the Performance of Obligations
When the principal debt has been duly performed, the security terminates automatically — no separate agreement is required. An accessory obligation follows the fate of the principal one: the debt disappears, and so does its security. The reverse is not true — termination of a pledge or suretyship does not by itself extinguish the principal debt.
The parties may amend the security in the same form as the original transaction. If the principal obligation is amended without the surety's consent in a way that increases its liability (for example, the debt amount grows), the suretyship terminates under the Civil Code of the RK. A third-party pledgor should also agree such amendments in advance — otherwise it risks being left without proprietary protection.
Grounds on which security ceases to be effective:
- performance of the principal obligation in full;
- expiry of the suretyship period without a claim being filed;
- loss of the pledged item or termination of the pledged right;
- amendment of the principal obligation without the consent of the surety or pledgor;
- agreement of the parties to replace one method of security with another;
- transfer of the debt to another person without the consent of the surety or pledgor.
Securing performance of obligations: steps for a reader from Almaty
The actions form a single route: assess the risk, choose the method, verify the counterparty, formalize the documents. Which mechanism is suitable depends on the likelihood of non-performance and the amount of possible damage. For monetary claims, a pledge or suretyship is used; for non-monetary ones, a penalty and a deposit are sufficient.
Counterparty verification takes place before signing: information on registration, the composition of participants, and encumbrances on property is reviewed in open sources — this shows whether the party has assets to answer with. Bonafacto lawyers begin by studying the documents and only then assess the prospects. The form is chosen to match the method: notarial certification or simple written form, if the law does not require otherwise, and in a pledge agreement the subject and the substance of the secured obligation are described so that they can be determined unambiguously.
Sequence of steps:
- Determine exactly which obligation is being secured and what the amount of risk is.
- Choose the method: penalty, pledge, retention, suretyship, guarantee, deposit.
- Verify the counterparty and its property using open sources.
- Draft the security agreement and the main agreement without contradictions.
- Certify the documents with a notary when required by law.
- Register a pledge of real estate in the legal cadastre through the PSC or eGov; a pledge of movable property — in the register of pledges of movable property, if registration is mandatory for it.
Key points at a glance
The choice of method comes down to two questions: how great the risk of non-performance is and whether the obligated party has property that can be subjected to enforcement. If there is little property, the emphasis is placed on personal security — suretyship or a guarantee, which add another defendant to the debtor. When there is an asset, a pledge or retention works: they tie the creditor to a specific thing.
Security should be arranged before a breach, not after: a pledge agreement, suretyship agreement or penalty agreement is concluded together with the main contract or at the stage of its performance. Evidence — correspondence, acts, records of the condition of property — is collected in advance, while the parties are still communicating. This is not a formality: without documentary confirmation of the terms of the dispute, any arrangement loses its force.