Construction

Contractor failed to perform the work: the customer's course of action in Kazakhstan

Recovery under a work contract begins with documenting the breach and checking the contract terms, not with filing a claim. First, the customer gathers documents and correspondence, then sends a pre-action demand, and only after that goes to court.

Contractor disappeared with the advance payment: what to do

A typical situation: the contractual deadlines have passed, the site stands idle, the contractor is not responding, and the advance payment transferred has not been returned. The solution depends on two things — what is written in the contract and whether the deadline for performance of the works has arrived.

Below is a sequence of steps: which documents and correspondence to collect first, how to draft a claim, in which court to file the lawsuit and what to demand in addition to the return of the advance. Separately — interim measures and mistakes because of which the client loses position even before the trial.

Where to start checking if a contractor failed to perform the work

Start with the contract and the calendar: the check is needed to understand whether the performance deadline has arrived and whether you have grounds to make a claim. A work contract is governed by the Civil Code of the RK , and it is its terms that determine when the contractor's obligation is considered breached. Bonafacto lawyers first read the contract and payment documents, and only then assess the prospects of the claims.

Find in the text the scope of work, the start and completion dates, the procedure for handing over the result, the terms on staged acceptance, and how the parties record performance. The answer to the question of whether there is a delay lies precisely in these clauses. If the deadlines are vague, rely on the agreed stages and the correspondence — it shows how the parties understood the schedule.

Next, gather the evidence. Below is what to prepare before the first demand.

  • Contract: scope, deadlines, acceptance stages, procedure for recording performance.
  • Calendar: check the date the deadline falls due — whether the delay already exists or the deadline is still running.
  • Inspection report: date, signatures, photos and video of the site.
  • Payments: documents on the transfer of the advance payment.
  • Correspondence: email, messengers, letters to the contractor.
  • Internal documents: passes, logs, internal memos on the site.

At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins — so the client sees in advance what they are paying for. A practical tip: do not send a demand until you have verified the deadline — the contractor will use a premature demand as an argument in their own favour.

The deadline has not yet expired: what you can and cannot demand

Until the deadline for completing the work has arrived, it is too early to demand a refund of the advance and a penalty: there is no breach yet. The construction contract ties the customer's right to make claims to the completion date of the work, so before that date it is reasonable to remind the contractor of the need to perform and to record this reminder in writing. When the deadline has arrived and the result has not been delivered, delay arises. From that moment, you can demand a refund of the unworked advance, a penalty if it is provided for, or terminate the contract and demand compensation for losses. The claim is sent in writing, with a calculation of the amount and a response deadline; if there is no response, the dispute is resolved in court.

If the deadline was extended by a supplementary agreement, the previous dates no longer matter, and the delay is calculated from the new date. It is worth verifying the signatures of both parties and the subject of the agreement: whether it changes specifically the deadline for the work, and not the payment procedure. Without such a document, the contractor's reference to an extension of the deadline is not confirmed.

  • Check the contract: the start and completion dates of the work, and the procedure for extending the deadline.
  • Establish whether the deadline for completing the work has arrived as of the current date.
  • Send the contractor a written reminder before the deadline expires.
  • After the deadline arrives, prepare a claim with a calculation of the unworked advance.
  • Collect correspondence, payment documents and evidence of non-performance.
  • If there are signs that the contractor never intended to work, file a fraud report with the police (Art. 190 of the CC of the RK) — the provision on theft of another person's property by deception or abuse of trust.

How a reminder and notifications help before the deadline arrives

A written reminder before the deadline expires is not a formality, but a way to record that the customer acted prudently and did not create obstacles for the contractor. It is better to send it in a way that leaves proof of delivery: hand delivery against signature, a registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt, or a message to the email address agreed in the contract. Attach a copy with a receipt mark or tracking number to the case file — together with the correspondence, it shows the chronology of events.

In the reminder itself, it is useful to list exactly what has not been done and by what date the result is expected, and also to ask for a written report on the progress of the work. The contractor's response or lack of one is also evidence: the contractor's silence when the customer is ready to discuss deadlines works against the contractor in a dispute.

  • Communication channel: use the address or number expressly specified in the contract — this makes delivery easier to confirm.
  • Content: list the unperformed work and the expected date of the result, and request a written response on the status of matters.
  • Confirmation: keep the receipt, the acknowledgment of delivery or the tracking number of the shipment.
  • Chronology: keep a single table of dates — contract, payment, reminders, contractor's responses.
  • Mistake: do not limit yourself to calls and oral agreements — in a dispute they are not supported by anything.

Advance payment transferred, works not performed: legal grounds for claims

The basis of the claim is the absence of counter-performance: the customer paid, but did not receive the result of the works. An advance payment under a contract for work is a preliminary payment that is credited toward future works. Unlike a deposit, it does not secure performance and does not confirm the conclusion of a contract: upon termination of the obligation, it is returned to the paying party. If the works are not performed, the money loses its basis for retention and becomes an unworked advance.

A deposit is a means of security: the party responsible for non-performance forfeits it or returns it in double the amount. An advance payment does not entail such consequences, so its return does not depend on fault for the failure of the works. Contracts for work are governed by the Civil Code of the RK, and a claim for the recovery of funds under a contract for work is built on two facts: payment is confirmed, the result has not been delivered.

  • Advance payment: a preliminary payment that, upon termination of the obligation, is returned to the paying party.
  • Deposit: a means of security — in case of non-performance it is forfeited or returned in double the amount.
  • Unworked advance: money that has lost its basis for retention after the failure of the works.
  • Termination of the contract: eliminates the basis for retention; after it, the advance is recovered as unjust enrichment.
  • Proof: it is sufficient to confirm payment and the absence of works.

Practical conclusion: document the payment and the absence of the result before asserting a claim — this determines what you can rely on in a dispute.

What to include in a claim to a contractor

A claim is a written demand by the customer to the contractor, in which the facts of a breach of the construction contract are tied to specific demands and a response deadline. The document is signed by the customer or their representative under a power of attorney. Before sending, verify every figure and date against the primary documents: the contract, the payment order, the acts. The contractor will use any discrepancy between the text of the claim and the account statement as a reason to delay a response.

The structure of the document follows the logic of the dispute. The introductory part names the parties, the details of the construction contract and the period for performing the work. The descriptive part sets out the facts in sequence: conclusion of the contract, transfer of the advance, non-performance of the work and failure to return the amount. The reasoning part provides references to the terms of the contract and to the norms of the Civil Code of the RK on construction contracts and on obligations. The demand part contains the return of the unworked advance and payment of a penalty, if it is provided for by the contract or by law, the deadline for a response and the method of transferring the money. Make the wording specific, without alternatives that allow evasion of a response: Bonafacto lawyers in such documents fix one demand and one deadline, not a menu of options.

Before sending, check that the claim contains all mandatory elements:

  • Parties: the name of the customer and the contractor, their IIN or BIN
  • Contract: the details of the construction contract and the date of its conclusion
  • Payment: the amount of the advance transferred and the date of payment
  • Breach: the specific works that were not performed on time
  • Demand: return of the advance and payment of the penalty
  • Response: the response deadline and bank details for the transfer

Send the claim in a way that leaves a trace: by mail with acknowledgment of receipt or through a channel where proof of delivery is preserved. Keep a copy with the delivery receipt together with the contract and the payment order — it will be needed if the dispute reaches court.

Calculating the unworked advance: how to present it in the claim

The amount of the demand is the difference between the advance transferred and the cost of the result actually accepted, and in the claim it is itemized line by line, not stated as a single figure. Attach a table: payment, date, purpose, cost of the works performed and accepted, balance to be returned. If acceptance acts were not signed, state directly that the result was not handed over to you — then the entire advance remains unworked.

What to attach to the claim
Document Why it is needed
Construction contract with appendices Confirms the deadlines, scope and acceptance procedure
Payment order or receipt Proves the transfer of the advance
Site inspection act Records the absence or incompleteness of the works
Correspondence on deadlines and scope Shows that the contractor knew about the breaches

Copies of the appendices are certified by the customer; the originals remain with them until court.

A typical mistake is to demand the return of the entire amount without separating the accepted stages: the contractor will object on the scope, and the dispute will drag on. The second mistake is to refer in the claim to oral agreements on postponing the deadline without a signed agreement: such arguments are not confirmed. And the third: not specifying the method of returning the money, as a result of which the contractor responds with general phrases and stalls for time.

Pre-trial settlement: negotiations and a termination agreement

If the contractor has not performed the work, it is worth pursuing pre-trial settlement before filing a claim. The Civil Code of the RK governs contracts for work and allows an obligation to be amended or terminated by agreement of the parties. Conduct negotiations in writing: a formal demand describing the scope breached and proposing discussion of a refund of the advance payment. Oral arrangements are not supported by any evidence — in a dispute they will not replace a written document.

The first option is a contract termination agreement: it records the termination of the obligation and the fate of the advance payment. The second is a repayment schedule with amounts and payment dates, signed by the parties. It turns a dispute over whether the debt exists into a dispute over deadlines.

Bonafacto lawyers first study the documents and only then assess the prospects — in negotiations this helps immediately separate the claims the contractor is prepared to settle amicably from those that will have to be proven. Written recording of every step (who agreed to what and when) will be useful if the agreement is never signed.

While the work deadline has not expired, one must not rush to file a claim — but correspondence, inspections and notifications must be recorded already at that stage. It is precisely these documents that later decide the dispute. Kristina Adilova

Aizhana Medetova

Collecting evidence before court: documents and correspondence

Before going to court, collect evidence of non-performance of work: the construction contract with all appendices, the agreed estimate, the technical specification, the work schedule, and acts of transfer of materials and access to the site. Payment orders, receipts or invoices confirm the transfer of the advance payment. Correspondence in messengers and by email discussing deadlines and scope is also part of the case — it is preserved in its original form with attachments and metadata, not just as screenshots. When reviewing documents, Bonafacto lawyers look specifically at the "contract — payment — correspondence" link: individually each file is weaker than together.

Store electronic evidence so that it can be verified: export the chat in full with dates and participants, save emails in a format with headers, make backups on a medium. Securing evidence with a notary — a protocol of inspection of correspondence — simplifies confirmation but does not replace the other documents. Photographs and video recordings of the site or undelivered material record the condition as of the date. Witnesses are useful for confirming the inspection and the progress of work; the transfer of money under a transaction requiring written form cannot be confirmed by witness testimony (Art. 153 of the CC of the RK).

  • The construction contract and all signed appendices, the estimate, the technical specification.
  • Payment orders, receipts or invoices for the transfer of the advance payment.
  • Correspondence in messengers and by email with attachments and metadata.
  • Photographs and video recordings of the site, materials, and place of work.
  • Written explanations of witnesses with their contact details.
  • Inspection acts drawn up with the participation of disinterested persons.
What each document confirms
Document What it confirms How to preserve it
Contract and appendices Obligations, deadlines, scope Original and scan
Estimate, technical specification Agreed cost and types of work Copy with signatures
Payment orders, receipts Transfer of the advance payment Bank statement
Correspondence Acknowledgment of debt, promises, deadlines Chat export with metadata
Photos and video Condition of the site or absence of work Files with the shooting date
Witness explanations Inspection of the site, progress of work Written form, details

Keep both paper originals and electronic copies: the court assesses evidence as a whole.

How to build a chronology and not lose evidence

Work with evidence begins with a chronology: reconstruct the sequence of events by dates — from the signing of the contract and the transfer of the advance payment to the contractor's last message. Arrange the documents by stages: conclusion of the contract, payment, progress of work, correspondence about deadlines and scope, refusal to perform. Such an inventory helps both in the claim and in the statement of claim: it shows which fact is confirmed by what and where there is a gap in the chain.

Next, check each document for legibility and completeness. The payment order must show the purpose of payment and the recipient's details, the correspondence must show the participants and dates, and the photographs must show the link to the site. If any document is lost, record this in advance and consider how else to confirm the fact.

  • Chronology: compile the events by dates into a single table or list.
  • Inventory: sign the list of documents indicating what each one confirms.
  • Completeness: check the legibility of scans, the details and the dates.
  • Backup: keep copies separately from the originals and do not edit the files.

Do not send the contractor the only copies of documents and do not agree to "add" what is missing to already signed papers — corrections and additions weaken the evidence. Practical advice: create a separate folder for the dispute and put everything there at once, with the date of receipt — by the time of the claim you will already have a complete set.

Which court hears the dispute and how to file a claim

A claim is filed with the district court at the defendant's place of residence if the customer is a citizen without entrepreneur status; a dispute between business entities is heard by the specialised inter-district economic court. Contracting relations are governed by the Civil Code of the RK, and the parties may change territorial jurisdiction by agreement. A consumer may also apply at their own place of residence. The amount of the claim affects the size of the state duty at the rates of the Tax Code of the RK — it is calculated before filing so as not to redo the documents because of underpayment.

The economic court accepts cases between entrepreneurs regardless of the amount. The claim is accompanied by the contract, evidence of the advance payment, correspondence and a pre-trial demand letter — it is the demand letter that confirms compliance with the pre-trial procedure. Recovery of debt through the court begins with filing a claim with a package of attachments; a copy with a mark of acceptance should be kept. If the defendant is registered in another region, the claim is sent there — at its location, not at the construction site.

Practical advice: check the jurisdiction and the state duty before sending the documents — an error in the court or the amount of the fee postpones the proceedings.

Interim measures: how to secure the debtor's assets

Interim measures are needed so that by the time the decision takes effect, the defendant still has property against which the money can be recovered. Without such a measure, the contractor may have neither an account nor assets — and then even a won case will not return the advance payment. The measure is appropriate if the defendant is withdrawing funds, selling property, closing accounts, or already has unfulfilled obligations to other creditors. The application is filed together with the claim or during the proceedings; the court assesses the proportionality of the measure to the stated claim and the risk of non-enforcement of the future decision.

Evidence confirming both the claim and the risk itself is attached to the application. It is better to collect it in advance — before filing:

  • Bank documents: account statements and information on the movement of money under the contract.
  • Correspondence: messages about deadlines, volumes, and the return of the advance payment.
  • Data on the contractor: information about a change of director, address, or composition of participants.
  • Information on debts: information about other claims and enforcement proceedings against the contractor.
  • Property: documents on the contractor's ownership of assets, if available.

A practical point: the more specifically the application describes the property or account, the clearer it is to the court what exactly is to be secured — a general wording such as "seize everything" does not provide such clarity.

What Is Recovered Beyond the Advance

In addition to the return of the advance, the customer has the right to claim a penalty, interest for the use of money, and compensation for losses. The construction contract is governed by the Civil Code of the RK, and it is its provisions that determine the sanctions if the parties have not stipulated them themselves. A penalty may be contractual or statutory, and each claim is substantiated separately — the court assesses their independence, not as a single list.

Interest is accrued on the amount of the unjustifiably retained advance based on the base rate of the National Bank of the RK (Art. 353 of the Civil Code of the RK), for the period from the moment when the contractor was obliged to return the funds. Losses include actual damage and lost profit; their existence and amount are proven by the customer. If the work has been partially performed, the amount of claims is reduced by the value of the accepted result.

In the prayer for relief of the claim, they list what is confirmed by the calculation and documents:

  • Unworked advance: the amount transferred to the contractor and not covered by completed work.
  • Contractual penalty: a sanction for delay in the amount and on the terms stipulated in the contract.
  • Statutory penalty: applied if the contract does not provide for it.
  • Interest for non-performance of a monetary obligation: accrued under Art. 353 of the Civil Code of the RK on the retained amount.
  • Actual damage: expenses incurred by the customer due to non-performance, confirmed by documents.
  • Lost profit: recovered if its amount is substantiated.

Practical advice: consolidate all amounts in advance into a single table with periods and grounds — this makes it easier to link each claim to the evidence and not lose it in the calculation.

Enforcement of the decision: from the writ of execution to recovery

After the decision enters into legal force, the court issues a writ of execution. It is submitted to a private bailiff at the place of residence or location of the debtor or their property. Enforcement proceedings are initiated on the basis of the enforcement document, and the debtor is given a period for voluntary compliance; in case of non-compliance, recovery moves to the compulsory stage. The procedure for recovering debt under a court decision does not end there: the writ is only the entry point into the procedure; thereafter, the progress of the case depends on how actively the creditor monitors the bailiff's actions.

The bailiff sends requests to the authorized bodies to identify property: real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, shares in legal entities. If no property is found, at the creditor's application, a search may be announced for the debtor or their property. Property is subject to arrest, and accounts are blocked within the amount of recovery. Check which requests have already been sent and which responses have been received — this information helps to file motions in a timely manner and not lose the assets found.

What the creditor should do, step by step:

  • Writ of execution: obtain it after the decision enters into force
  • Submission: hand the writ to a private bailiff
  • Monitoring the search: check the progress of the property search and the arrests imposed
  • Lifting restrictions: monitor the termination of measures after the debt is repaid
  • New information: if there is no property, resume enforcement when data on assets appears
  • Signs of embezzlement: if there is intent to embezzle the advance payment — file a report with the police under Art. 190 of the Criminal Code of the RK

Common mistakes made by the client

The client's position is weakest when they themselves have not documented the terms and payment. A work contract is governed by the Civil Code of the RK: without a written document, it is difficult to prove the agreed deadlines, scope and type of work. Oral agreements allow the contractor to reclassify the relationship as one-off services or deny them, and claims for a refund of the advance and a penalty hang in the air.

Payment in cash without a receipt is the second typical mistake. Transferring money for materials or a stage of work without written acknowledgment from the recipient is almost impossible to confirm. A bank transfer or payment order with the reference "advance under a work contract" records the fact of payment. A receipt separate from the contract must contain the parties' details, the basis for payment and the recipient's signature — Bonafacto lawyers advise keeping it together with the contract.

The client's mistake and its consequence
Mistake Consequence for the client
No written work contract The deadline, scope and price of the work are not proven; the contractor disputes the obligation itself
Payment in cash without a receipt It is impossible to confirm the transfer of the advance; the claim for a refund is unprovable
No acts or records of stages The fact of non-performance of the work or its improper quality is not confirmed
Deleting correspondence and drafts Evidence of agreements, notifications and pre-trial demands is lost
Skipping the claim procedure If a claim is mandatory under the contract or law, the lawsuit is returned and time is lost

Compliance with the written form, recording of payment and preservation of correspondence reduce the risk of denial of protection of the client's rights.

Conclusion

A dispute with a contractor who failed to perform the work follows a clear sequence: verifying the deadline under the contract, documenting the breach, a written pre-action claim, pre-trial settlement, a lawsuit with interim measures, and then enforcement of the decision. Each step relies on documents collected in advance — the contract with its appendices, proof of payment, and correspondence about deadlines and scope.

A written form of the agreements, recorded payment of the advance, and preserved correspondence reduce the risk of being denied protection of rights: without them, it is harder to prove both the existence of the relationship itself and the breach of its terms. The outcome of the case is not guaranteed — it is determined by the court, not by the claimant.

A practical guideline: the earlier the breach is documented and the claim is sent, the easier it is to build a position and preserve the debtor's assets until the decision is enforced.

Services on this topic

Construction lawyer

FAQ

Questions and answers

Didn't find your question? Ask it directly — we'll reply on WhatsApp.

Ask a question
Where should I start if the contractor failed to perform the work?

Start with the contract and the calendar: check whether the deadline for performance has arrived and what exactly the contract says about deadlines, acceptance stages, and documenting performance. Then gather evidence — the contract, payment documents for the advance, an inspection report of the site with photos and video, and correspondence with the contractor. Until you have verified the deadline, it is better not to send a demand: the contractor will use a premature demand as an argument in their favor.

Can I demand a refund of the advance if the work deadline has not yet expired?

No, until the work deadline arrives, it is too early to demand a refund of the advance and a penalty — there is no breach yet. A work contract ties the customer's right to make claims to the completion date. Before that date, it is reasonable to send the contractor a written reminder about the need to perform and keep proof of delivery.

What is the difference between an advance and a deposit, and why does it matter in a dispute?

An advance is a preliminary payment that, upon termination of the obligation, is returned to the paying party; it does not secure performance and does not confirm the conclusion of the contract. A deposit is a security measure: the party responsible for non-performance forfeits it or returns it in double the amount. Therefore, the return of an advance does not depend on fault for the failure of the work, and after termination of the contract it is recovered as unjust enrichment.

What should a pre-action demand to the contractor contain?

A pre-action demand is a written demand by the customer in which the facts of the breach of the work contract are linked to specific demands and a response deadline. It states the parties and their IIN or BIN, the contract details, the amount and date of the advance transfer, the specific unperformed work, the demand to return the advance and pay a penalty if provided for, the response deadline, and bank details. Make the wording specific, without alternatives that allow evasion of a response.

How should the calculation of the unworked advance be shown in the demand?

The claim amount is the difference between the advance transferred and the value of the result actually accepted, and it should be itemized line by line, not as a single figure. Attach a table: payment, date, purpose, value of work performed and accepted, balance to be returned. If acceptance certificates were not signed, state directly that the result was not delivered to you — then the entire advance remains unworked.

How should the demand be sent so that proof of delivery remains?

Send the demand by a method that leaves a trace: by mail with acknowledgment of receipt or via a channel that preserves proof of delivery. Keep a copy with the delivery mark together with the contract and payment receipt — it will be needed if the dispute goes to court. In our practice, documents and correspondence are studied first, and only then are the prospects of the claims assessed.

WhatsApp Call
Message us on WhatsApp