Documents and disputes

Pre-trial claim: how to draft and send it correctly

A pre-trial claim is an official written demand addressed to a debtor or an unscrupulous counterparty, sent before going to court. It records your position and provides an opportunity to resolve the dispute without litigation; if this procedure is not followed, the court will return the statement of claim (Article 152 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK).

Pre-action claim: drafting the document

You are facing a situation where a counterparty is not fulfilling its obligations: it is not repaying a debt, is dragging out repairs, or refuses to refund money for a service not rendered. Perhaps you have already tried to resolve the matter verbally, but all you hear in response are promises or complete silence. At such a moment, the thought arises to go to court, but for many categories of cases the law requires that a pre-trial claim be sent first.

Mistakes at this stage are costly: a claim drafted without the required details or sent without confirmation of delivery will not be considered proper evidence. The court will return the statement of claim under Article 152 of the CPC of the RK , and the deadlines will be missed. Therefore, before sending, verify the parties' details against the transaction documents and keep the receipt and the inventory of the enclosure — without them, delivery cannot be confirmed.

Pre-trial claim: why it is needed and what happens after it is sent

This is a formal written demand sent to the other party to a contract, a supplier, or a debtor before going to court. It describes the essence of the dispute, refers to documents, and demands a refund, delivery of goods, rectification of defects, or termination of the transaction. In essence, it is the party's written position, stated in advance and addressed directly, rather than in the courtroom.

The purpose of this step is twofold: the counterparty gets a chance to resolve the conflict voluntarily, while the claimant records the date from which the dispute is deemed to have been asserted. Sometimes, after the letter, the debtor pays or proposes an installment plan, and the matter never reaches court. If there is no response, the document becomes evidence that an attempt was made to resolve the issue amicably and that the other party was notified. Bonafacto lawyers first study the documents and only then assess the prospects — the written demand is precisely what shows how well the position is supported by paperwork.

Consumer disputes deserve separate mention: the seller, manufacturer, or service provider is obliged to review the buyer's written complaint about defects in goods, work, or services within ten calendar days, and this period cannot be shortened by the contract. The wording and procedure for filing are clarified according to the text of the law as applied to the specific situation.

What happens after sending depends on whether the addressee responds. If there is no response or it is unsatisfactory, the claimant goes to court, and the claim becomes part of the case file. The procedure is as follows:

  • Tracking delivery: obtain the delivery notification — it will confirm that the addressee received the letter.
  • Waiting for a response: wait for a written reaction or for the expiry of the waiting period specified in the demand itself.
  • Preparing the statement of claim: if there is a refusal or silence, prepare the court application and attach the claim to the case materials.
  • Preserving evidence: keep a copy of the mailing and the inventory of contents — without them it is difficult to confirm the content of the letter.

At Bonafacto, the cost of this stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so preparing the demand and the subsequent handling of the case do not turn into additional payments along the way. If the matter can be resolved by a written demand, the pre-trial route is proposed first here — it is cheaper and faster than going straight to court.

When a pre-trial claim is mandatory and when you can go straight to court

Whether a pre-trial claim is mandatory is determined not by the applicant's wishes, but by law and the terms of the contract. The general principle: a claim is required where it is expressly prescribed by a legal norm or where the parties themselves have agreed on such a procedure in the text of the transaction. In Kazakhstan, the law expressly requires prior notice, for example, in consumer disputes: the claim is first reviewed by the seller, manufacturer or service provider. In other cases, it is a pressure tool and a way to get money faster, not a pass to court.

When a claim is not required, the statement of claim is accepted immediately — for example, in disputes over recognition of a right, dissolution of marriage, or claims where the law does not establish prior notice. The danger lies elsewhere: if the court considers the pre-trial procedure mandatory and it has not been complied with, the statement of claim will be returned (Article 152, Part 1 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). You will have to send the claim, wait for the response period and file the application again.

The fastest way to check yourself is to look at the nature of the claim.

Below is a guide, but the final answer depends on the contract and the specific legal norm.

  • The contract expressly requires a claim — you send it first
  • The law establishes a mandatory pre-trial procedure — you follow it
  • A dispute over dissolution of marriage or recognition of a right — statement of claim immediately
  • The contract is silent and the law does not introduce such a procedure — you can go straight to court
When a claim is mandatory and when it is not
Situation Claim required Consequence of omission
A mandatory claim procedure is established by the contract Yes The statement of claim will be returned (Article 152, Part 1 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK)
The law introduces a mandatory pre-trial procedure Yes The statement of claim will be returned (Article 152, Part 1 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK)
A dispute over recognition of a right, dissolution of marriage No The statement of claim is accepted immediately
The law and the contract are silent No A claim speeds things up but is not mandatory

Return of a statement of claim is not a denial of legal protection: you remedy the violation and file the application again. Pre-trial settlement of debt under a loan or credit agreement should also begin with a written demand — this records the date of the claim and the amount of the debt.

How to Draft a Pre-Trial Claim: Mandatory Details and Content

The structure of a pre-trial claim serves a single purpose: to make sure the recipient understands from the text who is addressing them, what they want, and on what grounds. That is why the content of a pre-trial claim begins with the header: the full name and BIN or IIN of the parties, addresses, contacts. Next, state which contract or action connects the parties, and describe the circumstances: what happened, when, and what evidence supports it.

The middle of the letter is the demand: refund the money, deliver the goods, remedy the defects, compensate for the harm. Formulate the demand specifically and make it enforceable: an amount or an action and a deadline for performance. If money is involved, provide the calculation: what the amount consists of, for what period, at what rate or tariff. Do not carry unnecessary details about the parties' correspondence into the text — the recipient needs the facts on which the demand rests, not a chronicle of communications.

The text concludes with a list of attachments with copies of documents, the date, the signature, and for a company — an outgoing reference number. A universal template for a pre-trial claim follows the same logic: details, facts, demand, calculation, attachments. Keep a copy with a mark of dispatch — you will need it if the dispute goes to court.

  • Header: details of the sender and recipient, addresses — so the letter is addressed to a specific person, not "to the organization"
  • Circumstances: the contract, event, violation — with dates and references to supporting documents
  • Demand: an amount or an action and a deadline for performance — one, clearly formulated
  • Calculation: what the amount consists of — period, rate or tariff
  • Attachments: copies of documents supporting the arguments — listed item by item, not "all documents in the case"

Step-by-step procedure: from document review to sending the claim

Work on a claim does not begin with the text but with the folder of documents: until the contract and payment documents are collected, a demand has nothing to rely on. First, retrieve the contract itself with all annexes and supplementary agreements, then the payment documents — receipts, payment orders, checks, bank statements. Add to them correspondence, acts, delivery notes and any papers that record the scope of work, deadlines or promises made by the other party. Bonafacto lawyers begin precisely with a review of the documents and only then assess the prospects — without this foundation, a claim turns into a set of emotions.

Next, identify the proper addressee. In a dispute with an organization, the claim is addressed to the legal entity at its legal address; in a dispute with a sole proprietor — to the sole proprietor himself; in a dispute with an individual — to that citizen. An error in the addressee or in the name nullifies all the work: the letter will go to the wrong place, and the waiting period for a response will be lost. Verify the spelling of the name and the address against the documents, not from memory or a website.

Then formulate one main demand and the calculation supporting it. The demand must be specific: return the amount, remedy the defects, deliver the goods, terminate the contract. Present the calculation line by line — what each figure is made up of and which document it is based on. If there are several demands, single out the main one and subordinate the rest to it, otherwise the debtor will respond selectively.

Prepare the annexes together with the text: they are what turn a pre-trial claim into evidence. Describe each annex in the list and attach copies, not originals. Send it by a method that leaves a trace — by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt or through a service with delivery confirmation. Keep the inventory, the receipt and the acknowledgment: the date of delivery will be the starting point for waiting for a response.

  • Collect the contract, annexes and payment documents
  • Identify the proper addressee from the documents
  • Formulate one main demand and a line-by-line calculation
  • Prepare the list of annexes and copies
  • Send by a method with delivery confirmation
  • Record the date of delivery and wait for a response

At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, and before the start the client receives a written estimate — so it is clear what you are paying for at each step. Practical advice: gather the entire package into one folder and number the pages — when handing the case to a lawyer or to court, you will save time searching for the needed paper.

How to check a claim before sending

Reread the finished text through the recipient's eyes: will they be able, without knowing your story, to understand what happened and what is required of them. Go through the document with a pencil — from the header to the signature — and mark the places where one has to guess. Such a pass reveals gaps in logic faster than proofreading with fresh eyes.

  • Details: the name, BIN or IIN and address of both parties match the documents, not a business card or a website.
  • Basis: a specific contract with date and number is named, and the event is described with a date and supporting paper.
  • Demand: formulated in the imperative mood, with an amount or action and a deadline for performance.
  • Calculation: each figure is derived from the attached document, and the total matches the amount in the demand.
  • Annexes: the list matches the actual copies, the pages are numbered, and the originals remain with you.
  • Tone: no assessments of the person and no assumptions about motives — only facts, documents and the consequences of non-performance.

Separately, cross-check the sending address with what is stated in the header: a discrepancy between the "addressee" in the text and on the envelope is a frequent reason why delivery is later difficult to tie to the case. And save the electronic version of the text: when preparing a lawsuit, it is convenient to supplement it without retyping everything from scratch.

Gathering evidence for a pre-trial claim: which documents to attach

You need to gather documents for the claim before you send it, not after. It is the paperwork that determines whether the other party will have a clear picture of the debt and what your chances are in court if it comes to that. If there is no confirmation of the debt, the letter becomes a formality that is easy to ignore.

Which evidence to attach depends on the substance of the dispute. Under a work contract, it is the contract itself, work completion certificates, the estimate and payment documents; for services — the request, invoice, receipts or account statements. Print out messenger and email correspondence so that the dates, sender and substance of the agreements are visible: a screenshot without context is weaker than the full correspondence, and sometimes it does not read as confirmation at all.

Separately attach what records the breach: an expert opinion, an inspection report, a defect list, the other party's refusal to sign. Below is a short checklist of the basic set.

  • Contract with annexes and supplementary agreements
  • Payment documents and account statements
  • Work completion or service delivery certificates
  • Correspondence with dates and participants
  • Expert opinion or inspection report
What each document confirms
Document What it confirms What to look at
Contract The obligation and its terms Signatures, date, subject matter, deadlines
Receipts and statements The fact of payment and the amount of debt Payment date, purpose, payer
Certificates and delivery notes Acceptance of work or goods Signatures of the parties, remarks
Correspondence Agreements and acknowledgment of debt Dates, author, full text
Expert opinion The amount of damage or defects Who prepared it, when, on what basis

Attach copies and keep the originals with you — they will be needed in court.

How to send a pre-trial claim and record its delivery

A pre-trial claim is delivered by registered letter with a delivery notification and an inventory of contents, by courier, or handed over against a signature on a copy — and each method leaves its own trace in the evidence. The reliable option is mail: the inventory will confirm that it was your document with attachments inside, and the notification will come back with the recipient's signature and the date.

A claim sent by mail does not require the recipient's consent: correspondence is sent to the address in the contract or to the legal address from the certificate of state registration of a legal entity. If the recipient has changed address and the letter is returned marked as expired storage period, that is also evidence — the recipient evaded delivery. Keep the inventory, the receipt and the entire envelope, even unopened.

The second option is courier delivery or handover against a signature on a copy. Ask the recipient to put the date, surname and position, and if they refuse — record the refusal in writing with two witnesses. Proof of sending is what the court will start with, so keep it until the case is over.

  • Registered letter with delivery notification and inventory of contents
  • Courier delivery with the recipient's mark on your copy
  • Handover against a signature indicating the date, surname and position
  • A note of refusal to accept, certified by witnesses

Typical mistakes in a pre-trial claim: what to look out for

A claim without a demand is a document that is easy to ignore. A person describes in detail how they were let down, but does not write what exactly they want: a refund, rework, or termination of the contract. Without a specific demand, the appeal turns into a complaint, and the other party may leave it unanswered, since it is unclear what needs to be fixed. Check yourself with a simple test: if you cannot extract a single sentence from the text saying "I request that such-and-such be done within such-and-such a deadline," the demand has not yet been formulated.

The second mistake is the wrong addressee. A claim is sent to the manager who handled the deal, to their personal email or messenger, although it should be received by the organization at its legal address. The letter remains without action, and it is difficult to tie proof of delivery to the case. Emotions are just as harmful: insults, reproaches, and accusations of fraud drown out the facts, and instead of a dialogue you get a refusal.

The third mistake is the absence of evidence. The contract, receipt, correspondence, and act are not attached to the appeal — and it hangs in the air. The counterparty has nothing to verify your words against, and the position looks unfounded. Attach copies with an inventory — it is more convenient both for you and for the person who will examine the dispute.

  • No clear demand: it is unclear what the other party must do and by what deadline.
  • The addressee is specified incorrectly: the letter goes to the wrong person or not to the official address.
  • The facts are not confirmed: there are no copies of documents, receipts, correspondence, or acts.
  • Too many emotions and judgments: they obscure the essence and turn people against you.
  • Several demands are mixed without priority: the addressee does not understand what to fulfill first.

Pre-trial claim for credit, services and construction contracts

If a dispute arises with a bank, the credit claim must rely on the account statement, the payment schedule and correspondence with the creditor. Check whether the terms were changed unilaterally, whether interest, penalties and commissions were calculated correctly, and whether insurance was connected without your consent. In a claim to the bank, specify the particular transactions or contract clauses that you consider a violation, and state your demand: recalculate the debt, return what was withheld, stop the accrual. Such a document launches pre-trial debt settlement and records your position before going to court. Attach copies of receipts and screenshots of your requests — this keeps things disciplined and helps if the case reaches court.

A claim under a services contract is addressed to the service provider: a salon, a clinic, an online school, a repair crew, a carrier. Look at what exactly you paid for and what you received: deadlines, scope, quality, completeness. Record any refusal to refund money or to remedy defects — correspondence, an audio recording of the conversation, a delivery receipt. If the service was provided only partially, demand a proportionate reduction in price, not just a full refund.

A claim to a contractor for construction or renovation requires linking to the estimate, the acceptance certificates and photo documentation of defects. Describe which works were not performed, which were done with deviation from the contract, and state one demand: remedy the defects within a reasonable time, reduce the price or reimburse the costs of correction. It is useful to state that hidden defects were discovered after acceptance, if that is the case. Bonafacto lawyers advise checking the claim against the contract before sending:

  • Start and completion dates of works according to the schedule.
  • Composition and cost of materials, who purchases them.
  • Procedure for acceptance of stages and signing of certificates.
  • Liability for delay and defects.

Practical takeaway for each type of dispute: in a banking dispute, attach a calculation of your demands with figures from the statement; in services, keep the receipt and describe exactly what was missing; in construction, attach photos of defects with the date. This way the claim remains a working document, not a formality.

How to link a demand to the contract: a clause-by-clause review

The weak point of a claim under a contract is a demand that is not tied to a specific term of the transaction. The recipient reads such text as a wish and replies with a formal brush-off. What works is different: next to each demand there is a reference to the contract clause, certificate or payment document that substantiates this demand. Then the dispute moves from the plane of emotions to the plane of the terms the parties themselves signed.

The verification procedure is simple. Take the contract with its annexes and mark the clauses that were violated: deadlines, scope, quality, payment procedure. For each clause, select a document confirming the violation — a certificate, a receipt, correspondence, a photo. Then formulate the demand so that it follows from that clause, and state what action and by what deadline you expect from the addressee. If there are several demands, rank them by priority: the addressee should see what to perform first.

  • Contract clause: state the number and substance of the term that was violated.
  • Evidence: attach a document confirming the violation of this particular term.
  • Demand: formulate the action and the deadline for performance without vague wording.
  • Priority: if there are several demands, determine the order in which they must be performed.

Separately, check whether the text still contains demands that you cannot support with a document. It is better to remove the excess before sending: an unsupported clause gives the addressee a reason to challenge the entire claim as a whole, not just the disputed part.

A claim is not just a formality but your first step toward court: its content and proof of sending directly affect how the case will be considered. Natalya Lukyanova

Samal Amanova

What to do after the debtor's response or their silence

The debtor's response determines three different routes: full satisfaction closes the matter, a partial offer requires an assessment of the terms, and silence triggers preparation for court. Once you receive the money or consent, record the fact of performance in writing — a payment order, a receipt, a bank statement, a reconciliation report. If the debtor has proposed an installment plan or a smaller amount, respond in writing: accept the terms, reject them, or propose your own schedule. Silence is also a result: it confirms that the matter has not been resolved voluntarily and opens the way to a claim.

With a partial offer, it is important to understand exactly what is being offered: a deferral of payment, a reduction of the amount, or a substitution of money with property. Document any consent in writing — as an addendum to the contract or a settlement agreement stating the amount, the procedure, and the consequences of non-performance. A verbal agreement over the phone offers no protection: if the schedule is breached, its terms will have to be proven all over again.

  • Full satisfaction: keep the payment document and the debtor's written response — this confirms that the dispute is resolved
  • Partial offer: assess how realistic the schedule is and record the agreed terms in a separate document
  • Silence: keep the pre-action letter, the mailing receipt, and the delivery notification — they will be needed in court

The debtor's response also affects the claim: the correspondence shows that you tried to resolve the matter amicably, and an acknowledgment of debt in the response strengthens your position. If the matter can be resolved through a pre-action letter, Bonafacto lawyers first propose the pre-trial route — it is cheaper and faster than court when the debtor has the means to pay. The absence of a response does not cancel the right to protection: the documents collected become the basis of the statement of claim.

Conclusion

A pre-trial claim is a document with a dual function: it encourages the debtor to satisfy the demand voluntarily and at the same time serves as evidence that you attempted to resolve the dispute before court. It works only under three conditions: the demand is formulated specifically (what, how much and by what deadline), the addressee is identified correctly, and sending and delivery are confirmed in writing.

If even one link is missing — the amount is "approximate," the letter went to the wrong person, there is no receipt — the value of the document drops: in a dispute it becomes harder to prove both the fact of the request and its content. That is why a claim is prepared not hastily, but together with the documents on which it is based.

Services on this topic

Debt recovery lawyer Recovery of debt under a contract or a receipt Lawyer representation in court

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Is it mandatory to send a claim before going to court?

Not always: the mandatory nature is determined by law and the terms of the contract. If a legal norm or the text of the transaction expressly prescribes prior application, it cannot be avoided; in other cases, a claim is a way to speed up resolution, not a pass to court. In disputes over recognition of a right or dissolution of marriage, the claim is accepted immediately.

What happens if the court considers the pre-trial procedure mandatory and no claim was sent?

The statement of claim will be returned (Article 152, part 1 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). Return of the claim is not a denial of protection of the right: you need to send the demand, wait for the response period, and file the application again. Therefore, before filing, check whether the law or the contract requires prior application.

What details and sections must a claim contain?

A header with the details of the sender and recipient, addresses and contacts, then the circumstances of the dispute with reference to the contract and supporting documents. In the middle — a specific demand (amount or action and deadline for performance) and a calculation if money is involved. The text concludes with a list of attachments with copies of documents, date, signature, and for a company — an outgoing number.

How to send a claim to confirm delivery?

Choose a method that leaves a trace: registered mail with acknowledgment of receipt or a service with delivery confirmation. Keep the inventory of the contents, the receipt and the delivery notification — without them it is difficult to confirm what exactly you sent and when the addressee received the letter. The date of delivery will be the starting point for waiting for a response.

To whom should the claim be addressed?

To an organization — at its legal address, to a sole proprietor — to the sole proprietor himself, to a citizen — to that person. Verify the name and address against the transaction documents, not from memory or a website: an error in the addressee or name nullifies the work, the letter will go to the wrong place and time will be lost.

What to do after sending the claim?

Wait for the delivery notification, and then for a written response or the expiry of the waiting period specified in the demand itself. If they refuse or stay silent, prepare the claim and attach the pre-action demand to the case file, keeping a copy of the mailing and the enclosure inventory for yourself.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp