Court and procedure
Court costs: how to recover money for a lawyer in Kazakhstan
Court costs are the expenses a party incurs in conducting a case, some of which can be shifted to the losing party through the court. This requires supporting documents and an application for recovery filed in the prescribed manner.
The issue of reimbursement arises when a decision has already been rendered but the money paid for a representative has remained unreimbursed. It is unclear whether the costs of the case include the lawyer's services, document preparation, and travel to hearings, and how to claim these amounts from the other party to the dispute. For an entrepreneur, there is the added question of the differences between arbitration and a court of general jurisdiction, as well as what to do in the event of a settlement agreement.
Below are the composition of costs, the rules for allocation between the parties, and the grounds for refusing recovery. Separately — supporting documents, the form of the application (a motion during the proceedings or a separate document after the decision), and the specifics of the review stages. Court costs consist of the state fee and the expenses associated with the proceedings (Article 102 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK) — therefore, in the application they are itemized by type rather than stated as a single amount.
What court costs include: what makes up the amount to be reimbursed
The amount to be reimbursed consists of the state fee and the costs associated with the proceedings in the case (Article 102 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). The fee is a mandatory payment to the budget when applying to court; its amount depends on the type of dispute and the value of the claim; the law specifies the cases of exemption from it. Costs reflect the party's actual expenses for the consideration of the case and the collection of evidence.
The same composition applies in economic disputes between organizations: Kazakhstan has no separate arbitration procedure code; such cases are considered by specialized inter-district economic courts ( SIEC ) under the same CPC of the RK . Costs include amounts paid to witnesses, experts, specialists, and interpreters, payment for the services of a representative, postal expenses, and other expenses recognized by the court as necessary.
- state fee on a claim or application;
- amounts for summoning a witness and conducting an examination;
- payment for the services of an interpreter and a specialist;
- expenses for a representative who participated in the case;
- postal and other costs recognized as necessary;
- compensation for loss of time, if awarded by the court.
| Type of expense | When it arises | What confirms it |
|---|---|---|
| State fee | When filing a claim, application, or complaint | Payment document, receipt |
| Examination and specialist | If the court ordered a study | Invoice from the expert organization |
| Witness and interpreter | When summoned to court to give testimony | Receipt, payment document |
| Representative's services | Throughout the entire process | Contract, act, payment documents |
| Postal expenses | When sending documents to the parties | Receipts and inventories of mailings |
The list is not exhaustive: the court also reimburses other expenses if it recognizes them as necessary for the consideration of the case. A practical tip — keep payment documents for each item right away, rather than reconstructing them by the end of the process.
How to keep track of expenses in a case: the party's working folder
Tracking expenses begins on the day the party first spends money on the process, not on the day the decision is rendered. Set up a separate folder — paper or electronic — and put there everything related to the case: the contract with the representative, acts, payment documents, receipts for sending correspondence, invoices for the study. The point is simple: by the time you file for reimbursement, you should have a complete set in hand, not scattered papers in different places.
A procedure that helps you not to lose ground:
- Separate the items: the fee, costs, and payment for the representative are accounted for separately, not as one total amount.
- Link each document to the case: on the payment document or in the inventory, note which dispute and which action it relates to.
- Record the sending: keep receipts and inventories of mailings together with copies of the documents sent themselves.
- Verify the amounts: the figures in the payment documents must match the terms of the contract, otherwise the court will investigate the discrepancies.
- Update the folder as the case proceeds: new hearings and documents — new entries, not a deferred reconstruction at the end.
A typical mistake is to remember the supporting papers when the decision has already been rendered: some documents are lost by that time, and restoring them takes time. The second is to mix expenses from different cases or different instances into one amount, which makes the connection of the costs to a specific dispute unclear. The third is to pay for services without a document confirming payment: the mere fact of the representative's work without written confirmation of payment does not ensure reimbursement.
Legal costs for a representative: which lawyer's services the court recognises as necessary
The court recognises as necessary those services of a representative that are related to the consideration of a specific case and are confirmed by documents. These include payment for the work of the person providing legal assistance: preparing the claim and other procedural documents, collecting and presenting evidence, and participating in court hearings. Under the Civil Procedure Code of the RK, the party in whose favour the decision was rendered is reimbursed for the costs it incurred for a representative — but only where the fact and amount of such costs are documented.
The basis is a legal services agreement and a payment document confirming payment. If the work was performed but the documents are drawn up incorrectly, the court may refuse to award the costs or reduce the amount. Recovery is made within reasonable limits, taking into account the complexity of the case and the volume of work. Bonafacto lawyers fix the cost of each stage in the agreement before work begins — such a document is then easier to present to the court.
- reviewing the case materials and forming the legal position;
- drafting the statement of claim, response, motions and other procedural documents;
- collecting evidence and preparing it for presentation to the court;
- participating in court hearings before the court of first instance;
- preparing and filing procedural documents at the stage of appealing the decision;
- reviewing the minutes of court hearings and filing comments on them.
What does the court check first? The link between the paid service and the case under consideration: the position in the agreement must match what the representative actually did in the proceedings. A discrepancy between the list of services and the case materials is grounds for reducing the amount.
Who bears court costs and depending on the outcome of the case
The losing party pays: the court awards the party in whose favor the decision was rendered reimbursement of the costs it incurred at the expense of the losing party. As a general rule, costs are distributed between the parties in proportion to the amount of the claims granted. This applies to the state fee, costs associated with the consideration of the case, and payment for the assistance of a representative.
Who reimburses the costs is determined by the operative part of the decision. If the claim is granted in full, they are borne by the defendant. If the claim is denied, they remain with the plaintiff. In case of partial satisfaction, the court calculates what share of the stated claims was found justified and awards reimbursement in the corresponding part.
Check the operative part immediately after it is announced: how the distribution is recorded in it determines whether you can obtain the money without a separate dispute. The wording "to recover from the defendant in favor of the plaintiff" is precisely the basis for a writ of execution.
Court costs in a settlement agreement: how the parties divide expenses
Expenses are allocated as the parties have agreed and are recorded in the settlement agreement itself. Under the Civil Procedure Code of the RK, the court approves a settlement agreement by a separate ruling — which also sets out who covers which amounts. The law gives priority to the parties' agreement: the parties may specify in the text who bears the expenses and to what extent, including the state fee and payments to the representative. The court reviews this provision upon approval along with the other clauses.
In practice, several arrangements are used — from each party bearing its own costs in full to placing all expenses on one participant:
- each party bears its own expenses independently;
- expenses are divided between the parties in equal shares;
- expenses are fully imposed on one of the parties;
- the state fee is allocated separately from the representative's fees;
- the party that breached the terms of the agreement reimburses the expenses caused by such breach;
- the provision on expenses is included in the text of the agreement before it is signed.
Omitting this clause means leaving the allocation of expenses open and returning to it after approval, when reaching an agreement is more difficult. Check the wording before signing: it must unambiguously state who covers what.
Court costs of the losing party: when the court refuses to award them
The court refuses to award costs in full or in part if the party has not confirmed the expenses with documents, they are not connected to the specific dispute, or the claimed amount is clearly excessive. The court correlates the reasonableness of the amount with the complexity of the case and the volume of work performed by the representative. The court may grant a claim to reimburse expenses that noticeably exceed what is necessary not in full. Practical guideline: prepare confirmations for each item in advance — restoring missing papers after a decision is harder than collecting them during the proceedings.
The basis for refusal is the absence of documentary confirmation. Expenses not related to the given case, as well as those incurred before it was initiated or after the decision entered into force, are not accepted. Each item is verified against contracts, acts and payment documents — the mere fact of payment is not enough.
Bad faith of a party also affects the outcome. If a participant delayed the proceedings, filed unfounded motions or concealed evidence, the court may shift part of the costs onto them regardless of the outcome. A reduction is also possible where the fee is clearly excessive relative to the complexity of the case.
- excessiveness of the claimed amount relative to the complexity of the case and the volume of work performed by the representative
- absence of a connection between the expenses and the dispute under consideration
- bad-faith conduct of a party in the proceedings
- absence of documents confirming payment for services
- expenses incurred outside the framework of the case
- clear discrepancy between the price of the service and the average level for similar disputes
Expenses are reimbursed not by the one who lost, but by the one who failed to prove their reasonableness and connection to the case — the court assesses documents, not the fact of payment. Natalya Lukyanova
What documents confirm court costs and what the court checks in them
Representation costs are confirmed by written evidence that together shows three things: the services were actually provided, they are connected to a specific case, and they were actually paid for. The foundation is a legal assistance agreement specifying the scope of the engagement, the volume of actions, and the payment procedure. Bonafacto lawyers fix the cost of each stage in the agreement before work begins — such a document is convenient to present to the court because the amounts in it match the payments.
The second element is a completed works act or the representative's report on actual performance. It lists specific actions: preparing the claim, gathering evidence, participating in hearings. The signatures of the client and the contractor confirm that the services were accepted without objections; if there is no act, the fact that services were provided is proven by other written materials.
- a legal assistance agreement specifying the subject and scope of the engagement;
- a completed works act or the representative's report on actions performed;
- payment documents: cash receipts, payment orders, bank statements, receipts;
- documents on the representative's authority: power of attorney, order, document on education;
- evidence linking the services to the case at hand: procedural documents, hearing minutes.
| Document | What it confirms | What the court looks at |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement | Basis for providing services | Connection to the case, subject and scope of the engagement |
| Act | Actual performance | List of actions, signatures of the parties, absence of objections |
| Payment document | Incurring of costs | Correspondence of amounts to the agreement terms, reality of payment |
| Power of attorney | Representative's authority | Right to participate in the case and sign documents |
| Procedural documents | Participation in the case | Relevance of the services to the specific dispute |
The court assesses evidence as a whole; the absence of even one link reduces the chances of reimbursement. Check in advance that the details in the act and payment slips match the agreement — the court compares any discrepancies separately.
How to assemble the document folder: procedure
The evidence folder is assembled in the same sequence in which the costs arose — this makes it easier for the court to trace the chain from engagement to payment. First the agreement is filed, then the act with the list of actions, then the payment documents and documents on the representative's authority. The set is closed by procedural documents and hearing minutes: they show that the actions listed in the act relate specifically to this dispute.
- Verification of details: the names of the parties, agreement numbers and dates in the act and payment slips must match each other.
- Correspondence of amounts: the total on the payment documents is compared with the price stated in the agreement.
- Link to the case: in the act, it is better to name documents and hearings exactly as they are named in the case materials.
- Completeness of payment: if payments were made in parts, all payment documents are attached, not just the last one.
- Copies for the court and the parties: the set is prepared with copies so they can be attached to the application and served on the other party.
A common mistake is to bring only the payment order: the fact of payment by itself does not show what was paid for or whether it is connected to the dispute at hand. Another is an act where the services are described with the general phrase "legal services," without breaking them down into actions. A third is a discrepancy in dates: payment earlier than the agreement or an act later than the filing of the application. Check the folder before filing — supplementing it after the court has issued a ruling is more difficult.
How to claim court costs: a motion during the case or a separate application
Reimbursement can be claimed in two ways: by a motion during the proceedings — in which case the issue is decided together with the merits of the dispute — or by a separate application after the decision is rendered — in which case the court issues a separate ruling. The choice depends on the stage at which you are ready to substantiate the expenses: while the proceedings are ongoing or after the decision has entered into force. In our practice, documents are collected in advance — so the claim does not have to be postponed.
While the case has not been considered, the claim is included in the statement of claim or filed as a separate motion before the court retires to the deliberation room, with supporting documents attached. After the decision is rendered, the application is filed with the same court within the period established by the procedural law; missing the deadline results in the application being returned. Bonafacto lawyers advise checking that the attachments are complete before filing — an incomplete package delays consideration.
- Timing of filing: before the court retires to the deliberation room, or by a separate application after the decision.
- Document package: the contract, the act and payment documents confirming payment for the representative's services.
- Justification: the specific services and their connection to the case under consideration — the assessment of reasonableness depends on this.
- Instances: costs are claimed separately for each stage, including participation in appeal and cassation.
- Deadline: the application after the decision is filed within the period established by the procedural law, otherwise it will be returned.
- Verification: the completeness of documents is checked before filing so that the court does not leave the application without movement.
How to calculate the amount to be reimbursed: a step-by-step procedure
The amount to be reimbursed is the documented expenses that the court has recognized as necessary and proportionate to the scope of work on the case. The calculation is not prepared "by eye": each item is tied to a specific payment document and compared with what happened in the proceedings. An arithmetic error or a missing receipt weakens the calculation and may lead to a reduction in the amount recovered.
It is convenient to follow the procedure step by step:
- Gather the payment documents: receipts, payment orders, checks — for each amount you plan to claim.
- Verify the amounts against the contract and the act: the figures in the calculation must match the terms of the agreement and the services actually rendered.
- Break down the services by stage and instance: separately — work in the first instance, separately — appeal and cassation, separately — associated costs.
- Compare with the value of the claim and the scope of work: the court assesses proportionality and reasonable limits, so inflated items weaken the calculation.
- Prepare the calculation for the court: a table or list indicating the type of expense, the amount and the supporting document.
At Bonafacto, the client receives a written estimate before work begins, so reconciling the calculation with the agreement takes less time: it is clear what exactly was paid for. If the case went through several instances, it is more convenient to prepare the calculation for each of them at once — this makes it easier to show the court the connection between the expenses and a specific stage.
Court costs in a counterclaim and upon withdrawal of a claim
In a counterclaim, costs are apportioned in proportion to the claims granted, while upon withdrawal of a claim their allocation depends on the reason for the withdrawal. As a general rule under the Civil Procedure Code of the RK, the parties bear costs in proportion to the claims granted. If the withdrawal is caused by the defendant's voluntary satisfaction of the claim after the claim was filed, the plaintiff's costs are imposed on the defendant. For other reasons, such as loss of interest, they remain with the plaintiff.
A settlement agreement or an agreement on dispute resolution through mediation changes this logic: costs are allocated on the terms of the agreement, and in their absence — on the principle of proportionality. An agreement approved by the court terminates the proceedings, so recovery is possible only within the same case before its completion.
- if the defendant voluntarily satisfies the claim after the claim is filed, the plaintiff's costs are imposed on the defendant
- if the plaintiff withdraws for reasons of their own, the costs remain with the plaintiff
- upon reconciliation, the allocation is determined by the terms of the agreement, and in their absence — by proportionality
- in a counterclaim, the granted part is reimbursed; for the remainder, the costs remain with the claimant
- if both claims are granted, the court may set off the awarded amounts, including court costs
- the claim for reimbursement and supporting documents are submitted before the court retires to the deliberation room
Court costs in appeal and cassation: what changes at the review stages
The costs of the review stages are reimbursed under the same rules as in the first instance: they are awarded by the court that considered the case on the merits, or by the review instance itself. The costs are confirmed by a contract, payment documents and a certificate of work performed. The amount includes the fee, preparation of a response, collection of evidence and sending of procedural documents.
Disagreement with the decision does not create a right to reimbursement: costs follow the outcome of the appeal. If the appeal is refused, they remain with the applicant; if it is partially granted, they are distributed proportionally. Cassation costs are reimbursed based on the outcome of the case consideration, not on the fact of filing a motion.
- Fee: payment for the services of the representative who prepared the appeal or response;
- Documents: amounts for drafting procedural documents of the review stage;
- Evidence: costs of collecting and examining additional evidence;
- Correspondence: postal and other expenses related to sending the appeal and notifying the participants;
- Travel: travel and accommodation of the representative to attend a hearing in another locality;
- State fee: the state fee paid, if the law classifies it as costs in the case.
Practical tip: attach payment documents to each stage separately — this makes it easier to prove that the costs were incurred specifically in connection with the appeal, and not with the consideration of the dispute on the merits.
Court costs in the SMES and in courts of general jurisdiction: differences for businesses and individuals
The difference between the SMES and a court of general jurisdiction lies in the composition of the participants and in how the court assesses the costs of a representative. In a court of general jurisdiction, an individual protects personal rights, and there is no need to prove the commercial purpose of the expenses. In the specialised inter-district economic court, the parties are entrepreneurs, so the connection between the lawyer's fee and the case must be justified separately.
In both courts, reimbursement consists of the state fee and expenses, and the services of a representative are confirmed by a contract, an act and payment documents. The approach to an entrepreneur is stricter: the court looks at the scope of work, the complexity of the case and the proportionality of the amount. Bonafacto lawyers advise collecting supporting documents in parallel with handling the case, rather than after the decision.
The court has the right to reduce the reimbursement if it finds it excessive — and this applies to both categories of participants. Compensation can be claimed in the same proceedings or by a separate application after the decision enters into force; missing the deadline deprives the right to reimbursement.
- State fee: a mandatory payment when filing a claim, its amount depends on the value of the claim.
- Expenses: postal, expert, travel and other costs related to the case.
- Confirmation of representative services: a contract, an act of completed work and payment documents.
- Reasonableness of the amount: the court assesses it taking into account the complexity of the case and the scope of work performed.
- Allocation of costs: between the parties in proportion to the claims granted.
Court costs: common mistakes and how to avoid them
The most expensive mistake is filing for reimbursement too late: under the Civil Procedure Code of the RK, the same court resolves the issue, and as a general rule before the act enters into legal force. If the moment is missed, a separate proceeding will be required — the path to the money gets longer and there is a risk of refusal. Bonafacto lawyers build this step into the case plan in advance rather than remembering it after the ruling is announced.
The second difficulty is proof. Relying on an agreement with a representative without confirming payment and the scope of work leads to a reduction in the amount. Confirm payment with a payment document, record the list of services in an act, and keep the representative's procedural documents.
- Missed timing: the application is filed after the decision is issued, when the issue should already have been resolved in the case.
- No payment document: there is an agreement, but the fact of payment is not confirmed.
- Vague act: services are listed with general wording without reference to the scope of work.
- Lost documents: the representative's procedural papers are not gathered into a single case file.
Check the package before filing: agreement, payment slip, act, representative's documents — a missing element weakens the position.
What to do after a court decision: a short checklist
Once the decision has been announced, the procedure is straightforward: first review the operative part, then prepare supporting documents and apply to the court that heard the case. The operative part shows exactly what has been awarded and how costs have been allocated — it indicates whether there are grounds to claim reimbursement. Next, gather the agreement with the representative, the act on services rendered, and payment documents: without this set, the expenses cannot be confirmed.
- Operative part: verify what it states regarding the allocation of costs.
- Agreement and act: check that the subject matter and scope of services match the work actually performed.
- Payment documents: collect confirmation of payment for each payment.
- Application: file it with the same court that heard the case.
- Instances: claim expenses for each stage separately, without combining them in a single calculation.
- Completeness: before filing, double-check the set of attachments and the calculation of the amount.
Practical tip: prepare copies of the documents in advance and verify the calculation against the attachments — any discrepancy in the list or amount will have to be resolved after filing.