Employment
Disciplinary sanction: procedure for the employer to apply
A disciplinary sanction is a measure of employee liability for a breach of employment duties, and the employer may apply it only in compliance with the procedure. An error in drafting the explanatory statement, the deadlines or the order results in the penalty being annulled and the dismissal being recognized as unlawful.
An employer faces a situation where an employee breaches their employment duties: arrives late, fails to follow instructions, is absent from the workplace. The question arises of how to properly apply a measure of liability so that it is lawful and withstands scrutiny in a dispute. Quick decisions made without regard to the procedural requirements of the Labour Code of the RK result in the penalty being overturned — and this is not a rare outcome, but a direct consequence of a missed step.
Below — what exactly the employer is entitled to impose, how a disciplinary sanction differs from other means of influence, how to request an explanation and what to do if the employee refuses. Separately — the time limits, the content of the order, evidence, and the mistakes that cause the position in court to fall apart.
What a disciplinary sanction is and when an employer may apply it
This is a measure of liability that an employer applies to an employee for a breach of employment duties. The Labour Code of the RK classifies as such measures a remark, a reprimand, a severe reprimand and termination of the employment contract at the employer's initiative.
The basis is a disciplinary offence: culpable failure to perform or improper performance of employment duties. The offence must be unlawful and specifically related to work: lateness, absence from the workplace, refusal to comply with a lawful instruction, violation of the internal labour regulations.
- a remark;
- a reprimand;
- a severe reprimand;
- termination of the employment contract at the employer's initiative.
The employer may apply such a measure when the violation has been documented and a written explanation has been requested from the employee. The procedure and time limits are mandatory for both parties: without them, the decision is vulnerable in a dispute. Check whether you have evidence of the offence before issuing the order — it is harder to recover it later.
Types of disciplinary sanctions that the employer has the right to impose
The Labor Code of the RK contains an exhaustive list of measures: the employer has the right to apply only the types expressly named in the code and cannot expand the list. These include a remark, a reprimand, a severe reprimand, and termination of the employment contract. Before imposing any of these measures, a written explanation is requested from the employee — this is a mandatory step of the procedure, not a formality.
A remark, a reprimand, and a severe reprimand are applicable to all employees; for certain categories — for example, civil servants — other measures may be established by the laws of the RK. Dismissal is permitted only on the grounds provided for by the code and does not substitute for other measures. For heads of organizations and their deputies, the law allows additional grounds for termination of the employment contract. Practical guideline: the gravity of the misconduct and the circumstances of its commission are taken into account when choosing the measure — from mild to severe.
| Sanction | To whom it applies | Specifics |
|---|---|---|
| Remark | To all employees | For a minor misconduct |
| Reprimand | To all employees | For a violation of employment duties |
| Severe reprimand | To all employees | Taking into account the gravity of the misconduct |
| Termination of the employment contract | To all employees | On the grounds provided for by the code |
The list is exhaustive: a measure outside the code cannot be applied. A written explanation from the employee is requested before imposing any measure — its absence in the case weakens the employer's position in a dispute.
Disciplinary liability: how a sanction differs from other measures of influence
The answer is short: disciplinary liability arises for a breach of employment duties, and its consequence is one of the sanctions named in the Labour Code of the RK. Other measures of influence are not part of this list, although in practice they are confused. The difference matters: only a sanction entails legal consequences for the employee; the other measures do not.
Measures of disciplinary influence — for example, a verbal conversation or discussion at a meeting. Deprivation of a bonus is also not a sanction: a bonus is part of the remuneration system, and its absence is explained by failure to meet the bonus conditions. Such measures do not entail records of a sanction and do not affect the employee's future.
- Disciplinary sanction: remark, reprimand, severe reprimand, termination of the employment contract at the employer's initiative.
- Measures of disciplinary influence: conversation, verbal reminder of the rules, discussion of the case at a meeting.
- Deprivation of a bonus: relates to the terms of remuneration, not to sanctions, if the bonus was not awarded under the established criteria.
- Material liability: compensation for damage under labour law, not a response to a disciplinary offence.
- Administrative liability: applied by state bodies under the Code of Administrative Offences.
A practical guideline for the HR service: before drawing up documents, determine what exactly you are applying — a sanction or another measure. This determines both the set of procedures and the list of documents that will have to be prepared.
Procedure for Applying a Disciplinary Sanction: A Step-by-Step Algorithm for the Employer
The procedure for applying a disciplinary sanction under the Labor Code of the RK is built on documenting every step: from recording the violation to having the employee acknowledge the order. Skipping any stage weakens the employer's position in a dispute. Bonafacto lawyers advise collecting documents as events unfold rather than reconstructing them after the fact.
A disciplinary sanction is imposed only after the employer has requested a written explanation from the employee. The employee is given time to prepare; a refusal is formalized by an act. Then the validity of the reasons is assessed: illness, childcare, an accident, other circumstances. Whether there are grounds for an order depends on this assessment — if the reasons are valid, no punishment is applied. Bonafacto emphasizes: the conclusion on validity must be recorded in writing, otherwise it remains an unsupported opinion.
If the documents have been collected with gaps — no act of refusal, no explanation requested, the reason for the omission not described — it is better not to issue the order, but first to close the gap. The missing document is drawn up as of the fact, with the date and signatures of those present. An order issued retroactively will not fix a skipped stage.
- Step 1. Record the violation: a manager's memo, an act, an internal investigation
- Step 2. Request a written explanation; formalize a refusal by an act
- Step 3. Assess the validity of the reasons and record the conclusion in writing
- Step 4. Issue an order on applying the disciplinary sanction, stating its type and grounds
- Step 5. Have the employee acknowledge the order against signature; record a refusal by an act
Explanatory note in disciplinary action: how to properly request it and what to do if refused
Before applying a disciplinary sanction, the employer is obliged to request a written explanation from the employee — a document in which the employee sets out their view of the misconduct and its causes. The request is made in writing: a verbal suggestion to "explain yourself" has no evidentiary force. The request specifies exactly what the employee is being accused of and by what deadline a response is expected.
The explanation is submitted within the period specified in the request; the count starts from the day following the day of delivery against signature or dispatch by registered mail with notification. Failure to submit an explanation does not prevent the application of a sanction, but is recorded by an act.
The employee's refusal to sign the request does not halt the procedure: delivery is confirmed by an act drawn up in the presence of witnesses — it states the date, time and substance of the refusal. Such an act, together with the text of the request and proof of dispatch, settles the question of whether the employee was notified. If the employee refuses both to receive the request and to sign the act, the document is sent by registered mail with notification — the receipt and the inventory become evidence of dispatch.
A sanction imposed without a written explanation from the employee or outside the deadline is almost always overturned in court. Here the procedure matters more than the severity of the punishment. Dulat Abenov
Time limits for disciplinary sanctions: when punishment is no longer permissible
The Labor Code of the RK limits the employer in time by two periods: a short one — from the day the misconduct is discovered, and an ultimate one — from the day it was committed. The day of discovery is best confirmed by a document — a memo, a report, the result of an inspection: it is from this date that it is later calculated whether the employer stayed within the allotted period.
Once the period has expired, a belated sanction cannot be imposed, even if guilt is confirmed. For misconduct identified as a result of an audit, an inspection of financial and economic activity, or an audit, the law establishes a longer period: it is counted from the date the measure is completed. A continuing misconduct (for example, a report not submitted on time, which the employee continues not to submit) is treated not as a one-time event but as an ongoing violation — then the period is counted from the moment such behavior ceased or was stopped, and not from the first day.
- Two periods: the imposition of a sanction is limited both by the day the misconduct is discovered and by the day it was committed.
- Day of discovery: the date of documentary recording of the violation — a memo, a report, the results of an inspection.
- Illness and leave: the time of the employee's illness and leave is not counted in the period; during these periods the sanction is not applied.
- Duration: the duration of the sanction is limited by the LC of the RK; if there is no new sanction during this time, the employee is considered to have no sanction.
- Early removal: possible at the initiative of the employer, at the request of the employee, or on the petition of the manager.
- Continuing misconduct: the period is counted from the cessation of the violation or its being stopped, and not from the first episode.
Practical advice: record the date of discovery on the same day you learn of the violation — explaining it retroactively in a dispute is harder than drawing up a memo right away.
How an employer can stay within the deadline: a working checklist
The deadline cannot be met if the procedure is carried out "from memory": each stage must leave a document with a date. Keep a short sequence at hand — it helps not to lose days between the discovery of the violation and the order.
- Record the fact: a memo from the immediate supervisor or a report on the violation — with the date, place, and substance of the misconduct.
- Request an explanation: in writing, against signature or by registered mail with notification; refusal to be recorded by a report.
- Assess the reasons: illness, childcare, an accident, other circumstances — the validity is checked before the order, not after.
- Match the type of sanction to the severity: remark, reprimand, severe reprimand, termination of the contract — only from the list in the code.
- Issue the order: describing the misconduct, the date of detection, with reference to supporting documents and to the norm of the code.
- Familiarize the employee: against signature; refusal — again by a report.
The weak point in this chain is the gap between documents: if the report is drawn up later than the order or the explanation is requested "for show," the dates stop confirming the sequence. Check the chronology of the papers before signing the order — it is cheaper than disputing the cancellation of a sanction.
Order on disciplinary sanction: content, form, and employee acknowledgment
An order on disciplinary sanction is a written act of the employer that records to whom and for what a measure has been applied. The basis for it is documents confirming the fact and circumstances of the misconduct: a report or official memo from the manager, an act on refusal to provide an explanation, an act on the results of an official investigation, the employee's written explanation, or an act on its non-submission. The type of measure must correspond to the severity of the misconduct and the list in the Labor Code of the RK: remark, reprimand, severe reprimand, termination of the employment contract at the employer's initiative.
The sample order includes information about the employee, a description of the misconduct and the date it was identified, a reference to the supporting documents and the provision of the Labor Code of the RK, the type of sanction, the date of preparation and registration number, and the position and details of the person who issued the document. Usually the details are listed in the following order:
- name of the employer and details of the order (date, number);
- employee details: last name, first name, patronymic, position, structural unit;
- description of the disciplinary misconduct indicating the time and circumstances;
- reference to the documents confirming the misconduct and to the employee's written explanation;
- the provision of the Labor Code of the RK on the basis of which the sanction was applied;
- type of sanction and signature of the authorized person who issued the order.
The employee is acknowledged with the order against signature; if they refuse or are unable to acknowledge it, an act is drawn up to that effect — such a document confirms that the procedure was followed. A copy of the order is given to the employee, and the refusal to sign does not cancel the applied measure. Practical advice: record the date and time of acknowledgment directly in the order or in a separate act — this will be useful if the employee challenges the sanction.
What to check before signing the order
An order is issued only after all materials have been collected: without them, the document loses its evidentiary basis. Go through the chain of documents and make sure that each step is documented.
- Fact of violation: there is a report or official memo or an act on the violation drawn up by an authorized person and signed by several employees.
- Request for explanation: the request is made in writing, delivered against signature or sent by mail with notification; refusal or non-receipt is documented by an act.
- Assessment of reasons: the order or a separate statement shows why the reasons were found to be unjustified — otherwise it will be difficult to justify that the measure corresponds to the severity of the misconduct.
- Deadlines: at the time the order is issued, the period allowed by the Labor Code of the RK for imposing a sanction has not expired.
- Single version of events: dates, times, and wording in the report, act, and order match; discrepancies between them are a typical mistake that causes the document to lose weight.
Separately check that the order contains nothing extra: evaluative characteristics of the employee, references to oral agreements, or grounds that are not in the code. A nuance that is often forgotten: an order is not the place for "educational" wording; it should read as a dry record of the misconduct, the documents, and the provision.
Recording a violation: what evidence protects the employer in a dispute
Evidence of the misconduct is collected before the penalty order: without it, the employer has nothing to confirm either the fact of the violation or compliance with the procedure. Recording is done for each incident separately, indicating the date, place and substance of the violation. The materials are added to the personal file — this makes them easier to present during an inspection and in court.
The main document is the disciplinary violation report: it is drawn up by an authorized person and signed by several employees. If the violation was identified by the immediate supervisor, a memo is prepared addressed to the first executive — facts without conclusions about guilt: what happened, when, who was present, which documents confirm it. The executive's resolution on the memo initiates a review of the circumstances.
- Violation reports: drawn up by several employees, with the date and signatures.
- Memos and internal notes: record the fact, time and circumstances of the misconduct.
- The employee's written explanations: or a report on refusal to provide them.
- Witness statements: confirm what they personally saw.
- Reports, logs and documents on work results: show deviation from the plan or norm.
- Materials of inspections, audits and internal investigations: final conclusions on the incident.
The weak point is documents drawn up retroactively or without signatures: they confirm neither the event nor the timelines. Bonafacto lawyers advise collecting materials on the day the violation is identified and keeping them together with the order. Check in advance that each document answers the question "who, when, and exactly what was violated".
Disciplinary sanction and dismissal: when termination of the contract will be lawful
Termination of an employment contract at the employer's initiative is a separate measure of liability, named in the Labour Code of the RK alongside a remark, a reprimand and a severe reprimand. It can be applied only if there is a ground established in the code and with compliance with the procedure.
Here it is important to distinguish between two different situations. The first is dismissal where a sanction remains in force: the employee has already been held liable, the sanction has not been lifted or extinguished, and he has again violated his employment duties. The second is single-instance grounds: to terminate the contract, one offence from the list below is sufficient; a prior sanction is not required.
- Repeated failure to perform duties: the employee has again violated employment duties while having an unlifted or unextinguished sanction
- Absenteeism: absence from work without a valid reason for three or more consecutive hours during one working day (shift)
- Intoxication: appearing at work in a state of alcoholic, narcotic or other intoxication
- Disclosure of secrets: a secret protected by law that became known to the employee through work has been disclosed
- Theft or intentional damage: property at the place of work, the fact established by a judgment or ruling that has entered into force
- Occupational safety violation: resulted in grave consequences or created a threat of their occurrence
Before issuing the order, Bonafacto lawyers advise checking that the ground is confirmed by documents and the procedure has been followed: an explanation has been requested, the deadlines have been met, and the employee has been familiarised with the order. An error at any of these steps turns a lawful dismissal into a disputable one.
Appealing a disciplinary sanction by an employee and the employer's position in the dispute
An employee who disagrees with the imposed sanction first applies to the conciliation commission, if one has been established at the employer, and if disagreeing with its decision or if no commission exists — to the court with a claim to declare the order unlawful. In parallel, a complaint may be filed with the local labour inspection authority. The deadlines for applying to the court in labour disputes are established by the Labour Code of the RK; missing them without a valid reason results in dismissal of the claim.
It is important for the employer to confirm that a written explanation was requested from the employee before the sanction was imposed. The absence of an explanation or the drawing up of a refusal report in violation of the procedure deprives the sanction of evidentiary force. In addition to the fact of the misconduct itself, the court verifies compliance with the procedure, the proportionality of the chosen measure to the severity of the violation, and consideration of the employee's prior conduct. Bonafacto lawyers build the employer's position from documents that confirm each step of the procedure — without them, even a proven misconduct does not save the order.
- Explanation: the employee's written explanation or a report of refusal to provide one
- Memorandum: a note from the immediate supervisor about the misconduct
- Investigation: an internal investigation report stating the date, place and circumstances of the violation
- Order: the document imposing the sanction with the employee's acknowledgement or a report of refusal to acknowledge
- Local acts: the internal labour regulations and job description whose violation is alleged
- Proportionality: documents on previous incentives and sanctions to assess the measure
Typical employer mistakes in disciplinary penalties and their consequences
Mistakes in disciplinary penalties relate to procedure, not to the substance of the misconduct. The employer has the right to apply a remark, a reprimand, a severe reprimand, or to terminate the employment contract, but only within this list and in compliance with the procedure. A violation of the procedure turns a formally correct decision into an unlawful one. In a labor dispute, the court examines not only the fact of the misconduct but also how the employer recorded it and explained it to the employee.
The absence of a written explanation or the employee's refusal to provide one without drawing up a statement deprives the employer of evidence. Missing the deadline within which a penalty may be applied in itself makes the measure unlawful. A punishment without written documentation of the misconduct and without the employee's acknowledgment of the order has no legal force. A penalty outside the list established by the Labor Code of the RK is impermissible. Applying a measure to an employee whose guilt has not been established results in the cancellation of the order and compensation. At the stage of reviewing documents, Bonafacto lawyers check whether the case file contains a statement of refusal to explain and the employee's signature on the order — without them, the position in a dispute weakens.
- no written explanation from the employee or statement of refusal to explain;
- the penalty was applied after the established deadline;
- the misconduct was not documented before the order was issued;
- the measure is not among those provided for by the Labor Code of the RK;
- the penalty was applied to an employee whose guilt has not been proven;
- the employee has not been acquainted with the order against signature.
| Mistake | Consequence in a labor dispute |
|---|---|
| No explanation or statement of refusal | The order is cancelled as unlawful |
| Deadline for applying the penalty missed | The penalty is recognized as invalid |
| Misconduct not documented | No evidence for the court |
| Measure outside the list of the Labor Code of the RK | The penalty has no force |
| Employee's guilt not proven | Reinstatement and compensation |
List of penalties under the Labor Code of the RK: remark, reprimand, severe reprimand, termination of the employment contract at the employer's initiative.
How to structure the document review before issuing an order
It is convenient to conduct the review chronologically: from the moment the violation is detected to the employee's signature on the order. This makes it clear at which step the procedure failed and whether it can be remedied before the document is issued. If the gap cannot be remedied, it is more reasonable to choose a milder measure than to insist on a severe one.
- Date of detection: confirmed by a memo, statement, or inspection result, not by an oral report.
- Fact of misconduct: described by date, place, and substance of the violation, separately from conclusions about guilt.
- Request for explanation: delivered against signature or sent by mail with acknowledgment of receipt.
- Refusal to explain: documented by a statement signed by several employees.
- Proportionality: the type of penalty is correlated with the severity of the misconduct and the employee's previous conduct.
- Acknowledgment: the employee's signature on the order or a statement of refusal to acknowledge it.
A separate trap is the mixing of procedures: a disciplinary penalty does not substitute for the deprivation of a bonus and does not replace compensation for damage. Each ground is documented with its own set of documents; otherwise, in a dispute, it is difficult for the employer to explain exactly what the measure was applied for.
Conclusion
The measure of liability under the Labor Code of the RK rests not on severity but on procedure: the list of disciplinary sanctions is closed, and the employer has no right to expand it. A remark, a reprimand, a severe reprimand and termination of the employment contract are applied only after the employee's written explanation, and evidence of the misconduct is collected before the order is issued — not after.
Time limits work against the employer: a missed period for imposing a sanction deprives the order of force, so dates are recorded from the first day on which the violation became known. Documents, explanations and acknowledgment of the order are best formalized immediately, while the event is fresh in the participants' memory.
- Check the basis: whether the misconduct falls under the sanctions named in the code.
- Collect evidence and the explanation before the order, not retroactively.
- Verify the time limits — otherwise the penalty is no longer permissible.
Practical advice: keep a separate folder with dates for each violation — it will be useful both in a dispute and during an inspection.