Intellectual property
Photo Use Claim: What to Check Before Responding
A photo use claim is a written demand from the rights holder or the photographer to stop publication and resolve the matter before court. Whether it makes sense to respond on the merits or simply request confirmation of rights depends on which documents are attached and what exactly is claimed.
A letter about someone else's photo on a website, on social media, or in a commercial publication arrives without warning, and the first reaction is to delete the photo and close the matter. Such a step does not cancel the stated claims: you will still have to deal with it, but without the disputed material at hand. It is calmer to first record what was published and when, and then read the claim line by line.
Below — how to distinguish a justified request from a formal one, which attachments should accompany it, and what to look at in the deadlines and demands before writing a response.
Photo Use Claim: Where to Start the Review
You should start by documenting everything: save the document itself along with its attachments and note the date you received it. Such a letter is a rights holder's demand addressed to the person who posted the image without permission. It is sent by the author, photographer, a rights holder under a contract, or a representative; the basis is the Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights." The text usually asks you to stop the use, remove the material, and settle the dispute.
Next, establish where and when the photo was posted and who uploaded it. Do not delete the materials or correspondence — they will be needed to support your position. Bonafacto lawyers advise checking right away whether there is the author's permission, a contract, or another basis for publication, and only then responding in writing.
- Record the date and method of receiving the claim, and save the document and its attachments.
- Establish where, when, and by whom the disputed image was posted.
- Check whether there is the author's permission, a contract, or another basis for publication.
- Preserve the correspondence, source files, and information about the photo's author.
- Prepare a written response to the claim setting out your position.
- Determine who is responsible for the publication: the recipient, an employee, or a contractor.
Who may send a claim for the use of a photo and on what basis
The demand is sent by the person who owns the exclusive right to the image: the author-photographer or a person who has acquired the rights under a contract or by way of succession. Photographs are protected as works; the right arises from the fact of creation, so for a claim it is sufficient to confirm authorship.
If the exclusive rights have been transferred under an author's contract on the transfer of exclusive rights, the demand is made by the acquirer. Under an author's commission contract, the photographer retains personal non-property rights, while the exclusive right may belong to the customer. A trustee is also entitled to bring claims in the interests of the right holder — but strictly within the scope of the powers granted.
- Author of the image: an individual who created the photograph through creative effort.
- Photographer under an author's commission contract: if the exclusive right has not been transferred to the customer.
- Right holder under a contract: the acquirer of exclusive rights under an author's contract on transfer.
- Trustee: as well as an organization for collective management of property rights — within the scope of their powers.
- Successor: a person who has acquired the exclusive right by way of universal succession.
- Author in respect of personal rights: protects non-property rights regardless of the transfer of the exclusive right.
Practical guideline: verify the sender's status against the document they refer to — a contract, a certificate or the trustee's authority. If the chain of rights cannot be traced, the basis for the claim remains unconfirmed.
What documents must be attached to a claim for the use of a photo
The claim must be accompanied by documents confirming two circumstances: the claimant is genuinely authorized to protect the specific image, and it is precisely this image that was published on the addressee's website. Copyright in Kazakhstan is governed by the RK Law "On Copyright and Related Rights," so a pre-trial demand without supporting papers looks unfounded. When reviewing the attachments, one should check not their number but whether they form a continuous chain from the author of the photograph to the sender of the letter.
Rights to a photograph are confirmed by contracts: an author's contract, a contract on the transfer of exclusive rights, a license agreement, or an employment contract if the image was created by an employee. When rights pass along a chain, all of its links must be attached; otherwise, the defendant will claim the claimant is improper. A copy of the image in the original file with metadata links the object of the claim to the publication on the infringer's website.
When going through the envelope, it is convenient to follow this list:
- Contract with the author: shows how the right to the photograph came to the claimant.
- Acceptance certificate: records that the specific file was transferred under the contract.
- Original file with metadata: links the photograph to the date and device of capture.
- Screenshot of the publication: shows the page where the image is posted and the date it was recorded.
- Power of attorney: required if the letter was signed by a representative rather than the rights holder themselves.
If even one link is missing, the demand rests on words rather than documents — and it can be answered more calmly by requesting the missing items.
Pre-trial claim for a photo: is it mandatory before court
No, in disputes over the use of images the pre-trial procedure is not mandatory: neither the CPC nor copyright legislation establishes it. Photographs are protected as works regardless of artistic value, and the dispute is considered under the general procedure. A pre-trial claim is a right, not an obligation of the rights holder.
It becomes mandatory if the parties included a condition on the claim procedure in the contract (license, author's contract) or the dispute arises from a contract for which the law expressly provides for mandatory settlement. If the infringement is not connected with a contract, the court will accept the claim without a pre-trial claim. Hence the practical conclusion: first of all, one looks not at the text of the demands, but at whether there is a contract between the parties and what it says.
Several points are worth checking — they set the logic of the answer:
- Whether the contract with the defendant contains a clause on the claim procedure.
- Whether the dispute arises from a contract or from non-contractual use of the image.
- Whether a mandatory pre-trial procedure is established by law for the specific type of dispute.
- Whether the limitation period is expiring and whether it requires suspension.
- Whether the rights to the photograph and the fact of its use by the defendant are confirmed.
- Whether the addressee of the claim and the method of its delivery with confirmation of receipt are determined.
If there is no contract and a demand has arrived, this is not a reason to ignore the letter: silence does not stop the preparation of the claim, whereas the collected evidence of the use of the image and a response on the merits help build the position in advance.
Deadlines in a photo use claim: what to look at
The voluntary settlement period in a photo use claim is set by the rights holder: they name the date by which they expect a response or payment, and the law does not fix this period. If no period is specified, rely on the time sufficient to receive the letter and prepare a reasoned response. Bonafacto lawyers advise first comparing the response date with the date of receipt — this determines whether you have real time to prepare your position.
The response period is also set by the claimant: there is no mandatory pre-trial procedure for copyright disputes in Kazakhstan, and missing it does not lead to dismissal of the claim but to the court stage. Copyright is governed by the RK Law "On Copyright and Related Rights"; disputes are considered in the general procedure.
It is important to compare the date in the claim with the limitation period: the general period is three years from the moment the rights holder learned or should have learned of the infringement of their right. A claim does not interrupt or extend the period, and there is no need to wait after the letter.
Check point by point:
- Response date: what response or payment date is named and how it relates to the date of receipt
- Presence of a period: whether it is specified at all or only implied
- Date of infringement: whether the text contains references to it and to the moment when the claimant learned of the infringement
- Limitation period: whether it has expired for the stated claim
- Proof of receipt: whether it has been preserved
- Cross-check with attachments: whether the periods in the claim match the periods stated in the attachments
How to record the deadline and not lose time on a response
A period in a claim works only when the starting point is known — so first of all, save the envelope, the delivery notification or a screenshot of the letter with the date and time. Then draw up a short chronology: when the photo appeared on your page, when the demand arrived, what response date is named in it. Such a sequence will be useful both for internal review and as an attachment to the response.
Separately check to whom the claim is addressed and whether the addressee matches the person who actually posted the image: the website owner, an agency, an employee or a contractor. If the publication was prepared not by an employee, bring up the assignment, acts and correspondence — this will show who is responsible for the disputed material.
- Starting point: record the date and method of receipt of the claim
- Chronology: compile into one list the dates of publication, receipt of the demand and the response
- Addressee: verify to whom the demand is sent and who posted the photo
- Draft response: start preparing your position immediately, without postponing to the last day
Practical advice: respond in writing and keep a copy of the sent response with confirmation of delivery — this is your safeguard if the dispute moves to the court stage.
A claim is not yet a dispute but an exchange of positions: a careful review of documents often shows that part of the demands is unconfirmed or made by the wrong person. Aizhana Medetova
Claims in a demand letter for the use of a photo: what it asserts
The claims in a demand letter for the use of a photo are built around remedying the violation and compensating for losses. A photograph is protected as a work regardless of its artistic value, and use without the right holder's consent is unlawful. The set of items depends on how the photo was used and what the claimant intends to obtain — therefore the list in someone else's letter should be read not as a formality, but as a request for specific actions.
The main demand is to remove the photo: take it down from the website, publication, banner or product card and confirm the removal. Alongside this, a retraction or attribution of the author is demanded if the photo was distributed with distorted information. A separate item is compensation for use without a contract.
- Removal: stop using the image and confirm this in writing
- Retraction: publish a retraction or indicate the author and source
- Compensation: pay the amount for the period of use without a contract
- Contract: formalize the terms of further use of the photo
- Report: disclose the methods and scope of distribution of the photo
- Confirmation: notify in writing of compliance with the demands
A practical guideline: compare each item with what is actually supported by documents — a demand without evidence of use at a specific address or medium does not oblige you to respond on the merits.
Comparison of positions: photo use claim and response to it
A dispute over an image comes down to counterarguments: the claimant proves the use and the scope of rights, while the recipient looks for a ground on which there was no use or the use was lawful. The legal framework is set by the RK Law "On Copyright and Related Rights": protected works, personal non-property and property rights, cases of free use, and the term of protection. Bonafacto lawyers advise starting with the question: has every element of the claim been confirmed — the author, the transfer of rights, the identity of the image, the manner of placement?
Well-grounded objections are built on an analysis of each element: who the author is, whether the property right was transferred, whether the image is identical, where and how it was placed. If at least one element is not confirmed, the claim loses its foundation. It is convenient to assemble the response using the scheme "claimant's argument — recipient's counterargument — what confirms it": this shows where the dispute rests on documents and where on assumptions.
Main arguments against the claim:
- Free use: cases expressly named in the law — quotation for scientific, polemical, critical and informational purposes, illustrations for educational purposes — with indication of the author and the source;
- Scope of quotation: reproduction of an image as an illustration is justified by the purpose;
- Exhaustion of rights: applies only to copies lawfully put into civil circulation by way of sale; it does not extend to placement on the internet;
- Term of protection: the property rights have ceased to be protected;
- Unprotected content: official documents, state symbols, works of folk art;
- Amount of the sum: in determining compensation, the court takes into account the nature of the infringement, the degree of fault and the scale of use.
| Claimant's argument | Recipient's counterargument | How it is verified |
|---|---|---|
| The image was reproduced without permission | The use falls under a case of free use | Purpose, scope, indication of author and source |
| The author is a specific person | The claimant has not confirmed authorship | Evidence of creation and publication |
| The right was transferred to the claimant | The property right was not transferred or was transferred in part | The contract, its terms and subject matter |
| The infringement continues | The disputed object has been removed from placement | Recording the state of the page on a given date |
| The claim is being brought now | The term of protection has expired or the limitation period has been missed | Date of creation and the author's lifespan |
| The damage is significant | There is no harm, the use was in good faith | Nature and scale of placement |
The table is indicative: the set of arguments depends on the type of image, the manner of publication and the terms of the contract with the author.
How to draft a counterargument so that it works
A counterargument in a response to a claim is not an assessment but a link "fact — document — conclusion". Each of the claimant's arguments should be addressed in a separate paragraph: what exactly is being disputed, what confirms it, and what consequence follows from it. Arguments should not be mixed in one paragraph: an objection on authorship and an objection on the amount of the sum are verified by different documents, and a merged wording loses persuasiveness.
Procedure for working on the response:
- Mark up the claim: number the demands and link each to the claimant's attachment;
- Separate what is acknowledged: what the recipient does not dispute — this narrows the dispute to the genuinely conflicting points;
- Assemble your own evidence base: contracts, assignments, correspondence, screenshots with dates;
- Check the sums: correlate what is claimed with the nature and scale of placement;
- Formulate a conclusion on each point: the demand is rejected in full, in part, or acknowledged.
A typical mistake is a response consisting only of arguments without references to attachments: the position sounds but cannot be verified. The second misstep is silence on a point that cannot be disputed: the court assesses the response as a whole, and skipping a demand reads as agreement with it. The response is signed by the person entitled to act for the recipient, and copies of the attachments should be kept in the same form in which they were sent.
How to verify a photo usage claim: a step-by-step breakdown
Start with a comparison: a claim usually includes an image and identifies the rights holder, so the first step is to match that image against the original file and its versions on the website. Look at the frame, cropping, color correction, and resolution. Alteration does not remove protection: photographs are protected as works regardless of artistic value, and alteration requires the author's consent.
Next, check the file metadata: EXIF may contain information about the camera, the shooting date, and the editing software, while the publication history on the website and social media shows when the image appeared on your site and where it was taken from. Save screenshots of pages with dates, drafts, and correspondence with the designer or contractor if the material was not prepared by an employee. This is how verification turns into evidence gathering — and it is convenient to follow the steps in this same order.
- Image comparison: match the disputed image against the original file and its versions — frame, cropping, color, resolution.
- Metadata: examine the EXIF and publication history — dates, sources, page screenshots.
- Documents: pull up contracts, assignments, acts, and correspondence with the photographer or contractor.
- Role: determine your position — website owner, agency, employee, or intermediary.
- Identity: check whether the image from the claim matches what was actually used.
- Recording: preserve the evidence and prepare a reasoned response within the established deadline.
When reviewing such matters, Bonafacto lawyers advise following a single line of verification: first the identity of the image, then the origin of the file, then the documents concerning the contractor — this way the response relies on facts, not assumptions.
Free use of photos and a claim: when demands are unfounded
A rights holder's demands are unfounded if the publication falls under the free use regime: the RK Law "On Copyright and Related Rights" permits use of another's image without the author's consent when the work has been lawfully made public and the purpose of use is justified. Consent and remuneration are not required in such a case.
Quotation is lawful for informational, scientific, polemical or critical purposes — to the extent justified by the purpose, with indication of the author and source. Illustration in educational or news material falls under this regime as long as the photo does not become an independent subject of display; news use is permitted in a review of current events when the display is conditioned by the event itself. Passing off another's photo as one's own or placing it in commercial advertising without a contract is impermissible. An analysis of the publication circumstances shows whether consent was required — and this is the first step toward responding to the claim.
- Attribution: the author and the source of borrowing are named in the material
- Lawful publication: the image used was made public by the author themselves
- Extent: the fragment does not exceed what is justified by the purpose of quotation
- Purpose: informational, scientific, polemical or critical — not advertising
- Independence of the photo: the image is not presented as one's own and does not become a subject of display separately from the text
A practical guideline: save the page with the publication and its context as of the posting date — this record shows whether the purpose was informational and whether a source credit was present.
Evidence for a claim over the use of a photo: what to attach to the table
The attachments to the table must show that a specific image was posted and is accessible to an unlimited number of persons. Photos are protected as works regardless of artistic value — the very fact of use matters. Each piece of evidence ties the picture to the page, the date and the owner of the resource.
Recording begins with an inspection of the page. A notarial inspection of the website fixes the content of the web page at the time of the request: the address, the date, the reproduction of the image and the absence of any indication of the rights holder, and is used as independent evidence in court.
- Notarial inspection report: records the page, the image, the date and the address at the time of inspection.
- Screenshots with date and address: confirm the posting, but require linkage to the source.
- Archived copies of pages: show that the photo was available during a certain period.
- Agreements with the author or photographer: confirm the basis for holding the rights.
- Correspondence between the parties: reveals the circumstances of the file transfer and the reaction to the request.
- Examination of the image: establishes the identity of the disputed photo and the original.
| Type of evidence | What it confirms | What the lawyer checks |
|---|---|---|
| Notarial inspection report | Posting of the image on the page | Completeness of the recording of the address, date and content |
| Screenshot with date | Availability of the photo at the time of the capture | Presence of the page address and a legible date |
| Archived copy | The period during which the photo was online | Match between the image and the address |
| Agreement with the author | The basis of the rights holder's rights | Subject matter, terms of use, signatures |
| Correspondence | Circumstances of the file transfer | Link to the specific image and person |
Each piece of evidence is assessed in its entirety; a standalone screenshot without linkage to the source is weaker than a notarial inspection and an archive.
Typical mistakes made by a recipient of a photo-use claim
It is not the publication itself that damages your position, but the actions taken after receiving the letter. A dispute over an image is decided by documents and chronology: what was on the page, when it appeared, and how the addressee responded. Below are the missteps that narrow the room for objections.
- Deleting before documenting: the image and correspondence are removed before the state of the page, the publication date, and the placement parameters have been recorded — yet it is precisely this data that shows the scope and nature of the use.
- Careless wording in the reply: phrases that read as an acknowledgment of debt render subsequent arguments about the chain of rights and about free use meaningless.
- Promising payment without verification: the amount is agreed before authorship and the transfer of the property right to the claimant have been confirmed.
- Silence: the letter is left without a response, and from then on the conversation proceeds according to the rules set by the other party.
- A reply without attachments: objections are raised but not supported by documents and corroborating materials.
- Disputing with the representative instead of examining the chain of rights: energy goes into correspondence, while the key question — who the author is and to whom the rights were transferred — remains unverified.
At Bonafacto, the documents are studied first and prospects are assessed only afterwards. The practical guideline is simple: do not confirm the infringement and do not agree to the amount until the publication chronology has been compiled and the chain of rights has been verified.
What Happens After Responding to a Claim for Photo Use
The response records the recipient's position but does not end the dispute: further developments depend on the claimant's reaction. Three scenarios are possible — the claimant withdraws the demands, proposes a settlement, or goes to court. Which one will materialize cannot be predicted in advance, so the response should be prepared so that it works in any scenario.
If the matter reaches the court stage, the evidence base gathered while reviewing the claim works in the defendant's favor: a record of the page's state as of a given date, information about the image's source, and correspondence about the terms of use. Materials prepared for objections do not have to be collected again — they are used as the basis of the position. At Bonafacto, the cost of each stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so the scope of actions at every step is known in advance.
A separate point is deadlines. A claim does not interrupt or extend the limitation period, so the mere fact of sending it does not change how the period for protecting the right is calculated. Practical advice: keep confirmation of sending and receipt of the response — these documents will be useful if the dispute moves to the next stage.
What to do after reviewing a claim for the use of a photo
The document received is recorded in the form in which it arrived, together with its attachments and the date of delivery — this is the starting point for further correspondence. Then the circumstances of the publication are reconstructed: where and when the image appeared, who posted it, and whether the page was changed. Separately, the claimant's chain of rights and the identity of the photograph are verified, and an assessment is made as to whether the posting falls under cases of free use.
The response is prepared in writing and point by point for each claim, without wording that could be read as an acknowledgment of debt. A claim is an exchange of positions, not the final point: when reviewing the documents, some of the claims may turn out to be unsubstantiated or asserted by the wrong person.
- Recording: keep the claim, its attachments and proof of receipt.
- Circumstances: establish the date, method and authorship of the publication.
- Rights: verify the chain from the author to the claimant and that the image matches.
- Response: set out objections to each claim without acknowledging any debt.