Medicine and patients' rights
Medical error: what must be proven in court under Kazakhstan law
A medical error is not a ready-made legal conclusion but a matter of proof in each individual case. For a claim against a clinic or a doctor to be well-founded, a defect in medical care and its connection to the deterioration of the patient's condition must be confirmed.
People come with a question about medical error after treatment has not produced the expected result, their condition has worsened, or the diagnosis has diverged from a subsequent examination. The first thing to establish is whether a defect in medical care occurred and whether the deterioration is connected to the doctor's actions rather than to the course of the disease itself. Without answers to these questions, any claim remains emotional rather than legal.
It is worth starting with the medical records: without them, any discussion of causation and fault remains speculation. Below we will examine how Kazakhstan law defines such an error, how it differs from an accident and a defect in treatment, and how to build the evidence before going to court.
Medical error: what it is under Kazakhstan law
Under Kazakhstan law, it is not a separate ground for liability, but rather the poor-quality provision of a medical service that has caused harm to the patient's health. The RK Code on Public Health refers to the quality of medical care and harm to health, not to a doctor's error as a standalone construct. In everyday usage, it is understood as a discrepancy between the expected and actual outcome of treatment — but for a dispute, such a discrepancy by itself is of no significance. Bonafacto lawyers begin their analysis with the documents: they are what show exactly what was violated and what it led to.
The definition rests on two elements: a violation of standards and clinical protocols in the provision of a medical service, and the harm that occurred. If the service was provided poorly but there is no harm, there is no subject for a dispute. In other words, an error is revealed through the poor-quality service and its consequences, not through the subjective fault of the specialist.
What is checked first:
- Standards and clinical protocols: those in force at the time the care was provided, not as of the date of the dispute.
- Harm to health: the fact of causation itself and its severity.
- Causal link: the departure from the requirements must be connected to the harm that occurred.
- Circumstances excluding liability: their absence is confirmed separately.
- Medical documents: proper documentation for each stage of care.
Practical conclusion: it is worth gathering evidence from the moment care is still being provided — reconstructing records after the fact is harder than preserving them. In a dispute over a medical error, what decides the matter is the quality of the records, not the emotions of the parties.
How a medical error differs from an accident and a defect in treatment
In RK law, a medical professional's error, an accident, iatrogeny and a defect in the provision of medical care are different legal constructs, and they must not be conflated. A medical error is an incorrect act or omission by a healthcare professional without intent, caused by objective difficulties in diagnosis or treatment. An accident is an adverse outcome not connected with the actions of medical personnel and resulting from a random coincidence of circumstances or an individual reaction of the body.
Iatrogeny and medical care defect
Iatrogeny covers any undesirable consequences of a medical intervention, including foreseeable but adverse reactions, which do not always constitute an error. A defect in medical care is a broader concept: a violation of standards, rules or timelines, which may be both an error and the result of organizational failures. The difference between a lapse in a doctor's work and an accident lies in the presence of a causal link with the actions of a specific specialist: if there is none, no elements of an offence arise.
- Diagnostic: an incorrectly established diagnosis or its untimely detection.
- Treatment-related: the wrong choice of method, intervention or medication.
- Organizational: a violation of the routing, documentation or continuity procedure.
- Deontological: a violation of ethics and of informing the patient.
- Accident: an outcome without fault of the medical personnel, caused by chance or an individual reaction.
| Concept | Basis | Who is liable | What must be proven |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medical error | Incorrect act or omission without intent | Healthcare professional | Improper performance of duties |
| Accident | Random coincidence of circumstances | No liability arises | Absence of fault and causal link |
| Iatrogeny | Undesirable consequence of an intervention | Depends on the link to the actions | Nature and predictability of the reaction |
| Defect in medical care | Violation of standards or rules | Medical organization | Deviation from the standard and its consequences |
The distinction determines the subject of proof and the circle of liable persons: the correct classification determines to whom claims should be brought.
What types of medical error become the subject of a dispute
Court disputes involve four groups of situations. A diagnostic error is the incorrect or untimely identification of a disease: plaintiffs prove the incompleteness of the examination, disregard of complaints and test results. It also manifests in overdiagnosis, when treatment is prescribed for a disease that does not exist. A treatment error concerns incorrectly chosen tactics, dosage or regimen of medication. A surgical error covers damage to anatomical structures, leaving a foreign body and an incorrect scope of intervention.
Organizational errors are defects in patient routing, inconsistency between departments and a breach of continuity. The subject of proof shifts: for diagnosis — to the completeness of the examination, for treatment — to compliance with the clinical protocol, for surgery — to the technique of the intervention. Under civil procedure, the plaintiff must prove the fact of harm, its amount and the causal link to the actions of the medical institution. A forensic medical examination establishes whether a defect in the provision of medical care occurred. Distinguishing the types of error determines which evidence to collect first: in cases of improper treatment, these are entries in the medical record, prescriptions and observation sheets; in surgical disputes — the operation report, a description of the postoperative period and imaging data; in organizational defects — the routing sheet, admission logs and waiting time for care. Bonafacto lawyers advise recording these documents before the record goes into the clinic's archive.
- Diagnostic error: complaints on admission, examination plan, conclusions of instrumental methods.
- Treatment error: prescription sheet, diary entries, clinical protocol.
- Surgical error: operation report, postoperative observation, results of follow-up imaging.
- Medication error: prescription forms, dosages, notes on administration of the drug.
- Organizational error: routing sheet, timing of hospitalization and transfer between departments.
- Forensic medical examination: questions about the defect in care and the causal link.
| Type of error | Typical situation | Key evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnostic | Incorrect or late diagnosis | Complaints, examination plan, test results |
| Treatment | Incorrect tactics or dosage | Prescription sheet, diaries, clinical protocol |
| Surgical | Damage to structures, foreign body | Operation report, postoperative data |
| Medication | Error in prescribing a drug | Prescription forms, notes on administration |
| Organizational | Breach of route and timing | Routing sheet, admission logs |
In each case, the court assesses the evidence as a whole and orders a forensic medical examination.
Elements of a medical error offense: what must be proven
Four elements of the offense must be proven: harm to the patient's health or life, unlawful conduct by the healthcare professional, causation, and fault. If even one is missing, the medical organization's liability does not arise, so before making any claims, Bonafacto lawyers first review the documents and assess the prospects of the dispute.
To establish a medical error, it is necessary to show that the healthcare professional's actions deviated from the standards of medical care, clinical protocols, and rules. Unlawfulness is manifested in incorrect diagnosis, improper treatment, delayed intervention, or violation of the patient management procedure. An unfavorable outcome by itself does not mean unlawfulness if the care was provided within accepted standards.
The elements of the offense are best broken down point by point — this makes it clear which of them are already supported by documents and which still need to be proven:
- Harm: infliction of harm to the patient's health or life
- Unlawfulness: conduct by the healthcare professional that deviates from standards of care
- Causation: the link between the actions or omissions and the harm incurred
- Fault: of the healthcare professional or the organization
Separately, keep in mind the allocation of the burden of proof: it is the medical organization, not the patient, that must confirm the proper quality of care. This is a presumption of fault: the person who caused the harm is released from compensation only if they prove that the harm was caused not through their fault (Article 917, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code of the RK), while the patient proves the fact of harm, its amount, and causation. Practical tip: request copies of medical documents in writing and keep everything you receive.
Harm to health as the main consequence of a medical error
Without harm to health, a claim for compensation loses its meaning. A deviation from the standard of diagnosis or treatment does not in itself give grounds for payment — what matters is its effect on the body. The severity of the consequences is established by a forensic medical examination ordered by the court or in the course of pre-trial proceedings.
The expert determines severity according to the criteria of the forensic medical examination rules: danger to life, duration of the health disorder, permanent loss of general working capacity. Minor harm — a short-term disorder, moderate — a long-term one, severe — a life-threatening condition or permanent loss of working capacity. Loss of professional working capacity is assessed separately if the injured person cannot return to their previous job.
What exactly the expert records:
- Danger to life: assessed at the time care was provided.
- Duration of the disorder: the length of treatment is taken into account.
- Permanent loss of general working capacity: the ability to perform ordinary work.
- Loss of professional working capacity: the possibility of returning to the previous job.
- Disability: also recorded, including its group.
- Ongoing observation: whether the injured person requires medical monitoring.
In medical error cases, the outcome is decided not by the severity of the consequences in itself, but by how fully the link between the doctor's actions and the harm incurred is confirmed. Anna Kulzhemiyeva
Causation between a doctor's actions and harm: how it is established
Causation means that it was the action or inaction of a healthcare professional that led to the adverse outcome. A confirmed error in itself does not entail liability if the harm occurred for other reasons. The link is established through a forensic medical examination: assessing how the disease progressed and what changed its course requires specialized scientific knowledge. At the same time, the expert's opinion is not binding on the court, but the court must state its disagreement with it in the decision (Article 92, Part 7 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK).
Causation in medicine is almost never straightforward. The expert analyzes the dynamics of the patient's condition, compares it with the intervention, and assesses whether the deterioration was a natural consequence of it. The key question: would the harm have occurred if the doctor had acted correctly. If yes, there is no causal link to the error.
Several circumstances can break the link — the expert verifies each of them separately rather than taking it on trust:
- Severe concomitant diseases: could in themselves have led to the same outcome.
- Severity of the condition on admission: an unfavorable prognosis existed from the outset.
- Individual drug intolerance: not identified when taking the medical history.
- Patient's refusal of examination or treatment: affected the dynamics.
- Supervening new infection or complication: not related to the doctor's actions.
- Imperfection of the treatment method itself: there were no alternatives at the time care was provided.
Practical conclusion: the more fully the case materials reflect the dynamics of the condition, the more precise the expert's answer to the question of causation — therefore discharge summaries, observation diaries, and test results should be collected from the very first days.
Liability of a medical organization: when the clinic is liable, not just the doctor
A medical service is provided by the organization with which the patient concludes a contract. The doctor and other employees act within the scope of their employment duties, therefore, under the Civil Code of the RK, a legal entity is liable for harm caused by an employee in the performance of employment duties. Claims are brought against the organization, not against the specialist, even if the harm was caused by the latter.
Liability of the medical organization and presumption of fault
The organization's fault may manifest in improper selection of personnel, lack of control, failure to provide equipment and consumables, violation of the patient's care pathway, or defects in documentation. In the provision of medical care, a presumption of the tortfeasor's fault applies: the organization is released from liability only if it proves the absence of its own fault. This applies both to mandatory medical insurance and to contracts for the provision of paid services. Bonafacto lawyers advise recording exactly which employee and in which office conducted the appointment: such attribution helps establish the line of the clinic's liability.
How to read the list below? Each item is either a ground for a claim against the clinic or a circumstance that the clinic raises in its defense.
- Harm caused by an employee: caused in the performance of employment duties — the medical organization is liable.
- Presumption of fault: the service was provided under a contract or within the mandatory medical insurance system — the clinic must prove the absence of fault.
- Force majeure: the harm occurred as a result of such a circumstance — liability is excluded.
- Gross negligence of the patient: if it contributed to the occurrence or increase of the harm, the amount of compensation is reduced (Article 935, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code of the RK).
- Compliance with standards: the clinic has proven compliance with protocols, standards and procedures — the presumption of fault is rebutted.
- Improper defendant: the claim is brought against a specific doctor as an individual — the clinic remains the proper defendant.
Medical examination for medical error: how it is conducted
In cases of improper medical care, the key evidence is the conclusion of a forensic medical examination. The court does not possess special medical knowledge and cannot independently assess whether the doctor's actions complied with clinical protocols and standards. The examination effectively predetermines the outcome of the dispute: without it, establishing a causal link between the healthcare worker's actions and harm to health is almost impossible.
Such an examination is ordered on the motion of a party or on the court's own initiative, which issues a ruling listing the questions. The wording must be specific, neutral and free of legal assessments: questions of law are decided by the court. Properly formulated questions allow clear conclusions to be obtained about diagnosis, treatment and their consequences; vague ones lead to an incomplete conclusion and a repeat examination. It is convenient to prepare the questions in advance — with a margin, so that the court has a choice.
The expert is asked, in particular, the following questions:
- Did the healthcare worker's actions comply with clinical protocols and standards of medical care
- Was the diagnosis established correctly and in a timely manner, and were the necessary tests conducted
- Are there defects in the provision of medical care and what do they consist of
- Is the harm to health or the patient's death in a causal relationship with the healthcare worker's actions
- Could the outcome have been different with proper provision of medical care
In the expert's conclusions, medical error is described through a defect in the provision of care, rather than through an assessment of "guilty or not": legal qualification is left to the court. A practical tip — verify each question against the case materials and medical documentation, otherwise the conclusions will hang in the air.
Evidence of medical error: what the court relies on
The basis of evidence in a medical error case is medical documentation: the inpatient or outpatient medical record, operation reports, prescriptions, test results and instrumental studies. The records establish what decisions the doctor made and how the patient's condition changed. Without these documents the court has nothing to rely on: they record the course of treatment itself, not a retelling of events from memory.
The forensic medical examination report is of key importance: it answers questions about the defect in the provision of care and causation. Written consultations from specialists and reports of departmental inspections do not replace the expert's report (Article 82, Part 2 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK); the court assesses them together with witness testimony — the patient, relatives, and other medical workers.
What the court assesses first:
- Medical record, reports and prescriptions: record the course of treatment and the doctor's decisions.
- Forensic medical examination report: the main conclusion on the defect and causation.
- Written specialist reports: supplement the evidence but do not replace the examination.
- Witness testimony: confirm the condition and circumstances.
- Correspondence with the clinic and responses from authorities: document acknowledgment of deficiencies.
- Original documents: ensure their admissibility and verifiability.
Practical advice: request copies of documents in writing and keep everything you receive.
When the doctor does not answer: circumstances excluding medical error
A physician's liability does not follow automatically from an adverse outcome. If the doctor eliminated a danger threatening the patient's life and did not exceed the limits of extreme necessity, this is not a criminal offence (Article 34 of the Criminal Code of the RK). However, under the Civil Code of the RK, harm caused in a state of extreme necessity is, as a general rule, compensated; the court, taking the circumstances into account, may release from compensation in full or in part (Article 920 of the Civil Code of the RK). The law permits assistance without consent, in particular, when the patient is in a state of shock or coma and cannot express their will. The basis remains a real danger, not an assumption.
Justified risk excludes criminal liability when the goal could not have been achieved otherwise and the physician took sufficient measures (Article 36 of the Criminal Code of the RK). The court assesses whether the chosen option corresponded to the current level of knowledge and the conditions in which care was provided. The expert determines the line between permissible risk and negligence.
Circumstances that are examined when analyzing a disputed situation:
- Extreme necessity: elimination of a danger to the patient's life without exceeding its limits.
- Justified risk: the goal is unattainable without risk, while sufficient measures have been taken.
- Improper conduct of the patient: refusal of care, violation of the regimen, concealment of information.
- Objective impossibility of diagnosis: atypical course, lack of equipment, brief contact.
- Force majeure: external circumstances that could not have been prevented under the given conditions.
- Compliance with mandatory prescriptions and standards: in the absence of an alternative.
Liability for medical error and the procedure for filing a claim
Liability depends on the nature of the violation and its consequences. Civil liability — under the Civil Code of the RK: harm to health is compensated by the medical organization, including compensation for moral harm. Administrative liability — under the CAO for violation of requirements for the provision of medical care. Criminal liability — under the articles of the CC on improper performance of professional duties and infliction of harm by negligence. A medical error rarely falls within a single branch of law: a pre-trial claim, a complaint and a lawsuit may proceed in parallel, and the documents for them are largely the same.
The injured party has the right to file a written pre-trial claim with the management of the medical organization. If no response is received or the response is unsatisfactory, a complaint is filed with the authorized body in the field of healthcare or with its territorial department. The findings based on the results of the inspection become evidence in subsequent dispute. This helps to avoid missing deadlines and to collect supporting documents. Bonafacto lawyers advise keeping copies of all submissions with a mark of receipt.
It is convenient to keep the procedure for filing a claim before your eyes as a list:
- Application to the head: a written request for explanations and copies of documents of the medical organization.
- Complaint to the authorized body: to the healthcare authority or its territorial department following the application.
- Recording of consequences: causation, including the ordering of a forensic medical examination.
- Statement of claim: to the court for compensation for harm to health and compensation for moral harm.
- Criminal case: if necessary — an application to initiate proceedings on the fact of improper provision of care.
- Court proceedings: using the findings of the inspection and the examination.
Typical mistakes made by the injured party when collecting evidence
The main mistake made by the injured party is delaying obtaining copies of medical documentation: until the chart, records and prescriptions are collected, discussing a defect in the provision of care is pointless. Copies are requested in writing, and the documents received are kept in the form in which they were issued. If the original cannot be obtained, the very fact of the request and which documents were issued are recorded.
The second mistake is emotional demands without reference to a specific defect and the harm that occurred. A claim or lawsuit built on general words about poor-quality treatment shows neither the violation, nor its consequences, nor the causal link between the doctor's actions and the deterioration of the patient's condition. It is more useful to describe by date what happened to the patient, which prescriptions were followed and how the patient's condition changed.
- Late request for copies: the medical chart, records and prescriptions are requested immediately, while the records are not lost.
- No copies: without them there is nothing to give to the expert and the court.
- Demands without a defect: emotions instead of reference to the violation and harm do not constitute the subject of the dispute.
- One's own assessment of the doctor's actions: conclusions about the correctness of treatment are made by the expert examination, not by the patient.
- Refusal to record the consequences: without documents, the harm to health is not linked to the actions of the medical professional.
Attempts to assess the doctor's actions independently are another dead end: the causal link and the nature of the violations are established by a medical expert examination, not by the injured party's personal opinion. It is equally important to record the consequences of treatment — visits, examinations, prescriptions after the disputed intervention, otherwise the harm to health will remain unproven. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so the collection of documents and preparation for the expert examination can be planned in advance.
What Ultimately Needs to Be Proven: The Logic of Proof, Step by Step
Proving a medical error comes down to a chain: medical documentation, a defect in the provision of care, harm to health, causation, and the results of an expert examination. Each link rests on the previous one, and a break in the chain weakens the injured party's position. First, it is established how observation and treatment were conducted and with what records, then it is shown where the care departed from what was required, and only after that is that departure linked to the consequences that occurred.
Role of expertise and collecting documents
The expert examination completes the chain: it answers questions about the nature of the defect and its connection to the harm, but it relies on what has already been gathered in the case materials. That is why documents and confirmation of the consequences are collected before going to court — restoring lost records and documenting the condition later is more difficult.
- Documentation: medical record, test results, consents, and discharge summaries.
- Defect in care: a departure from rules and standards, confirmed by the records.
- Harm to health: the nature and severity of the consequences, documented.
- Causation: substantiation that the harm occurred specifically because of the actions or inaction of the medical professional.
- Expert examination: an opinion on the issues of the defect and its connection to the consequences.
Sequence matters more than volume: a gap in one link carries over to the entire position.