Intellectual property
Work made for hire: how to secure rights for the employer
A work made for hire is a result created by an employee within the scope of their employment duties on the employer's assignment, and the economic rights to it, as a general rule, belong to the employer. For the rights to actually transfer, the terms must be set out in the employment contract or the assignment.
An entrepreneur orders a website, logo, or article from an in-house employee and later discovers that they cannot dispose of the result: the parties' relationship has not been formalized. A private client who hires a designer or programmer under a contract faces the same issue — the work has been delivered, but the rights remain with the author.
Below — what to secure in the employment contract and the assignment, how to formalize the transfer of rights, what happens after the author's dismissal, and which documents protect your position in a dispute.
What a work made for hire is and when it arises
Such a result appears when an employee creates a copyright-protected object within the scope of their employment duties. It is the product of creative labour created under an employment contract, a job description or another local act of the employer. These relations are governed by the Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights", which determines who owns the personal non-property and property rights. What distinguishes it from an ordinary work is the basis on which it arises: not the author's free creative intent, but the performance of assigned work.
The employee's occupation — designer, programmer, journalist, engineer — does not matter; what matters is whether creating the object fell within their duties. If an employee wrote a text outside their employment function and without an assignment from the employer, the work is not recognised as a work made for hire, and the rights remain with the author. Therefore, the first step is to analyse the employment contract, the job description and the work assignments.
- the result was created by an employee in an employment relationship with the employer
- its creation fell within the employee's employment duties or was carried out under a specific assignment
- the object is creative and protected by copyright
- the work was created during the term of the employment contract
- the terms and procedure for allocating rights are set out in the employment contract or a separate agreement
Employment Contract and Work-for-Hire Work: What the Document Must Contain
The obligation to create a work-for-hire work is fixed in the employment contract through a description of the job function: the section on duties states that the employee creates specific types of works within the scope of the position. The wording must correspond to the job description, which details the tasks, the result, and the handover procedure. If the job function is described in general terms and the work arose outside of it, it is difficult for the employer to prove the work-for-hire nature.
The contract's terms on the work-for-hire work are effective when the types of objects created, the moment of transfer of economic rights, and the scope of the rights transferred are expressly named. A general clause stating that all rights belong to the employer without specifying the objects creates a dispute over whether it covers the work actually created. Under the Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights," economic rights to a work-for-hire work belong to the employer unless otherwise provided by the contract between the employer and the author, so any deviation from this rule must be expressed clearly.
- Types of works: specify in the employment contract which objects are created within the scope of the position.
- Job description: duplicate the obligation to create with a description of the result and the handover procedure.
- Moment of transfer of rights: establish when economic rights transfer and in what scope.
- Work-for-hire assignments: set out the procedure for issuing assignments and accepting the created objects.
- Personal non-economic rights: determine whether they remain with the employee and how they are exercised.
- List of objects: avoid a general clause on the ownership of all rights without a list.
Work made for hire outside an employment contract: civil-law contract and assignment
A result created by an employee within the scope of their employment duties qualifies as a work made for hire. If the author is engaged under a civil-law contract , the "work made for hire" construct under the RK Law "On Copyright and Related Rights" does not apply directly: the parties are the customer and the contractor, not the employer and the employee.
It is possible to secure rights to the result under a civil-law contract, but this is no longer a result created within the scope of employment duties, and expressly stated terms on rights are required. Without them, the exclusive right remains with the author-contractor, and the customer receives only a right of use, if expressly provided for. A contract for work or for paid services must contain provisions on copyright, and the customer's assignment must specify the result. It is worth checking the wording before signing: rewriting the terms after the result has been delivered is harder than agreeing on them at the outset.
- Subject matter: a description of the result to be created and the requirements for it;
- Rights: a statement that the exclusive right transfers to the customer or that a right of use is granted;
- Timing: when the customer's rights arise — from the date the result is delivered or the acceptance certificate is signed;
- Moral rights: a provision on the author's non-property rights, which are not alienable;
- Assignment: the procedure for the customer to issue it and for the author to record its performance;
- Liability: the consequences of breaching the terms on rights to the created result.
Who Owns the Rights to a Work Made for Hire
Economic rights are, as a general rule, vested in the employer, while moral rights remain with the author. The Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights" classifies as works made for hire those created in the performance of employment duties or an employer's assignment. The distribution of economic rights may be changed by contract — this is the only part the parties are entitled to rewrite.
Moral rights do not pass to the employer under any circumstances and cannot be the subject of a contract: authorship, the right to a name, protection of reputation, and publication. The company may not designate itself as the creator, distort the text, or publish it against the author's will without sufficient grounds. They are protected indefinitely and survive termination of employment.
Practical consequence: the contract should expressly state which economic rights the company receives and for what term; otherwise, a dispute over a specific manner of use will have to be resolved without reliance on the document.
Work-for-hire work and author's remuneration to the employee
Remuneration for a result created in the course of performing employment duties is a separate payment that does not replace salary. Personal non-property rights remain with the employee, while property rights pass to the employer unless otherwise provided by the contract; the basis is the Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights".
The employee is entitled to demand payment if the company uses the result in ways that were not part of their employment duties, or receives income from the use. The amount and procedure for payments are determined by the contract between the author and the employer — without written fixation of these terms, there is nothing to rely on when disputing the amount.
- Calculation base: remuneration is calculated from the use of the result or from income derived from it — as fixed in the contract.
- Scope of duties: use beyond the employment function is an independent ground for payment.
- Where the term belongs: the amount and procedure of payment are fixed in the employment contract or in a separate agreement.
- Consequence of a gap: without a remuneration term, the employee has no agreed amount or procedure for receiving it.
A work-for-hire work does not need to be re-executed with a separate contract each time — it is sufficient that the assignment and the author's employment duties are recorded in writing before the work begins. Aizhana Medetova
Work-made-for-hire works: types of results that qualify
The list of types depends on the employee's job function: a result becomes a work-made-for-hire work if it is created within the scope of duties or under the employer's assignment. The RK Law on Copyright classifies as work-made-for-hire works those created in the performance of job duties or an employer's assignment. Economic rights belong to the employer unless the contract provides otherwise; personal non-economic rights (authorship, name, protection of reputation) remain with the employee.
A result of labor within an employment relationship is not only text: images, code, design, audio and video also fall into this category. An article with photographs combines text and images, which may have different authors, so the rights to them are delineated separately. Software requires recording of stages, versions and libraries; design covers layouts, logos, interfaces, and corporate identity. Audio and video are harder to confirm as work-made-for-hire works due to co-authorship and third-party equipment — here it is especially important who made the recording and on whose equipment.
| Type of result | What is created | Main difficulty of formalization |
|---|---|---|
| Texts | Articles, reports, instructions, advertising materials | Proving a work assignment rather than initiative work |
| Images | Photos, illustrations, graphics | Distinguishing work-related shooting from the author's personal materials |
| Audio and video | Clips, podcasts, recordings | Co-authorship and involvement of engaged persons |
| Software code | Programs, modules, scripts | Recording of versions and third-party components |
| Design | Layouts, logos, interfaces | Co-authorship and use of third-party elements |
For each type, the work-made-for-hire regime is confirmed by the author's job duties and the terms of the contract with the employer.
Mixed result: how to delineate the contribution to a single object
A mixed result is an object that combines parts of different nature, and it must be formalized part by part, not by a single general act. A website, clip or presentation is made up of text, images, code and design, and each part may have its own author and its own basis for the emergence of rights. The assignment lists the constituent elements separately, and the acceptance act records what exactly was delivered and by whom it was created.
- Assignment: list the elements of the result as separate items, not as a single line "develop a website".
- Engaged persons: specify whom the employee may engage and on what basis their rights are formalized.
- Third-party materials: note which libraries, photos and fonts are used and on what right.
- Acceptance act: list the delivered parts and confirm that each was created within the scope of duties.
The weak point here is oral agreements with contractors: without written fixation of rights to a separate element, the employer receives an object part of which does not belong to them. Check the completeness of rights before signing the act, not after the project launch.
Work-for-hire work: how to formalize the transfer of rights in practice
The transfer of rights begins before the employee sits down to work: they are given a written assignment describing the result and the scope of use. The assignment is signed by the manager, and the employee confirms that they have read it — such a document shows that the work is created within the scope of employment duties, and not on personal initiative.
The procedure is as follows. First, the parties sign an acceptance and transfer act: it records the date of creation, the name of the work and its suitability for use. Then an order is issued securing the rights for the employer. And only after that does it make sense to talk about an additional agreement — it is needed if the rights go beyond the scope of the assignment or the work was created beyond the employment function. Such an agreement is drawn up under the Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights", specifying the scope of rights and the moment of transfer.
Documents that should be collected in one folder for each work:
- an assignment to create the work with the employee's signature
- an acceptance and transfer act for the work-for-hire work
- an order securing the rights for the employer
- an author's agreement on the transfer of exclusive or non-exclusive rights, if required
- fixation materials: source files, deposit, inspection
- a logbook or register of work-for-hire works
Bonafacto lawyers advise not to postpone signing the assignment until the result is delivered: a document drawn up retroactively is weaker than one signed at the start. Check that the assignment describes the result itself, not the process — otherwise the connection between the work and the employment function will have to be proven with other materials.
What to verify in the acceptance act and the order
The acceptance and transfer act and the order securing the rights are not a formality, but documents that later determine the boundaries of what has been transferred. In the act, it is important to name the work so that it cannot be confused with another result by the same employee: not "a layout", but a specific name indicating what the work consists of. The order records who the property rights are secured for and for which work — an order without a link to the act blurs the connection between the created result and the employer's decision.
Separately, it is checked that the assignment, the act and the order describe the same work: a discrepancy in the name or composition of the result gives grounds to dispute that the rights were transferred specifically to what is being used. If the work contains third-party components — someone else's libraries, fonts, images — this is reflected in the act or an annex to it, otherwise a dispute about co-authorship and third-party elements passes to the employer.
- Name: the work is named so that it can be unambiguously identified among the employee's other works.
- Composition: the parts of the result are listed, including text, images, code or layouts, if the work consists of them.
- Suitability: the act notes that the result is ready for use for its intended purpose.
- Link between documents: the assignment, the act and the order refer to one work and do not diverge in their description.
- Third-party elements: third-party components and engaged persons are indicated so that the rights to them are not mixed with the rights to the work itself.
A practical tip: keep the assignment, the act and the order together with the source files — in a dispute, it is precisely this set that shows that the work was created on instruction and that the rights to it are secured for the employer, and did not remain with the author.
Work made for hire: is a separate rights transfer agreement needed
A separate agreement is not mandatory: by law, the economic rights to a result created in the course of employment duties belong to the employer. However, an agreement with the author fixes the scope of rights, the remuneration and the terms of use — and removes any dispute over whether creating the result fell within the employment duties. Bonafacto lawyers advise against relying on a single wording in the employment contract: the more precisely the result is described, the easier it is to prove ownership of the rights.
Without a separate document, the employer relies on the work-made-for-hire regime, while the author relies on the personal nature of the result. Ownership of rights then has to be confirmed by circumstantial evidence. This weakens the company's position when defending against infringers and in transactions with third parties.
Before signing, check that the document:
- specifies the particular work, rather than the employee's type of activity
- defines the moment when the exclusive rights transfer
- secures the rights to process the work and to use it as part of other objects
- provides for the author's right to remuneration, if it is not included in the salary
- governs the use of the work after the author's dismissal
Work made for hire and the author's dismissal: what happens to the rights
The dismissal of the author does not terminate the employer's rights to such a work. After the employment contract is terminated, the company continues to use the result and dispose of it, while respecting the creator's personal non-property rights. A dispute arises when the employment contract, job description or a separate act does not record the obligation to create the work and its transfer to the employer: in that case, the dismissed author claims the work was done outside their employment duties and challenges the ownership of the rights.
What remains and what changes after parting ways with the author:
- Property rights: remain with the employer even after the author's dismissal.
- Personal non-property rights: are perpetual and non-transferable.
- Confirmation of the work-for-hire nature: the employment contract, job description or a separate act.
- A work created outside employment duties: cannot be used without the author's consent.
- Reproduction and transfer of rights to third parties: are possible without the former employee's new consent; modification — subject to the author's right to the integrity of the work.
- The author's name: attribution is retained unless the author has waived it in the prescribed manner.
Practical tip: when hiring, record in the documents not only the obligation to create the result, but also the moment of its transfer — this closes off the former employee's main argument in a dispute.
Work-for-hire work: common documentation mistakes
Disputes arise from careless paperwork. Economic rights belong to the employer unless the contract provides otherwise, but this rule works only when the status of the work is confirmed. If the employment contract, job description and assignment do not describe the creative nature of the work, the author will prove that they created the object outside their employment duties. Bonafacto lawyers advise checking the documents before the project starts, not after a conflict.
A typical set of mistakes: a vague wording "participates in creating content" instead of specific types of objects, failure to record the handover of the copy and source files, and signing the acceptance act with a backdate. A separate risk area is the use of personal equipment, USB drives and cloud accounts without written approval. The risks increase when the employee concurrently registers the object in their own name or passes similar material to third parties.
- The employment contract does not specify the creation of specific types of works — the link between the object and the employment function is not confirmed.
- The assignment was given orally, without recording the deadlines, scope and requirements for the result.
- The handover of source files, drafts and access credentials is not documented by an act or inventory.
- The employee creates the object on personal equipment and in personal accounts without written approval.
- The contract has no provision on rights to an object created outside working hours or beyond the scope of the assignment.
- Use of the object begins before the document on ownership of economic rights is signed.
Work-for-hire work: documents and evidence for protecting rights
Ownership of rights to an object created by an employee within the scope of their duties is confirmed by a combination of HR and creative documents. The Law of the RK "On Copyright and Related Rights" assigns economic rights to the employer, unless otherwise provided by an agreement with the author.
The basis is the employment contract, job description, work assignment, and the acceptance certificate for the result. Evidence is strengthened by documenting the creative process: drafts, working files, correspondence regarding the assignment, date of publication. If documentation is weak, a dispute arises as to whether the creation of the object fell within the employee's duties — Bonafacto lawyers advise assembling this set of documents at the stage of issuing the assignment.
- employment contract describing the job function
- job description or list of duties
- work assignment specifying the object being created
- acceptance certificate for the work result
- working materials: drafts, files, correspondence
- documents on publication or transfer of the object to third parties
| Situation | Key document | Additionally | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|
| Object created under an assignment | Employment contract and work assignment | Job description | Creation within the scope of duties |
| Object created under an assignment | Acceptance certificate | Working files and drafts | Fact of delivery of the result |
| Commissioned work | Commission agreement | Technical specification and certificate | Scope of rights under the agreement |
| Authorship dispute | Date and method of publication | Correspondence between the parties | Priority and authorship |
The set of documents depends on the type of object and the terms of the agreement; transfer of rights to third parties is formalized by a separate copyright agreement.
Work Made for Hire: Step-by-Step Procedure for Formalizing Rights
The procedure begins with a review of documents and ends with recording the object in the register — without skipping any steps. First, the employment contract and job description are reviewed: whether they describe a creative function and the duty to create a result. If the wording is vague, it is clarified before the project starts — proving the work-for-hire nature after the fact is more difficult.
Next, a written assignment is issued before work begins: what exactly is being created, in what scope, and by when. The progress of the work is documented with drafts, correspondence, and saved file versions — this confirms that the result arose within the scope of the assignment and not on personal initiative. At Bonafacto, the cost of the stage is fixed in the contract before work begins, and the same principle helps in formalization: the terms are clear in advance.
- Document review: the employment contract and job description contain a creative function
- Assignment: a written assignment is issued before work begins
- Recording progress: drafts, correspondence, and file versions are saved
- Acceptance: an act stating the name of the object and the date
- Consolidation: an order on rights to the result
- Going beyond the scope: a separate contract if the work is broader than the assignment
- Record-keeping: a log or register of works made for hire
The result is accepted by an act stating the name of the object and the date, then an order is issued consolidating the rights. If the work went beyond the scope of the assignment, a separate contract is drawn up, and all objects are entered in a log or register — this makes it easier to prove ownership of rights in a dispute.
Work made for hire and co-authorship: third-party components and engaged persons
Co-authorship risk arises where the result is assembled from third-party elements or with the involvement of people outside the staff. Audio, video, design and code include third-party components: libraries, fonts, stock images, equipment, as well as the work of engaged contractors. Formally, such an object remains a single result, but the rights to its individual parts belong to different persons — and this must be taken into account before the result goes to the client or into the product.
The first step is to record the list of third-party components and their rights holders: what exactly was used, on what basis, and what terms of use accompany it. The second is to formalize relations with engaged contractors through separate agreements that specify the scope of work and the fate of the rights to what is created. The third is to separate the author's personal archive from materials created under assignment: drafts, source files, personal notes and footage "for oneself" must not be mixed with working files.
- Component register: keep records of the libraries, fonts, stock assets and equipment used, indicating the rights holder
- Agreements with contractors: formalize them separately from employment documents, with a description of the rights being transferred
- Archive boundary: separate the author's personal materials from those created under assignment
Practical advice: collect supporting documents for components at the same time as acceptance of the result — it is harder to reconstruct the chain later. If the composition of third-party elements is unclear, clarify it with the author before signing the acceptance certificate.
Work made for hire: checklist for accepting an employee's deliverable
Accepting a deliverable from an employee comes down to a sequence of documents: the assignment before work begins, the acceptance act upon its completion, and an inventory of the materials transferred. The assignment is signed in advance — otherwise it is unclear whether the author acted within the scope of their duties. The act states the date, the name of the object, and its suitability for use. Bonafacto lawyers first study the documents and only then assess the prospects.
- Assignment: signed before work begins, with a description of the result
- Act: date, name of the object, suitability for use
- Materials: source files, drafts, and access credentials transferred under an inventory
- Working conditions: recorded on which equipment and in which accounts the work was performed
- Verification: confirmed whether the object was concurrently registered to the author
- Start of use: does not begin until the rights document is signed
The inventory of materials and the recording of equipment close off any dispute over whose resources the object was created with. Use before the rights document is signed leaves the employer without a confirmed basis — paperwork first, launch after.
What Ultimately Protects the Employer
What protects the employer is not the job title, but the combination of documents: job duties, a written assignment, and an acceptance document recording the rights. These three pillars work together — if one falls away, the official (work-for-hire) nature of the result becomes disputable.
Personal non-property rights — authorship, the right to a name, protection of reputation — always remain with the employee and cannot be transferred. Property rights remain with the employer even after the author's dismissal, provided the work-for-hire nature of creating the result is recorded in the documents.
Paperwork is done before work begins, not after a dispute: reconstructing an assignment and its terms retroactively is harder than signing them in advance.