Medicine and patients' rights
Refund for Treatment: How to Recover Payment from a Clinic in Kazakhstan
A refund under the consumer protection law is based on the contract with the clinic and payment documents: first, a demand is formulated and a claim is sent, then, if refused, the matter goes to court. The key is to confirm that the service was paid for and that the obligation was not fulfilled or was fulfilled not in the agreed scope.
Payment made but no result received: the appointment was rescheduled, the treatment plan was changed, the service turned out to be unnecessary or was only partially provided. Sorting out such a situation begins with two things — which legal norm to base the claim on and how to prove the very fact of payment.
People come forward already after the clinic's verbal refusal or when it has stopped responding. Below is the sequence of steps: from analysing the contract and payment documents to a pre-action claim, a lawsuit and enforcement proceedings. Separately — the specifics where the payer is an entrepreneur, and the typical mistakes that delay recovery.
When a clinic must refund payment
The clinic refunds payment if the service was not provided or was provided not in the scope agreed with the patient or the customer. The basis is the Code of the RK "On Public Health and the Healthcare System" and the provisions on compensated provision of services in the Civil Code of the RK. The same code obliges healthcare entities to ensure timely and quality medical care (Art. 115 of the Code of the RK "On Public Health and the Healthcare System").
The grounds differ. The first is that the service was not started: the money was transferred, but the appointment or procedure did not take place. The second is that the care was performed partially, and the payment exceeds the scope actually not provided. The third is that the result does not correspond to the agreement recorded in the contract. A separate case is the patient's voluntary refusal of the service before its actual provision: the customer has the right to withdraw from the contract provided that the contractor is paid the expenses actually incurred by it (Art. 686 of the Civil Code of the RK).
The key question in a dispute is what exactly confirms the payment and the agreed scope of services. The earlier the customer records the refusal in writing, the easier it is to separate the unprovided service from the one already performed.
Contract with the clinic as the basis for a claim
Paid medical services are provided under a contract for the provision of services for consideration, governed by the Civil Code of the RK and the Law of the RK "On Protection of Consumer Rights". The contract records which procedures and in what scope the clinic undertook to perform, and the patient undertook to pay for them. Without a written contract and confirmation of payment, it is more difficult to demand a refund, so keep the signed copy, invoices and receipts.
In consumer rights protection, a refund is tied to what is written in the contract itself: the subject matter and scope of services, the payment procedure, the deadlines, and the section on amendment and termination. If the document sets out the refund conditions for refusing procedures, the clinic is guided by them, not by internal rules. Bonafacto lawyers advise reading this very section before signing — it determines what amount you can count on if you refuse treatment.
What to check in the contract before paying:
- Subject matter: the specific medical services and procedures that the clinic undertakes to provide.
- Scope and deadlines: the list of procedures, their number and the period for performing them.
- Payment procedure: advance payment, instalments, payment stages and documents confirming payment.
- Amendment of terms: how additional procedures and adjustments to the scope are agreed.
- Termination and refund: the grounds for refusing services and the procedure for calculating the unused amount.
- Liability of the parties: the consequences of violating the deadlines and quality of medical services.
Separately, check whether the amount in the contract matches the one you actually paid: any discrepancy will have to be explained with receipts and invoices. At Bonafacto, when analysing such disputes, the first step is to compare the contract with the payment documents — this shows what part of the payment the clinic received and what it has not yet accounted for.
Payment confirmed — what happens next
Payment for treatment is confirmed by primary documents, and these are exactly what determine whether the patient can get their money back. The fact that money was paid is proven by specific paperwork: written evidence issued by the clinic or the bank. The consumer's right to a refund rests not on verbal assurances but on this set of documents — without it, the claim hangs in the air.
The main document is the cash receipt for payment of medical services: it records the amount, date, and recipient of the payment. If payment was made through a bank, it is confirmed by a payment order and an account statement. When paying in cash at the cash desk, a receipt for a cash receipt voucher or another strict reporting form is issued.
It is worth collecting everything that confirms the payment:
- cash receipt issued upon payment at the clinic's cash desk
- receipt for a cash receipt voucher for cash payment
- payment order for non-cash transfer
- bank account statement of the payer
- clinic certificate confirming payment for medical services
- payer's documents, if a relative paid for the treatment
Receipts get lost, and that is not a dead end: a bank statement can be reordered, and the clinic keeps records of payments received. Request a certificate of payment from it: the consumer has the right to receive a document confirming the provision of the service (Art. 18 of the Law of the RK "On Protection of Consumer Rights").
Types of claims and their differences
Paid medical services fall under the RK Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights," so the patient has the right to choose between several claims against the clinic, rather than only raising the issue of a refund: consumer protection here works as a framework, not as the only scenario. Each claim has its own legal nature and consequences; they cannot be arbitrarily mixed in a single lawsuit. Below is how the main types of claims differ and what will have to be proven for each.
A refund of an unearned advance payment is appropriate when treatment has not started, was interrupted at the clinic's initiative, or the agreed scope was not fulfilled. A reduction in the cost of treatment applies when the service was provided but its quality or scope does not correspond to the contract: the price is reduced in proportion to the defects. Reimbursement of expenses for remedying defects is compensation for costs incurred by the patient to correct the consequences of a poor-quality service with another specialist. Compensation for harm to health is a separate claim related to bodily injuries and other consequences for the body; it is not limited to a refund of amounts paid. Bonafacto lawyers advise first determining the subject of proof, and only then formulating the prayer for relief.
The table below helps match a claim to a situation and to what the client proves. It should be read line by line: first find your case in the second column, then see which circumstances will have to be confirmed.
| Claim | When applicable | What the client proves |
|---|---|---|
| Refund of unearned advance payment | The service was not provided or was interrupted | The fact of payment and non-provision of the service |
| Reduction in the cost of treatment | The service was provided with defects | Non-compliance of scope or quality with the terms |
| Reimbursement of treatment expenses | Defects were remedied by third parties | The amount of actual costs and their necessity |
| Compensation for harm to health | Harm was caused to the body | Causation and consequences |
Claims may be combined if the relevant grounds are confirmed; withdrawal from the contract terminates the obligations with a refund of the unearned portion of the payment.
How to choose a claim for your situation
Choosing a claim begins with the question of what exactly you want to obtain: money back, a price reduction, correction of the result, or compensation for health consequences. The answer determines both the set of documents and who bears the burden of proof.
- The service has not started: demand a refund of the unearned advance payment, attaching the contract and payment documents.
- The service was performed partially: compare the paid scope with the entries in the medical record and the procedure reports.
- The result does not correspond to what was agreed: assert a reduction in the cost of treatment, relying on the contract terms on quality and scope.
- The defects had to be remedied elsewhere: keep documents on the costs and the justification for their necessity.
- There are consequences for the body: harm to health is claimed separately, together with confirmation of causation.
Practical step: formulate the claim in one sentence and check which documents confirm it. If the paperwork is insufficient, collect it first — a pre-action claim and a lawsuit are built on written evidence, not on a retelling of a conversation with the administrator.
Pre-trial claim to a clinic
A claim to a clinic is the first step in pre-trial recovery of money paid for treatment. The document is addressed to the head of the medical organization — the clinic, center, office, or LLP where the service was provided. If the assistance was provided by a doctor as a sole proprietor, the claim is filed with that doctor personally.
The claim is drawn up in writing: details of the patient and the representative, information about the service provider, a description of the circumstances and services, an indication of deficiencies or refusal of the service. Then — a demand for full or partial refund with the method of transfer, a reference to the provisions of the Code and the contract, if one was concluded. It is better to formalize the claim in writing — verbal requests to the clinic administrator record neither the date nor the substance of the demand.
The following documents, on which the demand is based, are attached to the claim:
- a copy of the contract for the provision of medical services
- payment documents confirming payment for treatment
- medical documents confirming the scope and nature of the assistance
- a power of attorney, if a representative of the patient is acting
- correspondence with the clinic and other evidence of the request
- calculation of the amount to be refunded
The claim is filed in such a way that the patient retains confirmation of delivery: a mark on the second copy, a delivery notification. Bonafacto lawyers prepare the text and the calculation so that each point of the demand relies on an attached document — unnecessary attachments unrelated to the amount only blur the position.
Payment alone does not yet prove that the service was provided. Until the clinic provides confirmation of the scope and quality, the demand for a refund remains justified. Anna Kulzhemiyeva
Clinic's Response and Refusal
A clinic's refusal is a written response to a claim in which it explains why it is not refunding the payment. Paid medical services are covered by the RK Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights": the clinic is responsible for the quality and scope of care. If the treatment produced no result or was interrupted, the refund depends on what was performed under the contract and whether actual expenses were incurred.
The clinic refuses by citing services actually rendered: consultation, diagnostics, procedures. Such an argument is valid only where the result is confirmed by medical documentation, not by a price list or the words of an administrator.
Another ground is that the patient interrupted treatment on their own initiative. Here it is important to separate the completed scope from payment for stages not carried out: refusal to refund for services not rendered is unfounded, even if the contract is terminated at the patient's request. If negotiations have reached a dead end, recovery of the money through court becomes the next step — but before that, the response should be analyzed point by point.
What to look at in the clinic's response:
- the refusal repeats general wording without reference to specific services rendered
- the clinic's response to the claim contains no calculation of the withheld amount
- services not rendered are included in the total cost of the course
- expenses are not confirmed by documents or relate to other patients
- the clinic relies on a no-refund condition for services not provided, although such a condition infringes consumer rights (Art. 8-1 of the RK Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights")
- there is no reference to the RK Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights"
Practical tip: keep the envelope and the date you received the response — this affects how you should structure further correspondence and preparation of the lawsuit.
Where to file a claim and how to calculate deadlines
A dispute over a refund of payment for treatment is heard by a district (city) court under the rules of civil procedure. A claim against the clinic as a legal entity is filed at its location (Article 29 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK), and a claim arising from the activities of a branch may also be filed at the location of the branch (Article 30 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). A claim for consumer protection may also be filed at one's own place of residence or at the place of conclusion or performance of the contract (Article 30 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK). Practical advice: choose the venue in advance — it determines which court you take the documents to and where to send copies.
Pre-trial settlement of a consumer dispute is conducted on the proposal of the consumer and with the consent of the service provider (Article 42-8 of the Law of the RK "On Consumer Protection"), but a written claim records your position and the date you approached the clinic. A claim is drawn up in writing under the rules of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK, with the contract, payment and medical documents attached. If the dispute reaches court, the correspondence and confirmed payments will form the basis of the evidence.
The sequence of steps is as follows:
- Identify the defendant: the clinic, its branch, or a specific medical professional.
- Choose the court: at the location of the clinic or at your own place of residence — for consumer protection disputes, Article 30 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RK permits this.
- Attach the contract, receipts and medical documents to the claim.
- Observe the limitation period and record the date when you learned of the violation of your right.
- After the decision enters into force, obtain the writ of execution and hand it to the bailiff.
Evidence in a civil case
A dispute over a refund for treatment rests on documentary and physical evidence. Paid medical services are covered by the RK Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights." It is important for the patient to confirm that the service was agreed upon, paid for, and exactly how it was performed.
The basis of proof consists of the contract for paid medical services, payment documents, and medical records. Correspondence with the clinic, including electronic messages, confirms the agreement of terms and the patient's claims. If the service was not provided, the entries in the medical record, the procedures actually performed, and the paid scope are compared — the discrepancy becomes the core of the position.
What is collected for the case:
- contract for the provision of paid medical services
- payment documents: receipts, vouchers, statements
- medical records: chart, prescriptions, protocols
- correspondence with the clinic, including electronic messages
- independent expert opinion
- witness testimony
Practical tip: request copies of medical records in writing and keep the original correspondence files with dates.
Enforcement proceedings in Kazakhstan
After the court grants the claim for a refund of money for treatment, the creditor is issued a writ of execution. This document confirms the right to enforce recovery from the clinic and is presented at the location of the clinic or its property. The writ is valid for a limited period, so delaying its receipt and submission is disadvantageous primarily to the creditor themselves.
A paper writ of execution is submitted to the justice authority if it is enforced by a state judicial executor, or to the regional chamber of private judicial executors by territoriality; an electronic enforcement document is sent by the court itself through the digital enforcement proceedings system (Law of the RK "On Enforcement Proceedings and the Status of Judicial Executors", Art. 9-1). The application must be accompanied by payment details for the transfer of amounts. Further work proceeds step by step:
- obtaining the writ of execution from the court
- submitting the writ to the justice authority or the regional chamber of private judicial executors by territoriality
- filing an application to initiate enforcement proceedings
- requesting information on the clinic's accounts and property
- imposing seizure and foreclosing on monetary funds
- monitoring the completeness and timing of enforcement
A practical point: the payment details in the application should be double-checked before submission — an error in the account lengthens the path of the money, even though the decision has already been made.
Specifics for Entrepreneurs
When treatment is paid for by an LLP or a sole proprietor , a refund is not based solely on the RK Law "On Consumer Protection." The parties to the contract are the clinic and the organization, while the employee or director is the beneficiary, so the demand for a refund of the payment by invoice is made by the payer, not the patient.
A contract with a clinic concluded by a legal entity is documented with an invoice for payment and an act of services rendered. If the service was not provided, was provided poorly, or was paid for twice, the company sends a claim based on the contract, invoice, and payment order for the bank transfer. The money is returned to the payer's account, and the parties sign a termination agreement or an adjustment act — without this, the accounting and tax records will not reconcile. Corporate expenses for treatment are confirmed by the contract, invoice, act, and payment documents.
The sequence of steps for a company is as follows:
- Check who is listed as the payer in the contract and invoice: the LLP, the sole proprietor, or the employee.
- Keep the originals of the contract, invoice, act, and payment order.
- Record exactly which service was not provided or was provided with defects.
- Send the clinic a written claim demanding a refund of the amount.
- Upon refund, execute a settlement agreement and adjustment documents.
- Record the refunded amounts in the accounting and tax records.
Bonafacto lawyers advise verifying the act against the services actually rendered before signing it: a signed act without comments makes it harder to substantiate a claim.
Five mistakes that hinder recovery
Refunds for treatment fail because of documents and deadlines, not because of the clinic's position. The absence of a written contract does not deprive the patient of protection, but it shifts the dispute into the realm of evidence: the very fact of the services and their terms must be proven.
Payment without a receipt, slip, or card statement turns the claim into a question of whether money was transferred. Failure to issue a copy of the contract, the absence of written demands and the clinic's responses leave the position without evidence. If the defendant, before the decision, raises the expiration of the limitation period, the court will dismiss the claim (Article 179, paragraphs 2, 3 of the Civil Code of the RK), and a claim without a pre-trial demand closes the path to settlement without litigation.
- No written contract: the scope and terms of services are proven by indirect evidence.
- Payment without documents: there is no way to confirm the amount paid.
- Claims not recorded: there is no evidence of contacting the clinic before court.
- Deadline missed: upon the defendant's motion, the court dismisses the claim.
- Claim without a demand: the opportunity for settlement without proceedings is lost.
| Mistake | Consequence | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| No written contract | The terms of services and their scope are not confirmed | Collect any written and electronic evidence |
| Payment without documents | It is difficult to prove the fact and amount of payment | Request copies of receipts, a card statement |
| Claims not recorded | There is no evidence of a pre-trial demand | Send demands in writing and keep copies |
| Deadline missed | The court dismisses the claim | Check the running of the period before filing a claim |
| Claim without a demand | The opportunity for settlement is lost | First send a written demand to the clinic |
The table does not replace an assessment of a specific situation: what matters is which documents have been preserved and when the patient learned of the violation of the right.
How not to lose evidence before going to court
Evidence in a dispute with a clinic is collected immediately, not by the time of the claim: some documents are issued only upon request. The contract, receipts, slips, and statements are kept in one folder — paper or electronic, with clear file names. The medical record and prescriptions are requested in writing: a copy is issued upon application, and the date of the request is recorded on it.
- Copy of the contract: if a copy was not issued, request it in writing and keep confirmation of the request.
- Payment documents: receipts, slips, and account statements — in the original or a legible copy.
- Medical documentation: record, prescriptions, procedure reports — upon written application.
- Correspondence: messages in messengers and email are exported in full, with dates and sender.
- Calculation of the amount: a separate sheet with a breakdown of what was paid and what was actually provided.
It is better not to clean up or delete electronic correspondence and dialogs: keep the export with dates. Oral promises by the administrator are difficult to confirm — so ask for any agreement on the scope of services to be duplicated in writing.
Step-by-step procedure for obtaining a refund
A refund for medical treatment follows a single route: from collecting documents to handing the writ of execution to the bailiff. Each step builds on the previous one, and skipping any of them weakens your position in a dispute with the clinic. Below is the sequence it is convenient to follow.
- Collect the documents: the contract with the clinic, receipts and payment confirmations, medical documents — conclusions, prescriptions, extracts from the medical record.
- Record which service was not provided: compare the agreed scope with what was actually performed and describe the discrepancy in writing.
- Send a written pre-action claim: state the demand and its basis, attach copies of the documents, and keep proof of sending.
- If refused — file a claim with the district (city) court: attach the pre-action claim and the clinic's response to the statement of claim.
- Obtain the writ of execution: after the decision enters into force, hand the document to the bailiff.
The weak link in this chain is documenting the service not provided: without a written description of the discrepancy with the contract, the pre-action claim turns into a general complaint that is easy to answer with a refusal. It is better to prepare the pre-action claim once you already have the complete set of documents in hand — that way the demand sounds specific.
At Bonafacto, a specialist is assigned to the case from the first contact and handles it to the end — from reviewing the contract and the pre-action claim to supporting enforcement. This is convenient when the clinic responds with a refusal and the dispute moves into the courtroom: you do not have to hand the materials over to a new lawyer again.
Bottom Line
A refund for treatment rests on three pillars: the contract with the clinic, payment documents, and medical documents. The contract defines the scope and price of the service, receipts and payment slips confirm that the amount was transferred, and the medical documentation shows what was actually provided. If even one link is missing, the claim loses strength — which is why documents are collected before correspondence with the clinic begins, not after a refusal.
A pre-trial demand letter sets out the patient's position: what claim is being made, what it is based on, and what amount the clinic must refund. The clinic's response shows whether it is prepared to resolve the matter voluntarily. If it refuses, the dispute moves to court, and after a judgment — to enforcement proceedings, where recovery is already compulsory.
The outcome of a court case is not guaranteed: it depends on the evidence and the circumstances of the case. You pay for the specialist's work, not for a promised win — this should be taken into account when planning expenses.