Business
In-house lawyer or outsourced: an honest calculation for business
Outsourced legal services is a format where a business's legal tasks are handled by an external specialist rather than an in-house employee. Choosing between this and hiring in-house comes down to more than just salary: you need to consider workload, taxes, workspace, and what tasks the company actually has.
Business grows, and sooner or later the question arises: hire an in-house lawyer or outsource legal matters to an external specialist. The owner or manager starts calculating: salary, taxes, workplace, equipment. But the costs do not end there, and the new employee may not cover part of the work at all.
The situation is complicated by the fact that the wrong format slows down deals, hinders debt collection and costs more than it seems at the time of hiring. Below — which tasks an in-house lawyer takes on first, when it is more advantageous to outsource legal matters, how to calculate the workload and which hiring mistakes cost the most.
In-house employee or external lawyer: how to choose the right format for your business
The format is chosen based on the volume and predictability of legal work: if tasks arise regularly and fully occupy one person, you need an in-house lawyer, while for one-off or uneven requests an external specialist is more cost-effective. This is not a question of prestige but a calculation of workload and costs. Before opening a vacancy, break down your tasks into categories.
An in-house lawyer is an office employee who is occupied only with the company's affairs: contracts, HR, correspondence with government agencies, court cases. An external specialist is engaged for a specific task or provides ongoing support on a retainer basis. A visiting lawyer is convenient when the flow of work is uniform and can be planned. Bonafacto structures its work the same way: first, documents are reviewed and prospects assessed, and the cost of each stage is fixed in the contract before work begins.
- Frequency of tasks: whether legal work arises daily or once a month
- Presence: whether a person needs to be in the office at all times or remote communication is sufficient
- Document flow: whether there are regular contracts, HR documents, court cases
- Organization: whether you are ready to set up a workplace and supervise the workload
- Specifics: how complex the industry is and whether specialized experience is needed
Go through the points honestly: if there are few positive answers, a full-time position will sit idle, and the salary and workplace will become permanent expenses. The opposite situation is when legal work is continuous and requires a person inside the company. Bonafacto lawyers help assess the urgency of the matter in the first conversation and determine whether a one-time consultation is enough or the case needs ongoing handling.
In-house lawyer: which tasks they handle first
First of all, such a specialist takes over the day-to-day work that would otherwise fall on the manager: reviewing and drafting contracts, pre-litigation correspondence, HR orders and internal regulations. They work with internal documents every day and see what is happening in the company — therefore they spot a risk before it becomes a problem: a disputed wording in a contract, a missed deadline on a license, a conflict with an employee. In-house legal support is built on access to source documents: the lawyer reads documents before they are signed.
When external disputes arise, their tasks include preparing the position and documents for court, representing the company's interests in the courts of Kazakhstan, and interacting with a private or state judicial executor. If a matter requires narrow specialization — tax or criminal defense — they prepare materials and coordinate the work of the relevant specialist. The tasks of such an employee are broader than they seem: they remove from the business the risk of missing a deadline, signing an unfavorable document or losing evidence.
- Contracts and claims: review, drafting, deadline tracking.
- HR documents: orders, regulations, local acts.
- Internal documents: provisions, instructions, policies.
- Court disputes: position, evidence, representation.
- Coordination: working with relevant specialists on narrow issues.
The practical consequence for the business: it makes sense to load such an employee with tasks where familiarity with internal processes matters, and to give narrow topics to relevant specialists — otherwise time is spent learning the industry from scratch. And one more thing: if the company does not have a habit of recording which documents were reviewed and when, even a strong in-house lawyer works blind.
When It Pays to Bring in an Outside Lawyer
Outsourcing legal tasks to an external lawyer pays off when the workload is uneven. If in some months you need to support a transaction or review a contract, and in others it is quiet, a full-time position sits idle while salary and taxes for it keep accruing. Legal outsourcing in such a situation lets you bring in narrow specialists for a specific task: today you need a tax consultant, tomorrow a lawyer for a dispute with a contractor.
Another sign is one-off or seasonal tasks: registering changes, handling a specific dispute, preparing documents for an inspection. Keeping a person on staff just for such episodes is irrational: the workplace, taxes and the benefits package are paid all year, not only in the months of load.
Outsourcing also covers peak loads, when internal resources are insufficient and hiring a second lawyer for a few months makes no sense. When choosing an external provider, check their status: under Article 58 of the CPC of the RK , only an advocate or a member of the chamber of legal consultants is entitled to represent a company in court, while an in-house lawyer appears in court as an employee of the legal entity. For a business, this means that not every external consultant can take a dispute to court — the status is checked before signing the contract, not on the day of the hearing.
The signs that you should look toward an outsourced lawyer add up to a short list:
- Tasks are grouped into short periods, with no idle time between them.
- One-off projects: reorganization, a major contract, a court dispute.
- No need for constant access to routine matters and templates.
- Involvement of a narrow specialist on a specific issue.
You can vet a provider with a simple set of questions: do they hold the status of an advocate or a member of the chamber of legal consultants, who exactly will handle the case, and is the cost of each stage fixed in the contract. At Bonafacto, the cost of a stage is fixed in the contract before work begins — this clause is convenient to use as a model when comparing any offer on the market. If the answers are vague and the price changes as work progresses, the risk of overpaying is higher than it seems at the start.
What to Fix in the Contract with an External Lawyer Before the Start
A contract with an external provider covers not only the price but also the boundaries of the work — otherwise a dispute over what was part of the task and what was not surfaces after the result has been delivered. Describe the subject matter: which documents or actions you receive as output, in what form, and to whom they are addressed. As a separate clause, go through the approval procedure: who on the company side provides the inputs and approves the final result, so that the provider does not gather requirements from different departments.
Next comes what is easy to overlook on a first engagement:
- Scope and stages: breaking the work into blocks with a result for each, rather than a general wording of "legal support."
- Materials from the company: the list of documents and accesses you hand over, and in what form — originals, scans, exports.
- Confidentiality: a non-disclosure condition covering information about transactions, counterparties and employees.
- Reporting: in what form the provider shows what has been done, and how interim results are recorded.
- Acceptance: how and by whom it is confirmed that a block is closed — without this, a dispute over quality comes down to words.
- Additional expenses: fees, expert examinations, translations and notarial actions are paid separately and directly to the providers — this is worth discussing in advance so that the invoice does not come as a surprise.
A typical mistake is handing an external lawyer a folder of documents without an inventory and priorities: some papers turn out to be the wrong version, and urgent matters drown among the secondary ones. Keep a simple register: what was handed over, when, in which version, and what you expect in response. Such a list saves time for both sides and, when the provider changes, becomes a ready-made entry point.
Comparison: In-House Lawyer vs. Outsourced Lawyer by Workload
Workload is distributed differently: for an in-house specialist it is tied to the internal flow of tasks, while for an external one it is tied to the agreed scope of work. The former's day is split between contracts, employee consultations, and court cases; the latter's each block is set up as a separate task with its own deadline. This is where the difference in queue behavior comes from: for an in-house lawyer it grows during peak periods, while for an external one it is recalculated to match the scope.
The difference shows up on typical tasks. An external specialist takes on a specific block — a contract, a claim, a lawsuit — and drives it to a result, whereas an in-house lawyer handles several areas in parallel and sets priorities independently. A qualified external lawyer steps in when internal resources are insufficient and does not occupy a workplace during quiet months. Below is what the load looks like across common tasks.
- Contracts and claims — a constant flow for an in-house lawyer
- Court cases — peak workload requiring concentration
- Employee consultations — daily small tasks
| Task | In-house lawyer | Outsourced lawyer |
|---|---|---|
| Contract review | In the order of the internal queue | Within the agreed deadline |
| Court dispute | Switches from current tasks | Engages for the specific case |
| Employee consultation | Constant flow, fragments the day | According to an agreed schedule |
| Claims work | Combines with document flow | Handles as a separate block |
| Peak loads | Accumulates tasks in the queue | Load is distributed to match the scope |
How to read the table: compare your tasks against the "Peak loads" row — if the queue stretches during such periods, it makes sense to hand part of the block to an external specialist rather than expand the staff.
The practical conclusion is simple: count not the number of employees, but the volume of tasks that arrive unevenly. A staff position is justified where the flow is stable and requires a constant presence within the company; for peaks and one-off projects, it is cheaper to engage a specialist for the task.
In-house lawyer or outsourced: what the costs consist of
The total cost of an in-house lawyer is not just the salary, but all expenses for the workplace and administration. In addition to the salary, this includes mandatory contributions from the payroll fund, an equipped workplace and technical support: a computer, access to legal databases, communications, office supplies. Add training, professional development and time for administration — vacations, sick leave, downtime. Budgeting by a single line item "salary" means underestimating it: formats should be compared correctly across the full set of line items.
The cost of an outsourced lawyer is formed differently: payment for an agreed scope of work or hours, engaging specialized experts for a specific task, no expenses for organizing a workplace. The price of an in-house lawyer is predictable per month, but not flexible: you will have to pay even when there is little work. How much an outsourced lawyer costs depends on the complexity of tasks and the regularity of requests. A subscription lawyer in this sense is closer to a retainer: the scope of requests is discussed in advance, and expenses are tied to the actual workload, not to the employee's presence in the office.
- Salary and mandatory payments: salary and contributions from the payroll fund
- Workplace and equipment: computer, communications, access to legal databases
- Training: professional development and time for administration
- Payment by scope or hours: for an external lawyer — based on actual work
| Cost item | In-house lawyer | Outsourcing |
|---|---|---|
| Labor costs | constantly | based on actual work |
| Taxes and contributions | from the payroll fund | included in the payment |
| Workplace and equipment | at the company's expense | at the contractor's expense |
| Training and access to databases | regularly | as needed |
| Downtime | paid | not paid |
Composition of expenses without specific amounts.
The table should be read line by line: on the left is the item, on the right is how it behaves in each format. The permanent lines (labor costs, taxes, workplace) for an in-house specialist do not disappear when tasks decline, while for an external one they arise only together with the work. At Bonafacto, documents are studied first and only then are prospects assessed, so the estimate can be compared with the internal budget even before the start. Practical conclusion: compile a full list of items, mark which of them are permanent, and compare the formats by this amount, not by a single salary.
How to consolidate the calculation into one table and avoid mistakes in assumptions
A comparison of formats works when both columns are calculated over the same horizon and the same list of items. Take the same set of lines as in the table above and fill it in with your own data: permanent expenses for an employee — for the period, payment for an external specialist — based on completed tasks. This shows at what workload one format is inferior to the other, and where the difference blurs.
A typical mistake is comparing a salary with a one-time invoice for a single task: in the first case you pay for the calendar, in the second — for the result. The second mistake is forgetting about administration: interviews, onboarding, monitoring attendance and replacement during an employee's absence. The third is not factoring into the calculation narrow issues for which an in-house specialist will still need a specialized colleague, and an external contractor will need to engage such a specialist for the task.
- Horizon: calculate both formats over the same period
- Full list: permanent and variable items — in one table
- Administration: account for time on hiring, onboarding and monitoring as a separate line
- Narrow issues: mark in advance the tasks that require a specialized expert
The check is simple: if after filling in the table you cannot say which line tipped the decision, the calculation is incomplete. Go back to the list of tasks and make sure each of them falls into one column or the other.
What mistakes are made when hiring an in-house lawyer
The main mistake when hiring an in-house lawyer is failing to fix the job function and the list of tasks in the employment contract, although the job function is a mandatory term of the contract under Article 28 of the Labor Code of the RK. The consequence for the business is practical: without a written list of tasks, the area of responsibility blurs, and part of the work remains undone, while formally no one can be held accountable for it. The second mistake is hiring a specialist without experience specifically in your industry: the person understands labor disputes but not supply contracts, and industry-specific documents end up on the desk unchecked. The third misstep is hiring for everything at once, expecting one person to cover taxes, court cases, and corporate matters.
Mistakes also happen when handing over matters for support. If you do not audit current contracts and set priorities, the new employee spends time on secondary matters while urgent ones wait. It is also dangerous to leave limitation periods and pre-litigation claim work unattended: these areas cannot tolerate a delayed start. A sole practitioner in such a situation gets involved on a targeted basis — for the audit and prioritization — while the in-house position gets up to speed. To avoid repeating others' missteps, determine in advance:
- Priorities: which tasks the lawyer handles first and which — on a residual basis.
- Responsibility: who is accountable for the result — the lawyer, the manager, or the relevant department.
- Reporting: how often and in what form the lawyer reports on the work done.
- Storage: where the originals of contracts and court documents are kept.
These four points should be fixed before the first working day, not after the first failure: written fixation of tasks and priorities removes most disputes about the area of responsibility. And check that the list of tasks in the contract matches what you discussed at the interview — a discrepancy here costs the most.
What to check in the first month of a new lawyer's work
The first month is not a loyalty test but a check of how the person reads your documents. Ask them to go through the current contracts and flag disputable wording: this way you will see whether they notice risk before signing, not after a dispute. Separately, discuss how they track deadlines — for contracts, claims, and HR documents: if deadlines are kept in their head rather than in a register, some of them will fall through at the first busy period.
Also check how task handover is organized. Who sets the task, in what form, and what counts as the result — a draft document, an opinion, or a "approved" mark. Without this, the lawyer is either overloaded with minor requests or idle waiting for clarifications. It is useful to agree on a single entry point right away: all legal requests go through one person, otherwise employees bypass the lawyer and bring already signed documents.
- Deadline register: a single list of contracts, claims, and HR documents with dates showing what is urgent.
- Entry point: one channel through which employees submit legal tasks.
- Result format: what exactly the lawyer delivers — a draft, an opinion, or approval.
- Case folder: where working versions and originals are stored so a document is not searched for in correspondence.
A typical mistake of the first month is evaluating a newcomer by high-profile cases rather than by how many disputable wordings they caught in the routine. It is this inconspicuous work that pays for the position.
How to determine whether an in-house lawyer is needed right now
The answer is simple: an in-house lawyer is needed if legal work is continuous and cannot be postponed. Assess the workload by three criteria — the frequency of legal tasks, their volume, and the share of court disputes. When contracts, claims, and HR documents come in a steady stream, and disputes have become a regular part of the work, a permanent specialist inside the company is justified.
If tasks appear in waves — once a month or less often — and disputes are isolated, there is no reason to rush into hiring. In that case, it is more reasonable to cover the volume on a targeted basis: a consultant lawyer is engaged for a specific task rather than sitting on a salary waiting for assignments.
Use the criteria for choosing an in-house lawyer for your assessment:
- Frequency: legal questions arise daily or with pauses;
- Volume: how many contracts, claims, and HR documents pass through you per month;
- Disputes: isolated episodes or a permanent line of work;
- Who covers it now: an accountant, the manager, or no one.
Check whether anyone inside is handling the identification and analysis of legal risks: contract work, claims, HR documents, correspondence with government agencies. If an accountant or the manager covers these tasks on a leftover basis and they pile up, it is time to calculate the workload seriously.
Separately, look at how much time is spent supervising assignments and dealing with the consequences. When legal work takes more than one day a week from you, the answer to the question of whether an in-house lawyer is needed right now is usually obvious. During seasonal spikes, this volume is covered by outsourcing.
Calculating an in-house lawyer by salary alone is a mistake: part of the costs is invisible, and without a full-time workload you are paying for idle time. Decide based on the volume of routine work that cannot be postponed and must be handled continuously. Dulat Abenov
How to hand over cases to an external lawyer: step-by-step procedure
Handing over cases to an external lawyer begins with an inventory: you need to collect all active contracts, claims, court documents and correspondence with counterparties, as well as list current disputes and their stage. At this same stage, priorities are fixed — what requires a decision first and what can wait. Without such a list, a new specialist spends time reconstructing the picture instead of working on the tasks.
Next, the originals of documents and access credentials are handed over: email, profiles in document management systems, personal accounts on government agency portals, if they are used in the work. In parallel, the reporting format is agreed — how often and in what form you will receive information on the progress of cases. A practical tip: set up a single case register with dates and responsible persons, otherwise some deadlines are held only in the former employee's memory.
If it is about ongoing legal support, it is worth discussing in advance who is responsible for monitoring deadlines — an internal employee or the service provider themselves. At Bonafacto, before work begins, the client receives a written estimate, so the scope of the handover and the payment procedure are visible in advance. The work is structured in stages: review of documents, then position and strategy, pre-trial settlement.
A deadline control checkpoint is a mandatory element of the handover. Set a date when the new lawyer will reconcile the case register with the actual status, and record who is responsible for a missed deadline up to that moment. Such a reconciliation checkpoint helps avoid losing procedural dates during the transition period.
Which format of working with a lawyer should a business choose
The choice between an in-house specialist and an outside lawyer comes down to two parameters: the volume of legal work and its predictability. When the flow of contracts, claims, and consultations is steady and daily, a permanent presence on the team simplifies coordination. When tasks arise in waves — a transaction, a dispute, an inspection — it is more reasonable to engage a specialist for a specific block of work.
What should be counted is not the salary but the total cost: remuneration, taxes and mandatory payments, workplace, equipment, access to legal databases, training, and the manager's time spent setting tasks. The second layer is the scope of responsibility: what the contractor is responsible for, how the result is formalized, and to whom quality-related questions are addressed.
- Volume: whether the legal work runs as a steady flow or as separate projects
- Predictability: whether tasks repeat by type or are new every time
- Cost: whether associated expenses for the workplace and support are taken into account
- Responsibility: whether it is assigned to a specific contractor in the contract
- Control: whether the company has a person capable of setting tasks and accepting the result
A practical guideline: if, based on this list, at least two points cause difficulty, the format should be reconsidered before signing an employment contract — restructuring the relationship later is harder than choosing the right model from the start.