Business

Company Charter: What to Check Right Now and What Risks Are Hidden

The company charter is the document that defines the competence of bodies, the procedure for approving transactions, and the rules for participants' exit, so it must be checked before signing a disputed decision, not after. It is enough to verify several blocks: the powers of bodies, the terms of transactions, and the procedure for disposing of shares.

Charter of the partnership and minutes of the general meeting of participants

You open the charter to check the procedure for approving a transaction or distributing profits, and you see wording written many years ago. Since then, both the law and the composition of participants, as well as the scale of the business, have changed. Amending a couple of clauses seems like a simple task, but it is precisely this document that becomes the cause of corporate conflicts and counterparties' refusal to proceed with a transaction.

In Kazakhstan, a company's charter must comply with the mandatory norms of legislation on limited liability partnerships and joint-stock companies. Provisions that contradict the law are not applied, but they create confusion when making decisions. The risk areas are the competence of the bodies, the procedure for approving transactions, and the withdrawal of participants: these blocks should be checked first.

Company Charter: What to Check Right Now

This document is worth checking right now because it is a working document used to resolve disputes, formalize transactions, and undergo inspections. When a conflict arises between participants, a bank requests confirmation of authority, or the tax authorities review transactions, the charter is the first document opened. If a director signs an agreement outside the scope set out in the charter, the transaction may be deemed invalid, and the company may incur losses.

It is better to start the review before a problem arises, not after. Example: the document was drafted using a template when the LLP was registered and has not been amended since, even though the participants, shares, and types of activity are already different. In such a case, Bonafacto lawyers advise opening first the sections on the competence of bodies, major transactions, profit distribution, and the procedure for amending the charter itself — those are exactly where leverage and risk areas are hidden.

Below are five positions that are reviewed first; for each, it is important to understand not only the wording but also how it works in practice.

  • Director's authority: which transactions the director signs independently and which require participant consent
  • Major transactions: the value threshold and approval procedure
  • Profit distribution: when and how participants receive dividends
  • Procedure for amending the charter and convening the general meeting: who initiates and how a decision is adopted
  • Director's term of office: and the procedure for re-election

Practical advice: verify the charter not against your memory of "what was agreed" but against the actual documents — meeting minutes, orders, and recent transactions. The discrepancy between the text and actual management is the very area where risk manifests first.

When a company's charter is outdated and creates risks

A charter becomes outdated when the structure recorded in it no longer matches how the business is actually organized. New participants appear or the ratio of shares changes, branches and representative offices are opened, some powers are transferred to a manager or supervisory board — while the constituent document remains in its previous version. From then on it takes on a life of its own: decisions are made under it, even though it no longer describes the company.

The most dangerous thing is a discrepancy between the document and the actual structure. The charter may lack provisions on major transactions, allocation of votes, the competence of bodies and the approval procedure. In a disputed situation, the parties find it difficult to confirm that a decision was made lawfully, so an outdated charter should be checked before a transaction or corporate conflict — not after one has begun.

Signs showing that the document is due for revision:

  • Several versions, and it is unclear which one is in force.
  • No clauses on major transactions and the approval procedure.
  • The composition of participants and shares do not match the facts.
  • The board of directors or manager is not described.
  • Seals and details in the document are out of date.

Each point on its own is not a catastrophe — the problem is the combination: the document and the facts diverge, and any decision has to be defended not with the text but with explanations. It is convenient to start the check with the latest registered version and compare it with the current composition of participants.

Who in the company makes decisions under the charter

Decision-making under the charter is divided between the general meeting of participants and the director, and the boundary of their powers is set out in the charter itself. If that boundary is blurred, the director signs what the participants consider unacceptable, and the meeting votes on matters that are outside its remit. A governance dispute begins not with missing money but with the question of who had the right to make the decision — and from there everything depends on the wording of the document.

The management bodies in a company's charter need to be examined in two places: what is reserved to the exclusive competence of the meeting and which transactions the director may enter into only with the consent of the participants. Separately, check who convenes the meeting, how votes are counted and how approval is recorded. In a conflict, it is precisely these provisions that determine whether the manager is acting in accordance with the charter, and, in the case of a major transaction, whether he was entitled to sign the contract without approval. Bonafacto lawyers begin such a review by studying the document and the minutes, not by assessing the prospects of the dispute.

Allocation of powers in the charter
Body What it decides How it is formalised
General meeting of participants Amendment of the charter, major transactions, appointment of the director Minutes of the meeting
Director Day-to-day management, contracts within the limits of the charter Decision or order
Other bodies Matters assigned to them by the charter Decision of the body
Approval of a transaction Transactions above the limit set by the charter Consent of the participants

The "How it is formalised" column shows which document confirms the decision: minutes of the meeting, an order of the director or a decision of another body. Without such a document, the power is considered unexercised, so check not only the text of the charter but also whether the minutes and orders themselves exist. If the charter sets no limit on the director's transactions, the consent of the participants may not be required — this question is clarified by the content of the document.

  • Exclusive competence: the list of matters that the meeting decides itself and does not delegate to the director.
  • Transaction limit: the threshold above which the director needs the consent of the participants.
  • Recording of approval: the document by which consent is formalised — its absence deprives the decision of confirmation.

How to read the charter by bodies: the order of review

It is convenient to conduct the review from the general to the specific — from the meeting to the director, not the other way round. First, list the matters reserved to the exclusive competence of the meeting, then the list of transactions that the director may enter into only with the consent of the participants, and only after that look at day-to-day management. This immediately shows where the wording duplicates itself and where a gap remains between them.

  • Cross-check against the minutes: every decision of the meeting must rest on a document with an agenda, a quorum and voting results.
  • Checking the limit: make sure the threshold is described through a clear criterion, not a general phrase such as "major transactions".
  • Consent to a transaction: the written consent of the participants is formalised separately; its absence is a reason to review the approval procedure.
  • Order of the director: the manager's internal decisions are recorded by order, otherwise there is nothing to confirm the power with.

A mistake that occurs during such a cross-check is reliance on oral agreements: the participants remember that "that is how it was decided", but there is no document. The second slip is minutes that do not state which provision of the charter is being amended. The third is consent to a transaction signed after it was concluded. Any of these gaps surfaces in a dispute over powers, and it is better to close it before the transaction rather than in a conflict.

Company Charter and Transactions: Where Errors Arise

Errors in a company charter regarding transactions arise where the document does not set clear criteria: what constitutes a major transaction, who approves it and in what procedure. If the criteria are vague, both the counterparty and the company itself are left with grounds for a dispute over the validity of the contract, and the party may face restitution of what was received. A major transaction is described in the charter through measurable thresholds — a percentage of the balance sheet value of assets, types of property, a list of matters requiring the consent of the participants. There is one thing worth checking: whether the document contains a major transaction threshold and an approval procedure — without this, the mechanism does not work.

A separate risk area is interested-party transactions: the charter must state who is considered an interested person and how a conflict of interest is disclosed. When this is absent, challenging the contract and claims for damages become a likely scenario rather than a theoretical one. Check:

  • Scope of persons: whether the persons whose transactions require consent are specified.
  • Disclosure: whether a mechanism for disclosing interest is set out.
  • Consequences: whether the document contains provisions on a transaction without approval.

Practical advice: verify the charter's wording against the actual ownership and management structure — thresholds and the list of approving persons make sense only if they are tied to real roles in the company. Otherwise, the document formally exists, but it cannot be applied to a specific contract.

What documents are needed to verify a company's charter

To understand the actual state of affairs, request the company's current version of the charter with all amendments. Cross-check it against the minutes of general meetings of participants or decisions of the sole participant on the basis of which the amendments were made. Without the minutes, it is difficult to confirm that the changes are lawful and were adopted by an authorized body.

The company's charter documents should be reviewed as a whole: the state registration certificate, the statement of registered amendments, and the text of the charter itself. Verification of the company's charter documents also includes internal acts if the charter refers to them. This way you will see whether the actual management structure matches the records in the register.

The statement of amendments is the connecting point: it lists which amendments have been registered, while the text of the charter shows how they look in the final version. If the statement contains a version that the charter does not (or vice versa), then the document at hand is outdated, and any conclusions based on it will be erroneous. Compare the dates of approval and registration: a discrepancy will indicate which copy is outdated.

  • Current charter in the latest version
  • Minutes of meetings or decisions of the sole participant
  • State registration certificate and statement of amendments
  • Documents on all registered amendments
What to cross-check each document against
Document What to look at
Current charter Date of approval, version, references to internal acts
Minutes of meetings Quorum, authority, wording of decisions
Registration certificate Company details, fact of incorporation
Statement of amendments List of registered amendments and their dates

If any document is missing, that is already a risk: the gap will have to be closed before a transaction or dispute.

Typical errors in a company's charter in Almaty

Errors in a company's charter in Almaty fall into three groups: outdated provisions, missing mandatory clauses, and incorrectly executed amendments. The document was adopted under previous legislation, then piecemeal edits were made — and now the provisions on branches, the competence of bodies, or the procedure for alienating a share conflict with the current rules. A separate category is gaps: the procedure for convening the general meeting, the method of confirming decisions, the rules on withdrawal and preemptive rights are not described.

Amendments are often executed incorrectly: the minutes are drawn up retroactively, it is not stated which specific clause is being changed, the full new edition is not attached, and only the amendment sheet is submitted to the justice authorities. Bonafacto lawyers begin by comparing the edition with the registration certificate and checking the minutes — and only then decide what to fix. The clauses on major transactions and the director's powers require the most attention: a discrepancy here affects the transaction, not the document.

  • Outdated edition: provisions have not been brought into line with the current rules of law
  • Gaps in mandatory provisions: there is no procedure for convening the meeting and no method of confirming decisions
  • Contradictions: the charter and internal documents say different things about the same procedures
  • Defective execution: amendments are recorded by minutes without a full new edition
  • Desynchronization: edits have been made to the registration data that are not reflected in the charter

It is convenient to conduct the review in reverse: first write down which decisions and transactions the charter governs, then find each provision in the text and compare it with the actual way of working. A clause that exists on paper but is not applied in practice is just as much a risk as a missing one.

How to distinguish a defect in the text from a defect in the procedure

A defect in the text is visible when reading; a defect in the procedure — only when compared with the minutes. Divide the review into two passes: first you read the charter as a document, then you match each amendment against the decision of the meeting or the sole participant. This way you will understand what to fix — the wording or the very procedure for adopting the decision.

  • Check the dates: the edition of the charter and the minutes by which it was approved must relate to the same decision
  • Check completeness: the full new edition is attached to the minutes, not just the amendment sheet
  • Verify the quorum: the minutes reflect who voted and how the votes were counted
  • Match the clauses: the minutes name the specific clause being changed
  • Check against the register: the certificate of amendments confirms that the edit reached registration

A practical tip: create a table "charter clause — meeting decision — register entry" and fill it in line by line. An empty cell in any column is a signal that the provision rests on a verbal assurance rather than on a document.

How amendments to the charter are registered: a step-by-step procedure

The procedure begins with identifying discrepancies: you need to understand which provisions of the current version are outdated and what must change. To do this, the text is compared against the actual management structure, the composition of participants and decisions already adopted. The more precisely the discrepancies are described, the fewer amendments will have to be made again.

Next, a new version of the charter is prepared or the amendments are formalized in a separate document. Then a general meeting of participants is held (or the sole participant adopts a decision) and minutes are drawn up — this is the document that confirms the amendments were adopted by the authorized body. At Bonafacto, the cost of this stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so the scope of preparation is clear in advance.

  • Identify discrepancies between the current version and the actual state of affairs
  • Prepare a new version of the charter or a document with amendments
  • Hold a general meeting of participants and draw up minutes
  • Register the amendments with the justice authorities
  • Update the company's internal documents

After registration, the amendments take effect for third parties, and internal documents — policies, regulations, powers of attorney, contract templates — are brought into line with the new version. If the matter can be resolved through a claim and negotiations, Bonafacto lawyers first propose a pre-trial route. A mismatch between the charter and internal acts is a common cause of disputes over authority, so updating should not be delayed.

Stages of registering amendments and the result of each
Step What is done Result
Identifying discrepancies Compare the charter with actual management and decisions List of provisions to be amended
New version Prepare the text of the charter or a document with amendments Draft for the meeting
General meeting Adopt a decision and draw up minutes Confirmation of authority
Registration Submit documents to the justice authorities Registered amendments
Internal documents Bring acts and templates into line Unified management structure

A skipped step takes you back to the previous one: without minutes, registration is impossible, and without updating internal acts, the charter works only on paper.

What to attach to the application and how not to lose control over deadlines

The document package is assembled before the meeting, not after: the new version or document with amendments, the meeting minutes (decision of the sole participant), the registration application, as well as documents confirming the signatory's authority. A mistake that occurs in Almaty quite often is that the minutes and the new version are signed by different persons, or the minutes refer to a clause other than the one actually being amended. Check line by line: the clause number in the minutes must match the clause in the text.

  • Minutes: the agenda matches word for word the wording in the charter on the competence of the meeting
  • New version: signed by the same person as the minutes and contains the full text, not only the amended paragraphs
  • Application: the signatory acts within the authority fixed in the charter at the time of submission
  • Copies: keep a copy with a receipt mark — it will be useful when checking against the register

A practical tip: before submitting, go through the text of the new version and strike out all references to internal acts that have not yet been updated. A reference to a non-existent provision is a reason for questions during review and an extra reason for a dispute over authority.

Charter and Participants' Shares: Exit, Disposal, Preemptive Right

Participants' shares are governed not only by law but also by the company's internal provisions — and this is precisely where discrepancies come to light in a transaction. The charter should be checked for three blocks: the procedure for a participant's exit, the rules for disposing of a share to third parties, and the terms of the preemptive right of the remaining participants. If these provisions are worded vaguely or contradict the actual ownership structure, the buyer of the share and the company itself face the risk of the transaction being challenged and disputes over who is entitled to approve it.

It is convenient to conduct the review against documents rather than from memory: compare the text of the charter with the minutes of meetings and with information on how the shares are actually distributed. A practical tip — write down for each participant their share, the grounds for holding it, and the restrictions imposed on it by the charter, then compare the records with the actual position. Where the data diverge, that is where the main risk in a disposal arises.

  • Participant's exit: whether the procedure is set out — to whom and how the share is transferred upon exit
  • Disposal of the share: to whom and on what terms a participant may sell or transfer the share
  • Preemptive right: which participants are entitled to acquire the share first and in what order
  • Approval of transactions: which decisions on shares require approval by the company's bodies
What to verify on participants' shares
Charter provision What to check Risk in the transaction
Participant's exit Procedure and terms for transferring the share Dispute over who becomes the owner
Disposal of the share To whom and how the share may be transferred Doubts about the lawfulness of the transfer
Preemptive right Priority and procedure for acquisition Transaction challenged by other participants
Approval of transactions Which bodies decide and how Transaction without proper approval

A gap in any of these points should be closed before the transaction, not after: amending the charter is easier than proving your rights in a dispute.

Separately, check whether the text of the charter matches how the company actually operates: who signs decisions on shares, how consents are formalized, and whether there are internal documents that the charter refers to. If the wording allows for different interpretations, it is worth establishing a single procedure in advance. At Bonafacto, lawyers, advocates and notaries work within one practice, so questions about the charter and share transactions can be addressed comprehensively — from the text of the document to notarial formalization.

How to Formalize the Transfer of a Share: Sequence of Steps

The transfer of a share is formalized not by a single document but by a combination of decisions and consents, and here the order matters more than speed. First, the participant sends the others a notice of intention to sell or transfer the share — this is what triggers the preemptive right. Then the procedure set out in the charter is followed, and the refusals or consents of the other participants are recorded. Only after that is the transaction itself formalized and changes made to the company's information.

  • Notice: to whom and in what form the participant notifies of the disposal of the share
  • Consents: which participants confirm waiver of the preemptive right and in what form
  • Minutes: by which meeting decision the transfer of the share is approved
  • Documents for registration: what is attached to the application for changes

A typical mistake is to start by signing the contract and then collect the notices and consents retroactively. The second is to leave in the charter a provision on the preemptive right without specifying how and within what period the participants may exercise it: then it is unclear whether the right is deemed observed. The third is to fail to attach the full new version of the charter to the application if the transfer of the share is accompanied by amendments to the document. Check in advance that the notice, consents and minutes do not contradict each other in dates and content — this is the minimum that reduces the risk of a dispute over the lawfulness of the transfer.

What to do with the company's charter next

Start by documenting the discrepancies: write down which provisions of the outdated document contradict the actual management structure, the composition of participants and the procedure for transactions. These notes will become the basis for changes — do not try to fix everything at once, work through the specific inconsistencies.

The document can only be brought into order through the official procedure: prepare a new version, hold a general meeting of participants with a minutes record, and register the changes with the justice authorities. After registration, update the internal documents that reference the charter's provisions.

Also check how well the text corresponds to the current version of the law: some wording becomes outdated following amendments, and then even a substantively correct decision is drafted incorrectly. Separately, verify the director's competence and the procedure for approving transactions — these sections diverge from the company's actual practice.

  • Document the discrepancies in writing
  • Verify the provisions against the current version of the law
  • Check the director's competence and the procedure for approving transactions
  • Update internal regulations and policies

A company's charter only works when its provisions are specific and comply with the current law. Vague wording on the director's competence and the procedure for approving transactions is a direct path to a corporate dispute and the challenging of contracts. Dulat Abenov

Murat Bilalov

Services on this topic

Corporate lawyer Legal support for business Legal services for legal entities

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Where should I start checking the company charter?

Start with the sections on the competence of bodies, major transactions, profit distribution, and the procedure for amending the charter itself — that is where leverage and risk areas are hidden. Then compare the text with the actual documents: meeting minutes, orders, and recent transactions. The discrepancy between the charter and actual management is the area where risk manifests first.

How can I tell that the charter is outdated?

A charter is outdated when the structure recorded in it no longer matches how the business is actually organized: participants or shares have changed, branches have appeared, some powers have been transferred to a manager or board of directors. Signs include several versions with no clarity on which one is in force, missing clauses on major transactions and approval procedures, outdated seals and details. Each point alone is not a catastrophe; the problem is the combination: the document and the facts diverge, and any decision has to be defended with explanations rather than the text.

Who in the company has the right to make decisions under the charter?

Decisions are distributed between the general meeting of participants and the director, and the boundary of their powers is set out in the charter itself. Look at two places: what is assigned to the exclusive competence of the meeting and which transactions the director concludes only with the consent of participants. Separately check who convenes the meeting, how votes are counted, and how approval is recorded — in a conflict, these clauses determine whether the manager acted in accordance with the charter.

What happens if the director signs a contract outside the charter's scope?

The transaction may be declared invalid, and the company may incur losses. Risk arises where the document does not set clear criteria: what constitutes a major transaction, who approves it and in what procedure. If the criteria are vague, both the counterparty and the company itself have grounds for a dispute over the validity of the contract, and the party may face restitution of what was received.

How should major transactions and interested-party transactions be described in the charter?

A major transaction is described through measurable thresholds — a percentage of the balance sheet value of assets, types of property, a list of matters requiring participant consent. For interested-party transactions, the charter must state who is considered an interested person and how the conflict of interest is disclosed. Without this, challenging a contract and claims for damages become a likely scenario rather than a theoretical one.

What documents should I request to check the charter?

Request the current version of the charter with all amendments and compare it with the minutes of general meetings of participants or decisions of the sole participant on the basis of which the amendments were made. Without the minutes, it is difficult to confirm that the changes are lawful and adopted by an authorized body. Documents should be reviewed as a whole — together with the state registration certificate and a statement of registered changes; at Bonafacto, such a review begins with studying the document and the minutes, not with assessing the prospects of a dispute.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp