Court and procedure

Securing a claim: why it matters at the start of a case

Securing a claim is a temporary court measure that preserves the disputed property and the defendant's money until a decision on the merits. The application is filed together with the claim or during the proceedings, and the court checks whether the measure is proportionate to the claims asserted.

Application for interim measures and court order seizing property

You have filed a claim or are only preparing it, and the defendant is already withdrawing money from accounts, selling a car, or transferring an apartment to someone else. In a few months you will win the case, but there will be nothing to recover: a writ of execution will not give access to property that no longer exists by that time.

An interim measure closes this gap: the court temporarily freezes the disputed property or money until a decision on the merits. The mistake is that people file such an application too late or draft it without tying it to specific property, and the court refuses. Interim relief works only when the application names a specific asset — an account, a car, a share in a right — rather than an abstract "property of the defendant."

Securing a claim: what it provides at the start of a case

These are urgent measures that the court takes on the plaintiff's application even before a decision is issued. The point is simple: if the debtor manages to withdraw the money, sell the apartment or transfer the car to someone else by the time of the win, the decision will prove empty. Such measures do not recognize the debt and do not resolve the dispute on the merits — they only fix the situation so that there is something to recover by the end.

The court applies them when there is a real risk that the defendant will dispose of property or money. For the plaintiff, this is a way to protect their interests at the start of the case — and at the same time a signal to the defendant that the assets are under control. Why is it disadvantageous to delay the motion? While the court is considering it, the money manages to go to another account, and the car — to a new owner.

The measures work in conjunction with the preparation of the application itself: while the claim is being prepared, Bonafacto lawyers first study the documents and only then assess the prospects, including for urgent securing motions. The application is filed simultaneously with the claim or during the proceedings, and the court considers it without notifying the defendant — the defendant learns about the applied measures only after they have taken effect.

  • Arrest: on money in accounts or property of the defendant
  • Prohibition: to sell, gift or transfer assets
  • Suspension: of recovery under the disputed document
  • Custody: transfer of the item to the plaintiff or a third party

Practical advice: in the application, describe not only the debt itself, but also the specific property you ask to have arrested — this makes it easier for the court to assess that the measure has fulfilled its purpose.

When Interim Measures Are Needed: Risks for You

Interim measures are needed when, before the court's decision, the defendant manages to dispose of the disputed property: re-register an apartment, sell a car, withdraw money from an account. While the proceedings are ongoing, such actions are possible, and a won judgment risks remaining on paper. Interim measures close off this possibility: the court temporarily prohibits transactions with the property, freezes accounts, or places the item in custody. For you, this is not "strengthening the claim" but a way to preserve what can later be recovered.

The risk is assessed before filing, not after receiving the judgment. Specific signs become grounds to act immediately: the debtor has put the property up for sale, is transferring money to third parties, is hastily re-registering the business. Separately, keep in mind the other side: interim measures in a real estate dispute or a loan dispute may also be applied to you as the defendant. Then you will not be able to dispose of the disputed apartment, car, or money until the case is over.

  • The defendant has already put the apartment or car up for sale.
  • The disputed property is registered to relatives or third parties.
  • Money is leaving the accounts in large amounts or being transferred abroad.
  • The business is being hastily re-registered to another person.

A related but different tool is the preservation of evidence: it is needed when a document or correspondence may disappear before the court hearing. Property measures and the preservation of evidence solve different tasks, and they should not be confused in an application. Practical advice: record the signs of risk immediately — screenshots of listings, account statements, correspondence — this will come in handy when you have to justify urgency.

Securing a claim: the list of measures and what they change

Interim measures are a set of actions by which the court temporarily freezes disputed property or prohibits the defendant from taking certain steps, so that nothing disappears before the court's decision. The list includes seizure of property, a prohibition on alienation, a prohibition on the defendant performing specific actions (withdrawing money, re-registering real estate), and transfer of property for safekeeping to a third party or to the claimant. The measure is selected to fit the objective — to preserve money, real estate, or a specific item — and this determines exactly what will change for each party.

For you, this means the defendant will not be able to sell, gift, or transfer to relatives the disputed apartment, car, or share in a company. For the defendant, it means temporary restrictions: they cannot dispose of the seized property but continue to use it, unless the court has prohibited that. Bonafacto lawyers, at the stage of preparing documents, check the wording of the measure against exactly what asset you risk losing — this determines which measure to request.

Main interim measures and their consequences
Measure What happens For the plaintiff For the defendant
Seizure of property Property cannot be sold or re-registered The possibility of recovery is preserved Owns but cannot dispose
Prohibition on alienation Sale or gift transactions are blocked The asset remains with the defendant Cannot sell or gift
Prohibition of specific actions The defendant cannot perform specific operations The disputed item does not disappear before trial Restricted in actions related to the claim
Transfer for safekeeping Property is assigned to a custodian Control over preservation Uses within the limits set by the court

The measure is chosen to fit the objective: to preserve money, real estate, or a specific item.

What changes in practice: seizure and prohibition on alienation affect disposal, not use, so the defendant continues to live in the apartment or drive the car — but can no longer sell them. Transfer for safekeeping is a stricter option: the item is assigned to a custodian, and the defendant's access to it is restricted. If you are unsure which measure will cover your specific risk, compare it with what the defendant can actually do with the disputed asset before trial.

How the wording of a measure becomes an enforceable court ruling

Whether a measure works is decided not by its name but by how precisely the application describes the object and the action the defendant is prohibited from taking. The wording "seize the defendant's property" gives the court nothing to work with: it is unclear what exactly to block and where to look for it. The same measure, stated as seizure of a specific object or account, is enforced in a targeted manner.

The procedure is as follows: first, the objective is determined — to prevent the sale of the apartment, to prevent money from leaving the account, to preserve the item itself until the decision. Then, the type of measure is selected to fit the objective and described so that the bailiff can enforce the ruling without guesswork. Next, documents are attached to the application showing that the object exists and is connected to the defendant: an extract from the register, a technical passport, account information. The set is completed by a justification of urgency — facts, not general words.

  • Object: address, cadastral or registration data, account number — everything that allows the asset to be unambiguously identified.
  • Action: what exactly the defendant is prohibited from doing — selling, gifting, re-registering, withdrawing funds.
  • Connection to the claim: why the dispute concerns precisely this property or amount.
  • Confirmation: a document showing the existence of the object and its belonging to the defendant.
  • Urgency: specific facts showing that the defendant is already disposing of the asset.

A typical mistake is to request more than necessary "just in case": seizing all accounts in a dispute over a single item looks like pressure rather than protection, and the connection between the measure and the claim is lost. The opposite extreme is to limit oneself to a single object, even though the defendant may withdraw money through other property as well. Check the wording for enforceability: if the ruling does not make it possible to understand unambiguously what to block, the measure will remain on paper.

How to Draft an Application for Interim Measures: Documents and Procedure

An application for interim measures is filed either together with the claim or as a separate motion during the proceedings. In the first case, the court decides on the interim measure as part of accepting the claim; in the second, it considers the motion as a standalone request. Drafting a claim and a motion for a measure are not the same thing: the claim sets out the demand, while the motion explains why, without the measure, the judgment risks remaining on paper. The mistake is to file a motion using the same wording as the claim, without separate justification of the risk.

The court checks whether the demand is connected to the interim measure, whether the measure is proportionate, and whether there is a threat that the judgment will not be enforced. As grounds, state specific facts: the defendant is selling property, withdrawing money from accounts, leaving the country. General phrases such as "may abscond" or "may not comply" will not convince the court.

What to attach to the motion

  • Copy of the claim: if the demand has already been filed, attach a copy with a filing mark.
  • Documents for the property: an extract from the register, technical passport, account information — whatever you ask to have the measure applied to.
  • Correspondence: messages in which the defendant threatens to sell or hide assets.
  • Information about a sell-off: data showing that the property is already being offered for sale or the business is being closed.
  • Calculation of the claim amount: the amount you ask to secure — without it, the court finds it difficult to assess proportionality.

Procedure

First, determine exactly which measure you are requesting and which property it affects. Then collect evidence of the risk — documents, correspondence, account information. After that, prepare the text of the motion: the demand, the measure, the justification of the threat, the list of attachments. File it simultaneously with the claim or separately during the case — in the second case, the court considers the request as a standalone one. At this stage, Bonafacto lawyers check that the measure is tied to a specific asset rather than requested "just in case": vague wording reduces the chances of satisfaction.

At Bonafacto, the motion is prepared together with the claim materials so that the court sees the link "demand — risk — measure" in one package. Practical tip: check in advance with a notary or in the register whose name the property is recorded under — a measure against someone else's asset will have no effect.

How to describe the property so that the measure works

The wording of the measure must allow it to be enforced literally: not "seize the defendant's property," but a specific object — an apartment with an address, a car with model and registration details, an account at a specific bank. If exact data is unavailable, the motion asks the court to request information about property and accounts, and the measure is described for the assets already known. The more precise the tie-in, the fewer grounds the court has to return the motion for clarification — and every such delay works in favor of the defendant, who retains time to dispose of the asset.

Separately, think through exactly what you ask to prohibit: sale, gift, re-registration, withdrawal of money. A prohibition to "perform any actions" sounds broad, but the court finds it difficult to verify its enforcement, whereas a targeted prohibition on a specific transaction is clear both to the enforcement officer and to the parties.

What a typical motion lacks

  • Link to the demand: a paragraph that expressly states how the measure relates to the filed claim rather than to unrelated assets.
  • Chronology of the risk: dates and facts — when the property was listed for sale, when the money was withdrawn — without them, the threat looks like an assumption.
  • Request for urgency: a separate line on why the measure must be taken immediately, with reference to the disposal that has already begun.
  • Numbered list of attachments: each document gets its own item so that the court sees what supports each argument.
  • Contact for communication: a phone number and a means of prompt contact in case the court wants to clarify details on the motion.

Practical tip: before filing, reread the motion through a judge's eyes — can you tell from it in a minute exactly what to seize, why now, and what confirms it. If the answer is not obvious, the text is worth rewriting.

Proportionality of the measure and counter-security: how the court weighs interests

An interim measure must correspond to the claim asserted: the court ensures that an arrest or prohibition does not turn out broader than what the plaintiff seeks to recover or reclaim. Arresting "everything" in a lease dispute is a typical overreach: the claim concerns a specific amount or specific premises, yet property unrelated to the dispute falls under the prohibition. Where such a mismatch exists, the court is entitled to adjust the measure, and the defendant may assert that it is excessive.

The defendant is not left passive: they may request replacement of the measure, and in a monetary claim — deposit the claimed amount with the court instead of having property arrested. This changes the balance of power — instead of frozen assets, the plaintiff gets a claim secured by money, while the defendant continues to use their property. For the plaintiff, such a turn means that pressuring with a "broad" arrest is disadvantageous: the defendant will lift it with counter-security.

  • Proportionality: the measure is tied to the subject matter of the dispute and the size of the claim.
  • Replacement of the measure: the defendant is entitled to ask the court for a different interim measure.
  • Counter-security: in a monetary claim — depositing the claimed amount with the court.
  • Plaintiff's tactics: request a specific measure for a specific asset, not arrest of all property.

A practical takeaway for the plaintiff: in the application, describe the asset you are asking to arrest and tie the measure to the value of the claim. It is better to prepare the statement of claim and the application for interim measures together — this makes it easier to show the court the link between the claim and the measure. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, so document preparation can be planned in advance.

The defendant should remember: an application to replace the measure is not a dispute about fault, but a way to remove an excessive restriction. Bonafacto lawyers in such a situation first study the documents and only then assess the prospects.

How the court checks the balance: a step-by-step breakdown

The weighing of interests rests on three pillars: the link between the measure and the claim, its size relative to the value of the claim, and the reality of the threat of non-enforcement. The court does not assess whether the plaintiff is right on the merits — at this stage it is enough for the court to see that the requested restriction does not go beyond the scope of the dispute. That is why an application where the measure is "tailored" to a specific object passes review more smoothly than a request to arrest all of the debtor's property.

Then counter-security comes into play. A defendant who disagrees with the arrest is entitled to offer the court their own version of protection: a deposit in the amount of the claim or another measure that preserves the plaintiff's interest but does not paralyze the defendant's activity. The court weighs two interests — not losing the possibility of recovery and not stifling the defendant before the decision. Which prevails depends on how precisely the plaintiff explained the risk and how serious the defendant's losses from the restriction are.

  • Link to the claim: the measure concerns the same object or amount as the claim.
  • Size of the restriction: the arrest must not exceed the value of the claim.
  • Reality of the threat: facts are needed, not general words about possible asset stripping.
  • Defendant's alternative: a deposit or another measure instead of arrest.

A common mistake by the plaintiff is to request the maximum "just in case," expecting the court to trim it down itself. The calculation is wrong: an excessive request gives the defendant an argument about excessiveness and grounds to seek replacement. A precise formulation of the measure saves time and reduces the risk that the restriction will be lifted at the most inconvenient moment.

The defendant, conversely, should not stay silent: the earlier they assert disproportionality and offer counter-security, the less downtime in work and transactions. It is reasonable to prepare such an application in parallel with the defense on the merits — documents on property and obligations will be useful in both proceedings.

Securing a claim and replacing measures: how to protect yourself

If the court has already granted measures on your motion, the defendant has the right to ask that they be replaced with another measure, and in a monetary claim — to deposit the claimed amount with the court instead of having an attachment imposed. This way the defendant lifts the attachment from accounts and property without waiting for a decision in the case. The matter is resolved in the same proceedings in which the claim is being heard.

Replacement is not cancellation: the previous measure ceases to apply, but the protection of the plaintiff's interests is preserved in a new form. The court assesses whether the proposed arrangement is proportionate to the risks of both parties and whether it worsens the position of the party in whose favor the measures were granted. It is in the defendant's interest to show that the new measure genuinely secures enforcement of the future decision, rather than simply freeing up assets.

  • Application: the defendant files it with the court hearing the case, setting out why the current measure is excessive.
  • Confirmation: the application is accompanied by documents on depositing the amount with the court or describes the proposed replacement measure.
  • Outcome: the court issues a ruling replacing the measure or refusing to do so; it affects the interests of the parties and is therefore subject to appeal in the established procedure.

If the measures are later found to be unjustified, the defendant has grounds to raise the question of compensation for losses incurred because of them. The amount and causal link will have to be proven separately — the mere fact of interim measures does not confirm losses. Practical advice: record the expenses and downtime caused by the attachment while they are fresh — later it is harder to gather supporting evidence.

Securing a claim: common mistakes and how to avoid them

Mistakes in securing a claim are costly: the court refuses to grant the measures, and the defendant has time to move money out or re-register property. A typical mistake is when the applicant does not specify exactly which property or account should be seized, what confirms their arguments, and why the measures are needed urgently. The court rejects an application without specifics, and the applicant loses time.

Choosing a measure unrelated to the stated claim also leads to refusal: for example, in a claim to terminate a lease agreement, you ask to seize all of the defendant's accounts. If you delay the application while the defendant disposes of assets, the measures lose their purpose. At Bonafacto, the cost of this stage is fixed in the contract before work begins — this makes it easier to understand exactly what to ask the court for and which documents to attach.

To avoid mistakes, check that the application contains:

  • A specific object: the property, account or action of the defendant that the measure is requested against — without wording like "all property" and "all accounts".
  • Supporting documents: statements, contracts, correspondence — anything that shows the existence of the property and the defendant's conduct.
  • Link between the measure and the claim: an explanation of why this particular measure secures the stated claim rather than another one.
  • Justification of urgency: facts showing that without the measure the court's decision will be difficult to enforce.
  • Timing of filing: the application is filed before the assets are gone — delay devalues the measure itself.

A separate mistake is asking for more than the claim is worth: a disproportionate measure does not protect but creates risk for the applicant themselves. It is better to check the application before filing, not after a refusal — rewriting it during the process is harder.

Securing a claim: duration and cancellation

Interim measures securing a claim remain in effect until the judgment is enforced, if the claim is satisfied. If the claim is denied, they remain in effect until the judgment enters into legal force. Measures are lifted earlier than this period when the court issues a separate ruling cancelling them — a denial of the claim by itself does not lift the protective attachment.

Cancellation is possible upon the defendant's application or on the court's own initiative. Grounds: the need for the measure has ceased, the claim has been left without consideration or returned, or the proceedings have been terminated. A separate scenario is the defendant depositing the claimed amount with the court: in that case the court may replace the attachment of property with this amount.

  • The need has ceased: the circumstances for which the measure was introduced have changed.
  • The claim is left without consideration or returned: further retention of the property loses its basis.
  • The proceedings are terminated: the dispute has ended without a judgment on the merits.
  • Settlement agreement: the parties have resolved the conflict themselves.
  • Deposit of the amount: the defendant proposes that the court replace one measure with another.
What changes for the parties when the securing of a claim is cancelled
Situation Who applies What happens to the measures
The need for the measure has ceased Defendant or court The measures are lifted
The claim is returned or left without consideration Court The securing ceases to apply
The case is terminated Court The restrictions are lifted
The amount is deposited Defendant Replacement of the measure is possible

The court resolves the issue of cancellation by a separate ruling; the procedure for appealing such a ruling should be clarified with the court.

A practical point: it is in the defendant's interest not to wait for the end of the case but to raise the issue of replacing or lifting the measure as soon as grounds arise — otherwise the attachment will continue to work against them. The plaintiff, in turn, should keep ready documents confirming that the measure is still needed.

How the lifting of a measure proceeds: steps and documents

The lifting of securing goes through an application to the same court that is hearing or heard the case — there is no separate body for this. The application is filed in writing, with copies for the other party, and states which measure and on what ground should cease. The court verifies whether the circumstances have indeed changed and issues a ruling.

  • Application: which measure is being lifted, on what ground, and from what point in time.
  • Confirmation of the ground: a document on leaving the claim without consideration, on its return, on termination of the case, or on a settlement agreement.
  • Confirmation of replacement: a document on depositing the amount with the court, if the defendant proposes such a measure.
  • Copies for the parties: the application is sent to the participants in the case so that they can set out their position.

Separately, one should keep in mind the cost of a mistake: if the measures are later cancelled as unjustified, the defendant is entitled to claim compensation for losses caused by the securing of the claim, and this issue is resolved separately, with proof of causation and the exact amount of losses. Therefore, it is useful for the plaintiff to keep correspondence and documents showing why the measure was introduced and why it remained necessary. And for the defendant — to record their losses from the attachment if they expect to be compensated for them.

Securing a claim works only if it is requested simultaneously with the claim or immediately afterwards, before the defendant learns of the dispute. An application without specific property and evidence of risk will be rejected by the court. Natalya Lukyanova

Ruslan Kanseitov

Conclusion

Interim measures produce an effect when they are applied for in a timely manner and tied to a specific asset of the defendant. An application without evidence of risk and without a connection to the stated claim yields no result.

Parties use the replacement and lifting of measures as a tool for balancing interests: the defendant is entitled to request relief, while the plaintiff should ensure that the interim measures are not lifted prematurely. A practical takeaway for the end: verify what substantiates the risk before filing, not after a refusal.

Services on this topic

Representation in court Debt recovery lawyer Recovery under a contract and a receipt

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Why do I need to secure a claim if I have already filed the claim?

A claim records your demand, but it does not stop the defendant from disposing of the disputed property while the case is ongoing. A securing measure temporarily freezes a specific asset — an account, a car, an apartment — so that there is something to recover by the time of the court's decision. Without it, a won case risks remaining on paper: a writ of execution will not give access to property that no longer exists.

When should the motion to secure a claim be filed?

The application is filed together with the claim or as a separate motion during the proceedings. Delaying is disadvantageous: while the court is considering the motion, the money manages to move to another account and the car to a new owner. The court considers such an application without notifying the defendant, and the defendant learns about the measures only after they have taken effect.

What measures can the court apply?

Seizure of property or money in accounts, a prohibition on alienation — sale, gifting, re-registration, a prohibition on the defendant performing specific actions, and transfer of an item for safekeeping. Seizure and a prohibition on alienation affect disposal, not use: the defendant continues to live in the apartment or drive the car, but can no longer sell them. Transfer for safekeeping is a stricter option; the defendant's access to the item is restricted.

Why does the court refuse securing measures?

Because of the wording: "seize the defendant's property" gives the court nothing to latch onto; it is unclear what exactly to block and where to look for it. The application needs a specific object — address and registration details, account number — the action the defendant is prohibited from taking, and supporting documents confirming the asset exists. General phrases like "may abscond" or "may not comply" will not convince the court — specific facts are needed.

What risk indicators should be documented?

The debtor has listed property for sale, transfers money to third parties in large amounts or abroad, hastily re-registers the business, and the disputed property is registered to relatives or third parties. Document such indicators immediately — screenshots of listings, statements, correspondence: they will be useful when you have to justify urgency. Risk is assessed before filing, not after receiving the decision.

Can securing measures be applied to me as a defendant?

Yes, and this is worth remembering: in a real estate dispute or a loan case, measures may be applied to you as well. Then you will not be able to dispose of the disputed apartment, car or money until the case ends. You can still use the asset, unless the court has prohibited that too.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp